5 ms·
Can anyone give a reason in darwinian terms, for why brains would evolve a feeling of detachment and contentment near death? I can't project a selfish-gene reas
by ggm 8y ago
Can anyone give a reason in darwinian terms, for why brains would evolve a feeling of detachment and contentment near death? I can't project a selfish-gene reason.
Maybe, if you hypothesise its in the 'I die, so others live' space, its like altruistic behaviour and favours the group genome, not the individual
- mjg59 8y agoUnless it has an impact on your ability to reproduce, there's no reason at all. Lots of biology is just a consequence of implementation details.
- Vadoff 8y agoThat's not entirely true. If it impacts your direct descendents or even distant relatives, there'll still be an impact assuming you share the genes in question.
- bigiain 8y agoIf you consider taking a role of "grandparenting" to be a potentially positive role in "your ability to reproduce", then both you and mjg59 are kind of agreeing there.
- d33 8y agoYou don't have to copulate in order to express "your ability to reproduce". Keep in mind that your family also has your genes so if you just provide resources for them to reproduce, a part of you reproduces as well. This could be a mechanism to combat fear of death, which perhaps was making people less likely to have sex?
- drak0n1c 8y agoSometimes there is no reason. That might just be symptoms of gradual neuronal failure. It’s unlikely that the sensation of dying significantly increases or decreases the likelihood of passing on one’s lineage, except maybe imparting a peaceful impression on family around you.
- ggm 8y agoA lot of the folk-lore "there is no reason" stuff, turns out to be less clear. Appendix has a function in prior lineage, its remnant. Tonsils? well.. turns out kids who have 'em removed suffer life long consequence. So whilst I too am tempted to the 'there is no reason, its just happenstance' it worries me that an awful lot of things about the body, turn out to be less happenstance than we thought. Like.. altriusm or even the discovery gay behaviour is normal in lots of species. Arguing 'its just coincidence' feels pretty weak. But the bleak argument might work. Keep the young 'uns motivated to breed, it helps in the long term. We're a long time dead. "Enjoy yourself, its later than you think"
- jamesrcole 8y agoFor their to be an evolutionary reason for it, it has to increase fitness in some fashion. Roughly speaking, it has to increase the chances of propagating your genes. It seems very unlikely that the character of "near death experiences" could have an impact upon fitness. Saying that something doesn't have an evolutionary reason is not the same as saying it's just coincidence. Our bodies (including our brains) are very complex interconnected processes. There's going to be all sorts of effects when those processes break down, and even if those don't have an evolutionary purpose, that doesn't mean they're just coincidence. This is a factual matter, which has nothing to do with an argument being bleak or not.
- westoncb 8y agoIt could be social. Imagine the family surrounding the deathbed of an elder, dying relative. It's probably the case that the relative is observed closely while 'crossing over,' and depending on the relatives' interpretation of what's happening to their dying loved one, they may be left at peace or in turmoil. So maybe DMT has to do with creating the desired appearance to communicate to loved ones at the deathbed.
- mirimir 8y agoThe standard cocktail was morphine, cocaine and ethanol. Now they usually just do "inadvertent" opioid overdoses.
- TaupeRanger 8y agoWell we don't really understand the nature of "feelings", so the answers are going to be very speculative. But a better question might be: why do we feel contentment at all? Why isn't it all just fear and rage all the time, with certain things lessening the fear and rage, like eating, pooping, and copulating? After all, if we avoid death and reproduce, the genes get passed on - evolution doesn't care about feelings. This entirely sidesteps discussion about the epiphenomenalality of conscious experience and how/whether it can be "causal" in any sense.
- ggm 8y ago"I don't want to die" has a pretty strong biological determinancy to it. It helps, mostly in adverse situations. Flipping over to "meh, who needs bodies" is inexplicable (to me)
- tempestn 8y agoCould be that once you've reproduced and sufficiently cared for your offspring, it's preferable that you don't waste resources on yourself. Contentment and even apathy could be beneficial (from an evolutionary perspective) at that point.
- rangibaby 8y agoThere’s a moment where your brain switches from “fight for your life” to “I’m fucked, don’t bother trying to save me”. The I experienced when I nearly drowned once. I was very calm and ready to go. You can see it in videos of how to spot a drowning person.
- dpwm 8y agoI am an anxious person. About a decade ago I was a passenger and at one point I was within about one second of almost certain contact with a vertical box section on a very slow moving vehicle. There was no way that my friend, and inexperienced driver, could brake in time. That one second was slow and I was unnervingly calm. Right at the last minute with probably less than 200ms to go, the driver very gently swerved and we must have avoided collision by less than two inches. Quarter inch if we include wing mirrors. My friend, the driver asked later why I didn't say anything. I explained that had I panicked, he would have panicked and we would probably both be dead.
- yes_man 8y agoMaybe the human (or generally any conscious nervous system) existence is such an anxious experience that finally realizing it was all a trip that is ending is such a giant relief that the imminent death feels like a warm home? Not to sound too bleak but it would explain the contentment
- lovemenot 8y agoThat seems right. The KeepAlive muscle finally gets to relax.
- HIPisTheAnswer 8y agoDarwinism is the least likely explanation of evolution. Randomness? Take a look at how some species evolved in parallel to similar organisms; one was extremely unlikely, two or more is impossible. Darwin was quite foolish, but he had friends in the right places. Just another flat-earth belief. As for the DMT, there's only one way to find out. One grain of pure DMT in a pipe and get your answers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pymai 8y agoI have a vague recollection of someone suggesting small bits of DMT might be released while we sleep and that our dreams are like snack low key trips. Well dreams are a fairly beneficial things to have especially if you have some epiphany or figure out the solution to a problem you're having. The near death thing might just be your brain dumping that DMT out of your pineal gland all at once either when your body is shutting down from natural causes or when you are in some kind of traumatic accident.
- posterboy 8y ago> snack Can you paraphrase what that means? It's not a Freudian slip due to hunger, I hope. Asking out of prior curiosity for the word.
- jnurmine 8y agoI'm reaching, but since family units stuck together to hunt and for protection, and children were likely near their parents when death came, so perhaps it is a mechanism to avoid potentially destroying/harming (directly or indirectly) any offspring in a final flash of agony-fueled irrational violent rage. The idea is, in other words, that those who somehow went amok near death perhaps reduced their number of offspring, or damaged the family unit (e.g. destroyed their shelters or food), therefore hindering those genes from spreading, therefore the selection pressure to remove this behaviour. How do primates die?
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoWe can go the other way and this feeling of detachment and contentment might be what we evolved away from, but as our systems and cognitive functioning deteriorate we return to this state. For instance take pain. People view pain as negative but it's of course a great positive from an evolutionary point of view. Not everything (or even everybody) experiences pain, but those that do are going to be vastly more likely to succeed in life than those that don't. Your reaction to recoil from pain is not because the interaction itself is painful but because you have evolved instincts that tell you that what you're feeling is likely detrimental to your health and the situation needs to be resolved instantly, on a subconscious, level. As your pain receptors shut down it would ostensibly feel pleasant, but in reality it would just be one of the most important, and useful, evolutionary tools we have turning off.
- akvadrako 8y agoI have read recently it helps protect your brain cells from damage due to lack of oxygen. One article I can find now: http://beckleyfoundation.org/2016/09/15/the-first-study-to-show-that-dmt-protects-brain-and-immune-cells-under-stress/ http://beckleyfoundation.org/2016/09/15/the-first-study-to-s...
- Phenomenit 8y agoMy theory is that it's not so much our brain creating a feeling of detachment and Contentment but rather the brain reverting back to its initial state.
- GuB-42 8y agoYou can think of it another way: why do we feel stressed in dangerous situation and pain when we are wounded? Stress is us preparing for fight of flight, which is good for survival. Pain prevents us from further damaging our body. Stress overrides pain because your future well being doesn't matter if your die now. Now, when you are near death, when you know there is nothing you can do, stress becomes useless, because you can't flee or fight back. So there is no downside to detachment and contentment. Now the advantage may be that it may be the best response if, by chance, you survive. You don't overwork yourself, you are less likely to suffer mental breakdown afterwards, etc... Keep in mind that everyone who experienced NDEs survived, obviously. So NDEs are not death experiences, more like survival experiences.
- funkjunky 8y agoBecause life is a prison of constant struggle and suffering, the experience of ego death is that of shedding one's attachments that one struggles for, and the last chains keeping them from freedom are that of their identity, consciousness, and ultimately of life itself. The less the past, present, future, and you there is to care about, the more blissfully free whatever remains of you becomes.