10 ms·
A forgotten hero stopped the My Lai massacre 50 years ago
- maxxxxx 8y agoMost people would find it easier to just go along or look the other way. These guys were true war heroes and had courage under fire. They should be held up as examples what soldiers should be.
- chris_mc 8y agoThey are held as examples at plenty of US military officer training programs, thankfully. I learned about this incident and Hugh Thompson at the USNA, where they drilled into our heads that morals, ethics, and the laws of war are absolute and it's the officer corps job to ensure they are followed to the T. I always took that to heart. Unfortunately, as in the civilian world, there are crappy people in the officer corps that don't care much (the American GIs that Mr. Thompson was up against that day, for example).
- elboru 8y agoThat’s scary, we all like to judge others’ actions in order to feel morally superior, but what percentage of people would actually do something when they see their peers, friends, colleagues and superiors doing bad stuff? It’ll be always easier to go along and just fool yourself and say “I’m just following orders”
- rossdavidh 8y agoWe don't have to speculate as to what percentage: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 8y ago"what percentage of people would actually do something when they see their peers, friends," The history of genocides, war crimes and dictatorships clearly shows that most people will go along.
- BurningFrog 8y agoI suspect it's less about "following orders" and more about "war is hell". What would you or I do after a few months or years in hell? I for one hope never to find out.
- kungtotte 8y agoA hell you didn't sign up for, you were drafted into it. That makes for a big psychological difference I think.
- Theodores 8y agoIt is not as simple as that though. We know from war and concentration camps how many people 'just follow orders'. Briefly... In WW2 the Nazis learned from the Soviets that mass graves were a bad thing if discovered. They also knew that the Final Solution was an actual crime, the leaders acknowledged this but deemed the crime to be necessary for the survival of their own imaginably 'Aryan' race. Hence they got the Sonderkommando Jews to exhume mass graves and to build huge funeral pyres that they then used to burn the bodies. The Sonderkommando guys just followed orders until they were expected to build one final funeral pyre after all of the bodies were burned. By then they twigged that they were expected to meet their own fate that way. Only then, at the last chance, did they try to do something, e.g. try and escape or sabotage the gig. So long as there was someone in front of them in the queue these poor souls could be forced to do the unthinkable. The Germans had it all worked out, they could get people to shove their own mother into the gas chamber. They had enough bullets to make this fully possible. They could get practically anyone to participate in the criminal venture. Even if life was a misery in the concentration camp they could get people to want to stay there another day because life under such circumstances was better than being actually dead. I am certain in my own mind that everyone I have ever met in my entire life could be made into a Sonderkommando if push came to shove. This includes people in my family so quite a claim. I am also sure that everyone I have met has heard of the holocaust. Yet I do not imagine any heroics of the Schindlers List type of Hollywood movie. On the other hand, most regular soldiers do not like killing people, even if they are engaged in an 'honest war' and not a known crime. Some soldiers deliberately miss. Some go AWOL. Some play football with the enemy on Christmas Day. But then you have situations like Abu Ghraig where atrocities happen but the people involved do not believe they are committing a crime and have no fear of being found out. These people really do have a psychological problem, they are actually 'sick in the head'. However, during wartime the overwhelming majority of the population are not on the front line or anywhere near. Due to fear, propaganda and circumstance (e.g. being a parent, being too young, being too old) this bystander population passively goes along with the war, even if they do not fully subscribe to the doctrine of the day. These people have no skin in the game, they mostly support the doctrine and they don't think that far outside of what they are told to think, even if they laugh at some of the lies told to them. When the likes of MLK talk of being alone, it is these bystander folk that hurt the most.
- pessimizer 8y agoHe wasn't "forgotten", he was energetically smeared and condemned by the most right-wing, racist and nationalist elements of the government, media and US population; and all of the people who committed the massacre were acquitted but one, and that one was ordered released from jail by the POTUS during trial with his life sentence ultimately commuted to 3 1/2 years of house arrest.
- wonder_er 8y agoIt's easier to think he was forgotten, than that he was hated and attacked by his own government and country. If the latter is true, well - introspection is hard, and this is getting uncomfortable, so I guess I'll go check Twitter.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- apo 8y agoHigh point: Thompson told the American troops that, if they opened fire on the Vietnamese civilians in the bunker, he and his crew would open fire on them. Talk about courage. Low point: He concluded — after a decade of research in Pentagon archives and more than 100 interviews with American veterans and Vietnamese survivors — that Americans killing civilians in Vietnam was “pervasive and systematic.” One soldier told him there had been "a My Lai a month." Courage seems far too scarce a commodity.
- everybodyknows 8y agoHis crew apparently deserve some credit also. From Wikipedia: >Colburn and Andreotta focused their guns on the 2nd Platoon That could have been fatal.
- InclinedPlane 8y agoHasn't really stopped either. Read up on things like the shoddy evidence that goes into drone bombing or the crimes of Seal Team Six or the many other horrific acts the US military has done in recent years and decades. If anything it seems like we are getting better at sweeping this stuff under the rug.
- fit2rule 8y agoYes, thats the point of this history lesson - we are still committing these crimes, on a regular basis, with impunity. The only ones who can do anything about it is civilians. But, none of us seem to be too bothered by the 300,000 innocent lives lost, because America needs war.
- candiodari 8y ago"we" sadly means all of humanity. This is a problem of government forces in general: Here's the other side in that same war doing it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_at_Hu%E1%BA%BF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_at_Hu%E1%BA%BF Here's UN forces: https://www.apnews.com/69e56ab46cab400f9f4b3753bd79c930 https://www.apnews.com/69e56ab46cab400f9f4b3753bd79c930 The Dutch army: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rawagede_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rawagede_massacre Saudi forces: https://www.theamericanconservative.com/larison/a-saudi-coalition-massacre-of-yemeni-fishermen/ https://www.theamericanconservative.com/larison/a-saudi-coal... The French army: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bab_El_Oued https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Bab_El_Oued Japan: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731
- josu 8y ago>Unfortunately, our website is currently unavailable in most European countries. We are engaged on the issue and committed to looking at options that support our full range of digital offerings to the EU market. We continue to identify technical compliance solutions that will provide all readers with our awa I'm in Mexico :/
- gerdesj 8y agoWelcome to Europe mate. The place has always been a bit weird and I see no problem with Mexicans being considered Europeans. I'm British (we are properly strange) May I also welcome you to the world of IP to location nonsense. Quite large chunks of IPv4 have been shuffled around the world to the point that geo location on IP is nonsense.
- wnkrshm 8y agoEurope by elimination. Not US, not South-East Asia, not Russia. Must be Europe.
- qubax 8y agoIt's a bit strange that we are remembering the "hero" but not the 500 or so innocent vietnamese men, women, children and infants who were raped, tortured and/or killed. Strange how we always have to make ourselves the good guys. The "heroes". If you look at the war photos. You'll see infants. Such a horrific war. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Lai_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Lai_Massacre It's also strange that we say this is the worst event in vietnam war, when we dropped napalm on people ( chemically burning them to death ) and more than 4 million people were killed in that terrible war. God knows how many vietnamese women and children were raped. My Lai was one of thousands of my lai incidents in vietnam.
- mc32 8y agoIsn’t that how it usually works. Japan remembers its war dead, we remember ours. They rember their heroes, we remember ours. Same for Soviets, Germans, British, French, Spanish, Philipinoes, Indians, Pakistanis, etc..
- groestl 8y agoSince you mention the Germans: Their process of working through the past ("Vergangenheitsbewältigung") very much includes remembering the victims, massacres and non-heros, as well as embarrassement and remorse, while spending very little energy discussing the actions of positive figures. And even they are seldomly described as "heroes" ("Helden"), probably to avoid any ambiguity regarding the responsibility of the German people for the horrible events. Alas, Germany might be unique in that regard.
- romwell 8y agoI wouldn't call him forgotten - while I'm bad with remembering names, when I saw "My Lai", the first thing that came to mind was "that badass helicopter pilot who landed his helicopter between civilians and US soldiers, and threatened to open fire to protect the civilians". What I didn't know was that he took so much flak for that - from statements that he should be the one punished to death threats and dead animals on his porch. Unsurprising, yet sad. His name was Hugh Thompson, and today, let's remember that name[1]. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Thompson_Jr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugh_Thompson_Jr.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- thereare5lights 8y ago> What I didn't know was that he took so much flak for that - from statements that he should be the one punished to death threats and dead animals on his porch. Unsurprising, yet sad. Pretty much to be expected in any situation where someone goes against convention. People are shitty when it comes to tribal issues.
- hef19898 8y agoThis is the proof that war really brings out the worst or the best in people. Unfortunately most of the time it is the worst.
- aaron695 8y ago> What I didn't know was that he took so much flak for that I sincerely doubt it. He acted with courage and people respect that. It would have been because he reported it, this would have gotten post war veterans with PTSD in trouble when everyone just wanted to move on. Not saying he was wrong, but people don't death threat bad asses who are willing to fight other people with guns, that's considered a fair fight. > Back at their base he filed a complaint about the killing of civilians that he had witnessed.
- owenversteeg 8y agoAn extra point: his "helicopter" was about the smallest thing you could get and still call it a helicopter. It provided no cover or protection for the people inside. Had the soldiers engaged, Thompson and the others would have gone down instantly. Photo: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Hiller_UH-12_(H-23)_bw.jpg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Hiller_UH-12_(H-23)_bw....
- squarefoot 8y ago"Unfortunately, our website is currently unavailable in most European countries. ..." So much for the World Wide Web. Someone give me back the web 1.0 before 2000, please.
- Bluestrike2 8y agohttps://outline.com/pvdxgM https://outline.com/pvdxgM And 100% agreed, particularly for a major newspaper.
- drakenot 8y agoThanks for the link. I hadn't heard of outline.com before, but seems like a useful service.
- giodamelio 8y agoIt is pretty nifty. They have a Chrome extension too, but that seems like massive overkill so I threw together a quick bookmarklet [1]. You need a decently new browser to use it. fetch( "https://outlineapi.com/parse_article?source_url=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location) ) .then(res => res.json()) .then(body => { if (body.error) { return alert(`Outline Bookmarklet Error: ${body.error}`); } window.location.href = `https://outline.com/${body.data.short_code}` }) .catch(err => { alert("Outline Bookmarklet Error. See console for details."); console.error(err); }); Or minified to be copied directly into bookmark: javascript:fetch("https://outlineapi.com/parse_article?source_url="+encodeURIComponent(window.location)).then(o=>o.json()).then(o=>{if(o.error)return alert(`Outline Bookmarklet Error: ${o.error}`);window.location.href=`https://outline.com/${o.data.short_code}`}).catch(o=>{alert("Outline Bookmarklet Error. See console for details."),console.error(o)}); [1]: https://gist.github.com/giodamelio/c97f71a12eec5c142f21f757a6ba4d8a https://gist.github.com/giodamelio/c97f71a12eec5c142f21f757a...
- stevehb 8y agoIt's not blocked here in Taiwan. I wonder if they're blocking it because of the GDPR?
- 1ceaham 8y agoSome of you may find the recently-staged monodrama focused on Hugh Thompson with the Kronos Quartet of interest. The NYT wrote it up [1], but excerpts can also be found elsewhere. I found it a fitting tribute to his memory. [1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/28/arts/music/my-lai-review-vietnam-kronos-quartet.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/28/arts/music/my-lai-review-...
- oconnor663 8y ago> On the 30th anniversary of the massacre, Thompson went back to My Lai and met some of the people whose lives he had saved. "There were real good highs," he told me, "and very low lows. One of the ladies that we had helped out that day came up to me and asked, 'Why didn't the people who committed these acts come back with you?' And I was just devastated. And then she finished her sentence: she said, 'So we could forgive them.' http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-wiener-my-lai-hugh-thompson-20180316-story.html http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-wiener-my-lai-hug...
- rmason 8y agoThere are a lot of people who use the My Lai massacre as an example of the 'real' America. There are a lot of My Lai's and William Calley's in other countries throughout history. But far fewer Hugh Thompson's and to me that's the 'real' America. In Michigan we've got the recent example of Dr. Hanna Attisha and the Flint water crisis. She was vilified by Flint officials, state officials and by the state's universities. The state health director called her irresponsible and execs at her hospital wanted her fired. Worries made her physically ill. I do not know how she stood courageously for so long but she did. Eventually a Detroit Free Press article supported her and in time everyone withdrew their opposition. https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2015/10/10/hanna-attisha-profile/73600120/ https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2015/10/10/h...
- abalone 8y ago> There are a lot of My Lai's and William Calley's in other countries throughout history. But far fewer Hugh Thompson's and to me that's the 'real' America. There were a lot of My Lai’s in Vietnam. Biggest misconception is that it was some kind of fluke. But in a “war” where entire civillian populated areas were designated “free fire zones” where you could kill anything that moves, civillian massacres were the norm. Not every solider did it of course but it was a regular feature of that war. It is good to recognize brave soldiers that resisted. But we must be respectful enough of those who were murdered to not attempt to rehabilitate the image of America in Vietnam by pretending those resisters were the norm or represented the true spirit of America and what it was aiming for or some such sentimental nationalist nonsense. As the article notes, a My Lai happened every month in Vietnam. Civillian mass murder was an explicit goal and the U.S. was very good at it.
- Pica_soO 8y agoIts one of those features of asymmetric warfare, that you can drag the enemy into the moral-mud-pits of combating opposition among the civilian population. For the opposite side this has the benefit of getting new recruits among the relatives and survivors and obviously of leading a far superior enemy by the noose ring through the public arena -which raises Opposition in a democracy - and reduces combat effectiveness in the military in dictatorships and democracy's (sovjet afghanistan). I would really love to have the CIAs Information on how much vietnamese population was in active opposition to the american "police" action. My estimate would be around 75 %.
- torstenvl 8y agoAnother hero, whom I as a judge advocate personally admire, is Captain Aubrey Daniel III, the prosecutor in the case against Calley. While still on active duty, he wrote a letter to President Nixon urging him not to intervene. Thompson displayed both physical and moral courage, whereas Daniel was never in any danger to life or limb. But his moral courage is courage nonetheless. https://www.famous-trials.com/mylaicourts/1623-daniels-ltr https://www.famous-trials.com/mylaicourts/1623-daniels-ltr
- abenedic 8y agoA thing more oft than not forgotten about war, is the individual element. I was in my countries armed forces, while necessary. I saw many different types of commanders during that time. One thing not to forget is that a person is still a human even if a soldier. My commander ordered things I hated to do, while a person in a similar position was hung for failure to perform duty, allegedly because of his belief in human life.
- jrandm 8y agoI want to add to what chris_mc and others said confirming this horrible instance is used as a training exercise for lots of the US military. When I did USMC boot camp in the late 2000s this and other less publicized examples were used to enforce disobeying unlawful orders and encouraging critical thought. To quote a West Wing episode (AFAIK): "All wars are crimes." I'm glad we try to do better by teaching from our mistakes.
- bbddg 8y ago>I'm glad we try to do better by teaching from our mistakes. ... > Kills a million people in iraq
- bbddg 8y agoIf there was any justice in the world, the US officials who dictated military action in Vietnam would be tried for war crimes.
- iforgotpassword 8y agoWell, that's the exception unfortunately, especially of you're on the winning side. Even in Germany, which is often held as a prime example on taking responsibility for their actions during WW2 afterwards, quite a bunch of medium to high ranked officials got away. Another example is Japan. Even fewer were prosecuted and punished for their war crimes there, even though the US were paying close attention first. It became less important after it turned out Japan could be a great ally for the US's involvements in Asia, so a lot of them could get off the hook.
- fit2rule 8y agoIf there was justice in the world, Cheney, Bush, Rumsfeld, and Obama would all be in The Hague, in irons. There is no justice in the world.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoThats far too easy. In a democracy YOU are the state. I wonder what would happen if we could live cast our military deployments so that every voter has access to every war crime committed? Maybe then people wouldn't be so quick to sign up for another war. Or they would at least be honest about it.
- DanBC 8y agoWatch films and TV shows where blatantly illegal actions - including Geneva convention war crimes - are committed by the heros. I'm not persuaded the public wants less of this. And politicians sometimes play to this, asking for action that's of dubious legality
- fit2rule 8y agoOh, I agree fully that citizens are responsible for the actions of their military, and as well those of their politicians. The trouble is, the people always get the rulers they deserve.
- quickthrower2 8y agoOblig: https://xkcd.com/206/ https://xkcd.com/206/
- pvsukale1 8y agoI read the wikipedia article about this article. There is picture of a woman seconds before being killed. She is with her children. She was recently sexually abused and was trying to tie her buttons. And it is really devastating. How did United States get away with this? All that captain got was a 3 years house arrest?!
- AndyMcConachie 8y agoSeymour Hersh, the reporter who's largely the reason we know about the My Lai massacre at all, recently published his Memoirs. https://www.amazon.com/Reporter-Memoir-Seymour-M-Hersh/dp/0307263959/ https://www.amazon.com/Reporter-Memoir-Seymour-M-Hersh/dp/03... He's probably one of the most important investigative reporters to have ever lived.
- objektif 8y agoLets also remember Aubrey Daniel who worked hard to prosecute these war criminals.
- GreeniFi 8y agoI’ve known several soldiers over the years and all had struggles with depression and possibly PTSD. I obviously wouldn’t want to present these limited data points as conclusive evidence, but I’ve been struck by the extent to which combatants pay a high price for their jobs. I feel sorry for them, because no-one tells them about this when they’re recruited. It’s a real bait and switch: promises of comraderie, glory and a trade and what you actually get is a thumping case of depression and PTSD. I don’t believe in karma, but this looks a bit like it to me.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoWhen I hear about Vietnam, I think about the 13 young men I grew up with in a town of 6000 who didn't get a chance to be grandfathers. Nobody 'wins'. We all LOSE.