4 ms·
So yes, Google can be very impressed with Google. But I'm not sure that's the issue here. Is it really surprising that people who have extremely precise time n
by wpietri 8y ago
So yes, Google can be very impressed with Google. But I'm not sure that's the issue here.
Is it really surprising that people who have extremely precise time needs and a whole team devoted to solving them would notice issues that other people wouldn't? I think it's a very common pattern that a product has some set of trailblazer users who find issues before the people who make the product.
Also, I think you're over-interpreting. "Had to" here only means that they noticed and reported the issue first because their system depended on GPS time being right. It doesn't preclude the possibility that the USAF would notice and fix the issue eventually, just with a higher latency that Google wanted.
- hosay123 8y agoIf some condition existed that exceeded GPS intended design, you most certainly wouldn't learn of it first from some random anecdote on HN.. more likely the front page of the BBC as the transportation system instantly collapses So the anecdote itself is noise, it's intended to show how seriously intractable a problem accurate time is, but it doesn't do that, instead it only demonstrates OP's lack of familiarity with GPS and willingness to regurgitate corporate old wives' tales
- skrebbel 8y agoSub-millisecond flaws in GPS would make the transportation system collapse? Why?
- dleslie 8y agoTriangulation of location is bounded by the accuracy of those clocks. 1 microsecond is 300 meters of error.
- tzs 8y agoWhat if all the satellites are off by the same amount? According to the link posted higher up in the thread, in early 2016 they were all off by 13 microseconds for 12 hours, with no apparent consequences for anything ordinary people use GPS for such as location finding. To triangulate, I think you need to know (1) where the satellites are, and (2) how far you are from each satellite. I think either absolute distance or relative distance works. Getting both of these depends on knowing the time. That time comes from the satellites. Let's say they are all off by 1 us. Your time is derived from satellite time. That would mean the time you use to look up/calculate their positions will be off by 1 us from the correct time so you would get the wrong position for the satellites. A quick Googling says the satellites orbital speed is 14000 km/hr, so using a time off by 1 us to look up/calculate satellite position would give you a position that is about 4 mm off. The procedure for deriving the time from the satellites would get some extra error from this, but that should be limited to about the time it takes like to travel 4 mm, so we can ignore that. As a result your distance measurements between you and satellites would be off by about 4 mm or less. The key here is that when all the satellites have the same error, the time you derive has the same error, so your distance calculations should still work, and so you only get an error of about how far satellites move in an interval equal to the time error. In summary, if all the satellites are off by 1 us, your triangulation seems like it would be about 4 mm more uncertain. If only one satellite is off, it is going to depend on how the time algorithm works. If the algorithm is such that it ends up with a time much closer to the times of the correct satellites than to the off satellite, then if it calculates the distance from the triangulated position to the expected positions of the satellites, and compares that to the measured distance, it should find that one is off by something on the order of the distance light travels in 1 us, and the others are all pretty close to where they should be. It should then be able to figure out that it has one unreliable satellite it, drop it, and then get the right location. I have no idea if they actually take those kinds of precautions, though. The case that would really screw it up would be if several satellites are off, but by different amounts. With enough observation it should be possible in many cases to even straighten that out, but it might be too complicated or too time consuming to be practical. (This is assuming that the error is that the satellites are simply set to the wrong time, but that wrong time is ticking at the right rate).
- ninkendo 8y agoPrecise geolocation relies on extreme time accuracy (the story always being that relativistic time dilation effects with the difference in gravity on the surface vs LEO must be accounted for), so yeah, it wouldn't surprise me one bit that the accuracy required is on the order of much less than a millisecond.
- ihattendorf 8y agoHere's an interesting article[1] about how relativity affects GPS satellites. The clock ticks in a GPS satellite need to be accurate to within 20-30 nanoseconds for accuracy, and they tick 38 microseconds/day faster to account for relativity. [1] http://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/~pogge/Ast162/Unit5/gps.html http://www.astronomy.ohio-state.edu/~pogge/Ast162/Unit5/gps....
- jandrese 8y agoGPS is one of the few technologies that have to account for both Special Relativity and General Relativity. The level of engineering that went into the system is just amazing. Fun fact, GPS satellites use rubidium clocks instead of cesium clocks, and only maintain their accuracy thanks to yet another incredible feat of engineering.
- joshuamorton 8y agoA single satellite mildly misbehaving on occasion won't necessarily cause catastrophe. You're normally connected to more than the requisite 3 satellites anyway, so you might notice less accuracy, but not anything terrible. Most of these systems are designed to work if you lose GPS entirely, so they fail gracefully. Planes won't actually fall out of the sky if GPS makes mistakes. That's y2k fearmongering. Why is it hard to believe that a group using GPS for a unique purpose has unique needs and detect unique issues?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cloudwizard 8y agohttps://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35491962 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-35491962 Could this be it?
- 21 8y ago> Is it really surprising that people who have extremely precise time needs and a whole team devoted to solving them would notice issues that other people wouldn't If GPS timing is bad, a lot of people will notice that their position on the map is incorrect, because that's the whole purpose of the GPS network. A 1 microsecond error is 300 meters.
- mannykannot 8y agoGPS is not typically used to confirm a position that is known accurately by other means, and that is not its purpose. Only in those cases where there is a manifest conflict with independent spatial information will the problem be evident.
- Rapzid 8y agoPeople are going to notice a 300m deviation due to landmarks and their eyes.
- mannykannot 8y agoRarely, if you are navigating at sea or in the air or in the woods... and even on the road, it is not uncommon for my GPS device to be clearly off without justifying the conclusion that there is a fault in a satellite.
- Rapzid 8y agoHere are some users that have a high chance of noticing visually and in aggregate would probably produce a lot of noise: * Air and sea port operators and navigators * Military personal running supply lines * Military personal on foot in operations and training * Space-X * NASA * River boats * Fresh water fishermen * Etc Out of all the possible users who would notice a 300m deviation just based on visual reconciliation, I personally would not say it would be so rare that the USAF would not find out very quickly. Of course, this is ignoring the equipment that would likely detect the issue way before somebody in the Army started phoning the USAF.