3 ms·
It has more "content" than the post to which it replies. "This is good." "No, it is bad, in these particular areas." [EDIT:] Granted, the post could still be
by jessaustin 8y ago
It has more "content" than the post to which it replies.
"This is good."
"No, it is bad, in these particular areas."
[EDIT:] Granted, the post could still be wrong, but ISTM accusations of content-freedom tend to be projections.
- pdpi 8y ago"This is a good read" is a statement of opinion. You're free to assign whatever value you like to the op's opinion, but that opinion is "content" in and of itself. "The article has false claim" is a statement of fact. A vague statement of fact about a non-obvious topic that puts no effort into providing concrete examples and reasoning is pretty much worthless.
- jessaustin 8y agoAdding qualifiers makes a statement have less content? Please try to imagine using this questionable argument in any other context... It's a controversial topic and TFA was written by someone with a commercial interest. Everything is opinion. The level of comment-policing I see here makes me quite suspicious of everything in TFA. [EDIT:] aargh I'll never learn every discussion that starts with "content-free" cliche goes nowhere... just downvote and move on...
- haberman 8y agoIf you're suspicious about me, it's not very well-founded, considering my main comment thread on this story takes issue with the blog's claims: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18039801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18039801 I just prefer to have discussions about specific things, not posturing and innuendo.