4 ms·
> The computer will not be able to make sense of this step either. What does that mean, then? That a leap is being made that depends on the reader's fuzzy intu
by MaxBarraclough 8y ago
> The computer will not be able to make sense of this step either.
What does that mean, then? That a leap is being made that depends on the reader's fuzzy intuitions, rather than the established axioms? If that's the case, it's not a formal proof at all, no?
Or am I way off here?
- konschubert 8y agoMaybe he says that the computer won't help understand the proof since the proof is missing a step. He may be saying the equivalent of "A computer won't help you to prove that 1+1=3“
- heinrichhartman 8y agoExactly, this is how I read it as well.
- MaxBarraclough 8y ago> He may be saying the equivalent of "A computer won't help you to prove that 1+1=3“ But it can. You need to have the computer 'comprehend' the relevant axioms, of course. If your 'proof' is in fact just arguing the case for new axioms, that isn't a proof at all, it's a misunderstanding of what 'axiom' means. (They're definitions, not profound universal truths.)
- MauranKilom 8y agoI find his explanation of the reverse quite clear: > Any proof that can be spelled out at a level of detail sufficient to be analyzed by a computer is necessarily going to consist entirely of steps that are each completely comprehensible to a mathematician. This means there must either be a lot of steps or a lot of different paths to follow in order for a computer to be of use. Neither is the case here.