4 ms·
It's similar to how racism is presented. Many people talk about how "racist" the US is, and of course there is still a lot of racism in the US. But there is ra
by fastball 8y ago
It's similar to how racism is presented. Many people talk about how "racist" the US is, and of course there is still a lot of racism in the US.
But there is racism everywhere. I've lived in several countries, including Switzerland. I've never heard anyone except people that have lived in CH talk about how racist it is (very).
The difference, I think, is that the US is the country most likely to admit fault when they are racist. Americans themselves will say "yes, we're racist", while Swiss, Germans, Brits, etc. all seem to still be in that denial stage.
I think things like Brexit are starting to get people to think long and hard about their actual views on race / immigration. America just got to the party first.
- refoundglory 8y agoWeeeeeeelllll, you might say that America is one of a few countries that had overt legal racism recently enough that it's impossible to ignore.
- vivekseth 8y agoYeah, I don’t think racism is an American issue. I think racist attitudes can result wherever people have low exposure to people of different races. For example, I feel that India has a lot of racism (just from my personal experience visiting a few times). Part of what makes US unique is that it’s minority groups are much larger than most other countries. I feel that this means racist attitudes get acted upon more frequently, and that victims have a stronger voice here.
- throwaway4job 8y agoHaving worked in Germany, London, and America, I feel as though America is far more racist than the other countries. I understand your desire to pretend that the US is merely honest about a global belief, but that's not true. That's just some shit that racist people want to be true. Racism in the US is stronger, more violent, and more vitriolic than it is is in other places. The other places aren't perfect, but America is a fucking cesspool filled with vile people.
- village-idiot 8y agoThe US is also a very heterogeneous society, so race issues come up a lot. Some (but not all) of the countries you’ve listed have a more homogeneous population, which means race problems are less likely to flare up in big messy ways. It’s a lot easier to spot a racist when the target of their ire is nearby, as compared to the one that Just mutters obscenities about foreigners while reading the newspaper.
- spiralx 8y ago> The US is also a very heterogeneous society, so race issues come up a lot. No it isn't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_ranked_by_ethnic_and_cultural_diversity_level https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_ranked_by_et...
- olavk 8y agoSo you are saying other countries are "just as bad" when it comes to imprisoning innocents? I don't see how that is even possible given that the incarceration rate in the US is so much higher.
- fastball 8y agoNo, I'm not trying to engage in "whataboutism". However, I think you might be conflating two issues. A country can have a very high incarceration rate without imprisoning a single innocent: that country could have a very high crime rate, or the bar for "crime" could be lower and more aggressively pursued. I think the vast majority of the US' "over-incarceration" can be attributed to those two factors, not to the US just throwing randoms in prison. Do we also sometimes imprison innocent people? Absolutely. But so does every country. As far as I am aware, there is nothing unique to the US justice system that would cause a higher incidence of actually innocent people going to jail. But we do send more people to jail. But the vast majority of them are guilty of their crimes, the question is really "should smoking pot be an imprisonable offense?", or similar.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- iforgotpassword 8y agoWhat about the privatization of prisons? It makes sense to lobby for setting the bar lower if you happen to run a prison. It also makes sense that you don't have any interest in helping your prisoners to have good chances of reintegrating, getting a job after release, but rather have them commit the next crime and come right back. I think Germany is at the other end of the extreme; if it's your first conviction and it wasn't exactly cold blooded murder you almost always get away with probation, or a couple months tops. There were cases of people abusing children and only getting a year or two, which makes me furious. And there have been cases in Germany where people were innocent too, of course. This is actually the most important argument for me against the death penalty. Since we know for sure that we make mistakes every now and then we should not carry out a sentence we cannot undo. Sure we cannot give the wrongfully imprisoned back their youth; but we can give them the rest of their life at least.
- rland 8y agoI have a friend from Japan. I was attempting to explain to him how racism in the U.S. operates—how it comes in subtle forms, how you can be racist and not even intend to be, how social power can sometimes be so abstract and diffuse that it no individuals can be blamed. After our 3 hour long conversation, I brought up Korea. He explained to me how Koreans are loud, rude, and dirty. I told him, yes, racism in the US sometimes takes a similar form, to which he replied: "No! It's not racism! It's Koreans!" Yes, this is tremendously accurate. I don't think racism is worse in the US, I think we have more heterogeneity which makes it more visible.