5 ms·
Soldiers have always groused about their chow, of course. Generations of generals have repeated the adage that armies march on their stomachs, but few ever ment
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Soldiers have always groused about their chow, of course. Generations of generals have repeated the adage that armies march on their stomachs, but few ever mentioned taste buds.
Adding to the anecdotes here:
My dad was an E-8 in the army. He told a lot of stories about cutting through the bureaucratic BS to look out for the welfare of his people. He was very savvy about the fact that simply being in charge actively created obstacles to him knowing what was really going on at the lower levels.
One of his stories that sticks with me:
He inspected the chow hall by walking in unannounced and taking the tray from the guy coming off the line, then telling the staff to get the guy a replacement tray post haste so he wasn't unduly screwed over in the process. This meant they couldn't set aside any special cuts of meat or whatever just for The Sarge. He knew he was eating what they ate because he was eating a tray prepared for one of the troops, not for him. He gave them no warning so they couldn't have this day be the day everything was better or whatever.
I'm not convinced MREs are an improvement over the old rations. I've eaten MREs. They are pretty bad. I've heard stories from my dad about the old rations and some of it was apparently okay.
I'm not a fan of microwave meals either. MREs strike me as sort of like that. It is some new fangled means to do x, y or z that actually lowers food quality. Though I have read that in WW2, there were two different bugs that so regularly infested the flour with which biscuits were made for soldiers, that soldiers could tell you which bug they preferred to end up eating because one of them made the biscuits very bitter. So maybe it isn't quite as simple as I like to imagine.
Anyway, this looks like a good thing to me. The article mentions that pizza is "ubiquitous" in the US. That's actually understating it's popularity. From what I gather, it is actually the most widely eaten food globally and they do things like put fish on it in Japan.
- johan_larson 8y agoI recently tried a bunch of knock-off MREs sold to civilians. As far as I could tell the contents of the kits were the same stuff as in real MREs, but packaged a bit differently. My take is that the components that are naturally dry work best. Cookies, crackers, raisins, nuts: all of these are fine. Things get weird and unappealing once the components have to be wet, which is a problem because most of the main dishes are basically stews of various sorts. I can appreciate that the MRE designers are facing a hard problem: making food that is shelf-stable for years yet palatable enough to be eaten for weeks on end. But the results really aren't very good.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMy recollection is that the MREs did weird things like included veggies as an ingredient in crackers to help add variety nutritionally, which did weird things to the taste. I'm fine with eating dried fruits and roasted nuts. I don't see why there isn't more of that type thing in military field rations. Isn't that a tried and true means to preserve food for long periods while still being nutritious and delicious?
- rtkwe 8y agoThe meals also need to be pretty calorie dense too though so that soldiers can carry them and quickly get the energy they need.
- thrower123 8y agoIt's surprisingly difficult to produce combat rations that can provide enough calories for wartime activities. The (civilian) 2000 calorie diet on the side of the box now is already a joke for anybody reasonably active, but when you're humping a third to half your bodyweight through rough terrain, it's downright ridiculous. WW2 K-Rations (approx 3000 kcals daily), when not supplemented with anything better, frequently led to malnutrition, scurvy and other similar ailments, not to mention that troops on them for extended periods of time in a warzone lost so much weight and muscle mass that they were ineffective for months afterwards.
- dpark 8y ago> I'm fine with eating dried fruits and roasted nuts. I don't see why there isn't more of that type thing in military field rations. Probably because dried fruit and roasted nuts are both pretty expensive compared to normal rations. Also I’m pretty sure my digestive system would be pretty unhappy if I were eating primarily nuts and dried fruit for days or weeks on end.
- DoreenMichele 8y ago"I don't see why there isn't more of that type thing in military field rations." does not mean "Let's feed troops exclusively dried fruit and nuts and nothing else." Re expense: They spend millions on research to develop new MREs. If "Healthy, palatable food that already exists costs too much" is a primary basis for rejecting it, something is wrong with this picture.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ardy42 8y ago> I'm not convinced MREs are an improvement over the old rations. I've eaten MREs. They are pretty bad. I've heard stories from my dad about the old rations and some of it was apparently okay. I'm not military nor have a military family, but I was under the impression that the main problems with the pre-MRE rations was that they were heavy and lacked variety, so you'd get sick of the good stuff pretty fast.
- VLM 8y agoI have a few years experience with MREs admittedly some decades ago, between the two gulf wars. 1) On a short term subjective individual basis anything mom didn't put in your lunch will be defined as awful, such that if you swap lunches with the kid next to you in grade school you'll hear plenty of complaining about lunch is inedible, even if every individual loves their own mom's cooking. This goes away after some weeks. 2) Most eating is about social signaling, virtue signaling, conspicuous consumption. So the stereotypical "first day pass" every new private passes up an objectively better free meal at the DFAC for an icky greasy chezburger at the on post Burger King and claim its the best food they've ever eaten. Likewise in the field you're issued an MRE that tastes pretty good and you'll hate the lack of choice no matter how good it tastes; offer soldiers their choice of cardboard flavored instant Ramen and they'll declare that a culinary masterpiece. Imagine the reaction if a Michelin Star restaurant refused any serving choices at all; here's your drink and meal chosen by us; no matter how good the food is, the complaints would be deafening. 3) Sometimes the food is objectively bad in taste or texture or consistency from pack to pack. The famous vegetable omelette can be delicious or randomly they include too much soggy woodchip-like "mystery fiber" and thats just disgusting although I generally like that MRE. Also the Italian sausage MRE sandwich, which has been around at least a decade and is essentially a rolled up pizza, gives me and every other soldier I've asked, heartburn, and essentially no other food gives me heartburn (whiskey shots, but only sometimes). On the other hand we had a running joke / research project in my platoon along the lines of the army counts every meatball in the spaghetti entree, expect a hand receipt for nine serial numbered meatballs with every entree, or whatever. 4) Sometimes the system is subjectively inconsistent across the system. Almost everyone in the army ate a chef boyardee ravioli or spaghetti with meatballs or salisbury steak meal when they were kids, and the army has produced MREs that are consistently indistinguishable from the kid dining experience to the point of generating homesickness. MREs contain (used to contain) a poundcake that was indistinguishable from an flat unstuffed twinkie. And of course a pack of M&Ms for desert is literally a civilian pack of M&Ms making it very consistent with civilian life and everyone likes those. On the other hand, something like the famous omelette is very binary, almost political, in that about half of soldiers will trade it for anything and refuse to eat it, and the other half think its pretty tasty when warmed up. I have no idea what the army was thinking shipping something half the troops will hate. 5) If your chain of command suck or for whatever other reason your morale is low, its totally socially acceptable in the Army to complain about the food. Yet going the other way if field conditions are so rough you'd eat anything "SERE course style" then lack of complaining also worries leadership. Basically leadership operates under the model that if the worst thing the troops are doing is complaining about the food, then the leadership is probably doing mostly well. I suspect in the long run once the PR dies down the pizza MRE will be hated by the troops because everyone has their own ideal mental model of a pizza and "one size fits all" isn't going to work for anything thats not a mass produced kid food (like chef boyardee ravioli). Also if its essentially an unrolled italian sausage MRE sandwich, almost everyone is gonna get heartburn.
- gonzo41 8y agoThe trick with MRE's is to go vegetarian. Penna pasta 2-3 times a day for ~2 months. I didn't eat pasta for about 3 years after that. I should say, meals wern't great, but they weren't bad.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoIdeally soldiers get whatever's easily sourced locally, but I can imagine most current warzones aren't really bountiful enough to support thousands of troops in addition to the local population. Still, canned vegetables go a long way and they have a shelf life of at least a year. I don't see a need for food with a shelf life of years for the current wartime situations.
- alexhutcheson 8y agoCanned food is heavy and bulky (mostly from the extra water, not the can itself). Normal canned vegetables aren't very calorie-dense either, which is one of the criteria MREs are trying to hit.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoCanned food also isn't as resistant to damage as a flexible bag of odds and ends can be, and more importantly tends to harbor bioweapon-tier food poisoning when it does get damaged
- harimau777 8y agoI remember reading in one of the Wikipedia articles on US Military mess kits that the United States is the only military that doesn't expect troops to forage at least some of their food. (This was relevant to the article because that resulted in some of the mess kit designs being optimized for cafeteria style serving) Of course normal considerations about the accuracy of Wikipedia may apply.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI was just at a resort hotel in Japan and went over to the pizza bar for some sausage pizza (hopefully) only to find pizza with varieties of fish :( it’s actually kind of hard to find really good American style pizza here. The same goes for burgers - everything has weird ingredients, sauces or the meat is not 100% (mixed with some other stuff). Don’t get me wrong, the food is amazing, but once in a while I just want some ham and pineapple or meat lovers shitty papa johns, ya know? I would choke a child over some Chicago deep dish right about now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- harimau777 8y ago...ham and pineapple... You monster! (Kidding, although I don't think I'll ever understand Hawaiian pizza)
- sho 8y ago> it’s actually kind of hard to find really good American style pizza here And when she was good, she was very, very good, But when she was bad she was horrid I have to admit Japan is weird like that. Food is either world class (when they "get it") or it's simply awful (when they don't). There's no good Thai in Tokyo, no good hamburgers, no good Mexican, not even much decent Italian (Saizeriya. Dear God). Not really even any good bread, if you like crusty sourdough. There's a complicated calculus at work between what the market wants, its expectation when it gets it, and what it will pay. When those factors align you will get absolutely world class food. When they don't, for whatever reason, you get absolutely nonsensical garbage. The best Thai that I know of in Tokyo, a city of 30+ million people, I would equate to a 3rd rate strip mall takeout place in my home country. And yet the crappiest 5-for-100¥ gyouza in Tokyo is better than any gyouza in Australia. The market drives everything, and the japanese market knows nothing about pizza. I've felt your pain. Eat a lot when you get back home. update: just noticed that you wanted ham and pineapple pizza. I withdraw my sympathetic remarks. I consider fish pizza an appropriate punishment
- mmjaa 8y ago
- enriquto 8y ago> [pizza] is actually the most widely eaten food globally and they do things like put fish on it in Japan. Why do you mention that? Aren't anchovies a universal staple of pizza toppings?
- tudelo 8y agoIt has to be the most uncommon pizza topping in the US.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt's also widely mocked as a topping many people would find objectionable.
- enriquto 8y agowow, US culture is so exotic, I love it!
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWe aren't talking about anchovies: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18033318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18033318
- miluge 8y agoThey do put fish on it in JP and I love it, I sometimes do it here too and always get the yuck look from my friends/gf.