3 ms·
Copenhagen interpretation is not that easy to debunk. It is not backed by any additional math beyond all of the quantum physics math that is solid but backs mul
by scotty79 8y ago
Copenhagen interpretation is not that easy to debunk. It is not backed by any additional math beyond all of the quantum physics math that is solid but backs multiple interpretations.
In physics if something doesn't have its own math then it is just an opinion. You can't prove it, you can't debunk it, you can have different one. Ultimately it doesn't matter.
For me Copenhagen interpretation becomes absurd from the moment it states that observer matters. Each observer is just lots of particles and the fact that they arranged to have eyes and brain can't possibly matter for the basic laws of physics.
- consz 8y agoYou don't need eyes and a brain to observe, a photon can be an observer.
- scotty79 8y agoThat's not obvious to everybody. Even in this post there is mention that Shrodinger's cat is somehow different from Shrodinger's scientist.
- nabla9 8y agoCopenhagen interpretation does not imply human or conscious observer. That's called quantum mystism that usually uses Copenhagen interpretation as a starting point. What Heisenberg and others assumed was that that there exists so called 'Heisenberg cut' between somewhere between quantum and macroscopic phenomenon.
- scotty79 8y agoThat's not obvious to everybody. Even in this post there is mention that Shrodinger's cat is somehow different from Shrodinger's scientist. And I've seen serious physicist lecturers claim that even recorded measurement didn't cause collapse because recording was not seen by anyone. This is completely bonkers and misticism is the right word for it. People who invented the thing are to blame. Why call something 'observation' if you mean interaction with macroscopic object. And why make the fuss about Shrodinger's cat?