9 ms·
The Justice Dept's secret rules for targeting journalists with FISA court orders
- rasengan 8y agoTargeting journalists is horrible. Any government that is doing these things does not represent we the people. Journalists are our loudest narrators - meaning - the government appears to really wish to control our narrative.
- slowmovintarget 8y ago> Journalists are our loudest narrators - meaning - the government appears to really wish to control our narrative. When the narration is coordinated with the DNC, this makes me think they aren't doing their job any more. But yes, it wasn't acceptable when the Obama administration was wire tapping Fox News reporters, and it's not acceptable now.
- falcrist 8y agoABC, NBC, CBS, WSJ, NYT, Chicago Tribune, New York Post, BBC, PBS, NPR, AP, Reuters, etc... All of these (or even the majority) are controlled by the DNC? I don't think so, and if that isn't on the nose enough for you, I'll just say that I think you're talking about 24 hour news networks... CNN specifically. Yea, they endorsed Clinton as hard as they could. So STOP WATCHING THEM, and stop equating journalism to the likes of CNN and Fox. Watch and/or read something else. You speak English and live in a country with a protected press (which is why this article is worrying in the first place). There are literally thousands of newspapers, magazines, television news shows (and networks) out there. Pick a couple of reputable ones (including at least one that challenges your views) and stop watching piffle.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>All of these (or even the majority) are controlled by the DNC? To play devils advocate, yes they are (to varying degrees), in the same way that college campuses are "controlled" by the DNC. >and stop equating journalism to the likes of CNN and Fox Kinda funny how far we've come. CNN used to be the impartial one.
- falcrist 8y agoThe DNC may want to control the news, but they don't have anywhere near that kind of power. The outlets I listed span across the entire anglosphere. As far as CNN... they saw what Fox was doing on the right and realized partisan pandering is more lucrative than impartial reporting. I honestly think that's likely to become worse over time.
- tokai 8y agoIt is pretty disingenuous to compare correlating political opinions to being "controlled".
- ilbesilncd 8y agoIt is rather difficult to engage with people on this issue, I believe most people don't actually read anything beyond their own partisan echo chmabers. https://theintercept.com/2016/10/09/exclusive-new-email-leak-reveals-clinton-campaigns-cozy-press-relationship/ https://theintercept.com/2016/10/09/exclusive-new-email-leak... Go ahead and compare your list of 'news' organization with the leaks from podesta s emails.
- falcrist 8y agoOK. Let's take the names from this article and assume these people are controlled by the DNC rather than just friendly to the Clinton campaign. Let us further assume that their employers are also controlled by the DNC. You can strike ABC, NBC, CBS, NYT, and NPR off of my list. CNN and Fox also have employees named in the article. So... That's still not half. And the assumptions made at the beginning are beyond spurious. Now, I don't comment much here, and I don't know how moderators look on having loosely related conversations in the comments, so I'm probably not going to continue this discussion... But I stand by my point.
- slowmovintarget 8y agoYou keep using the word "control". That's a strawman argument.
- slowmovintarget 8y agoI didn't say "controlled" I said "coordinated with" implying a partnership. We know from the Clinton and Podesta e-mail leaks (remember their content?!? it was kind of important) that ABC, CBS, NBC, MSNBC, NYT, Bloomberg, and Politico all had "journalists" amenable to planting or slanting stories. These weren't just op-ed pieces either.
- falcrist 8y agoHaving friendly journalists in a news organization doesn't imply you control or even have a partnership with that news organization.
- oh_sigh 8y agoIf your friendship with a journalist affects their reporting on issues, or what kind of slant they put on a story, then they are shitty journalists.
- falcrist 8y ago"friendly" in this context means "has similar politics". That's generally what the article was pointing out with the off record meetings with the Clinton and McCain campaigns. The article talks about the Clinton campaign's attempt to influence these journalists, but not the extent to which they were influenced.
- slowmovintarget 8y agoThis isn't a case of "sure I'm buddies with that DNC guy... shrug". This is a case of journalists adjusting language to fit DNC talking points, journalists omitting components of stories after checking with DNC operatives for approval/disapproval. These journalists compromised the work they were doing in order to further political concerns of the DNC. That confirms partnership, no implying or inferring needed. FWIW: I still never said "control". It is certainly easy to argue the DNC doesn't control the media. The problem is that such control is unnecessary as many journalists were and continue to be willing partners in turning news stories into one-sided political pieces, while be unwilling to label such work editorial. i.e. "Not doing their jobs."
- falcrist 8y agoI found the commenting rules, but I don't see a way to edit my comment, so the caps emphasis will need to remain at least until I get home and open a proper browser. My apologies.
- rapsey 8y agoI am marvelling at your naivete
- jessaustin 8y agoWas any statement in parent comment incorrect?
- rapsey 8y agoIf it was incorrect I would say so. It is naive because it can only come from an idealistic worldview that has nothing to do with reality. > Any government that is doing these things does not represent we the people. It barely ever did and it certainly does not now. > the government appears to really wish to control our narrative. As if there ever existed one that did not want to.
- jessaustin 8y agoMy reading is that of a response to that "idealistic worldview" (not actually idealistic, but rather cynical enough to pretend so). People say stupid shit like "elections mean that the government is controlled by the people" all the time, even here on HN where many people are fairly intelligent and also mostly honest. Clear evidence to the contrary doesn't always make it through the media filter, so I don't see the harm in highlighting that evidence.
- gergles 8y agoJust a note to try to derail the inevitable political handwringing: these documents are all dated from 2014 or 2015 and therefore have nothing to do with the current administration, beyond that they haven't revoked them and replaced them with something else.
- unstuckdev 8y agoI'm more curious about the status quo before the rules. They might have been put in place due to abuses in the absence of clear policy. The government shouldn't target journalists at all, but it will, and clear policy may rein in darker impulses.
- yasp 8y agoFISA surveillance is intended to go after spies. If government shouldn't target journalists at all, won't spies just become journalists?
- unstuckdev 8y agoGovernment is going to target journalists regardless of the ethics and legality of it. Joining a profession with less access to vital government secrets and more scrutiny by government than any other seems like an odd choice for a spy.
- bluGill 8y agoJournalist is also a good cover. There are a lot of secrets that are not actually secret if you just spend some time looking in the right places. However normal people do their day job and go home to the family so they don't figure out much. An example: a "office building" that has a large underground lab. Normal people see a construction site with a few dump trucks of dirt leaving. A spy will watch long enough to figure out it isn't just a few dump trucks, a lot more dirt is leaving than should be. A journalist has cover to watch long enough. It is a double edge sword. A spy who can copy the real blueprints, or works in the lab is better. However the people who have that access to that might not talk at any price so you take what you can get.
- yardie 8y agoJust another reminder that the Justice Department is not your ally. Sessions, Mueller, Rosenstein, and Comey; if they eat their own fine by me. But don't think for a second if they aren't working against your interests while they are arguing over Russian influence.
- prolikewh0a 8y agoA lot of left wing Americans seemingly threw out their ability to question once the DNC started making claims that Russia was responsible for Trump. They trust these people hands down, without realizing that Mueller was instrumental in lying about the Iraq WMD's [1]. While I'm glad massive fraud charges are being brought up on Trump's friends & cabinet, I'm hesitant to not seriously question anything about foreign influence from the same people who lied us into the Iraq war. [1] https://youtu.be/uTDO-kuOGTQ https://youtu.be/uTDO-kuOGTQ
- jessaustin 8y agoFrom that perspective, it's possible to see Trump's schizophrenic foreign policy as a sort of negotiation from his previous stated position of non-interventionism. He could get away with peace talks with Kim only by countering them with saber-rattling toward Iran. He has avoided the planned Syrian War but still managed to drop bombs in Syria. The military-industrial-media complex wants Endless War, and they were only too happy to corrupt progressives in order to pressure Trump. The biggest risk now is that D's take back both houses, and Trump starts another disastrous war in order to avoid impeachment and removal from office.
- oh_sigh 8y agoWhy would you need to threaten war with Iran in order to have peace talks with NK?
- a_tractor 8y agoIts about who is pulling the strings. Obviously NK doesnt care about the US'relationship with Iran, and visa versa. What OP is talking about, the people who Trump is "negotiating" with on this level, desire an "existential threat" "boogey man" they can use to fear monger and mind control their constituents into a state of distraction and permissiveness, among many other purposes. The idea here is that Trump was able to trade peace with NK if he allows the creation of a new one, Iran. Iran might serve these interests better than NK, and NK might serve Trumps'. I'm not saying I agree with that assessment or not, but it is interesting. Its all behind-the-scenes realpolitik. Who really knows.
- benmmurphy 8y agoThe FISA court should be abolished or needs very serious reforms. The original reasoning was for surveilling foreign spies but it is now being used to monitor journalists (presumably American as well!) and American's involved in political campaigns. If the FBI had disclosed it would be using the FISA court in this manner when the laws were proposed the laws would not have received support.
- GVIrish 8y agoFISA court is still about national security and espionage cases. The reason they may want a FISA warrant on a journalist is because we know that there are foreign intelligence services that use journalists to spread disinformation, propaganda, and stolen classified materials. So for example, RT America was recently forced to get FARA registration, as was some Chinese media outlets. One development in the Paul Manafort case is that he admitted to pushing disinformation to American media to support his Ukrainian clients. If there were other avenues of hostile foreign influence operations attempting to subvert US media, a FISA warrant would be one way it might be done. One thing to remember about the FISA court is that it's not about surveillance for the purpose of normal criminal prosecutions, it's about supporting national security, which often doesn't necessarily lead to criminal charges. It may mean just monitoring what adversaries are up to. This is also why the bar for FISA warrants is different than it is for normal criminal investigations. At any rate, the FISA court's powers can certainly be abused and meaningful oversight is needed. Especially in this time with increasing politicization of federal law enforcement. Spying on journalists gets into dangerous territory, so yes, people should pay close attention here.
- close04 8y agoIs the success rate of this method able to justify using it? Because any system that generates too many false positives/negatives needs to be redesigned or reformed.
- GVIrish 8y agoWould be very difficult to ascertain because a lot of the information gleaned from a FISA warrant may feed into counter-espionage efforts, which by their very nature are rarely going to become public. As I said, sometimes what the FBI does is just monitor the actions of spies and their assets for a long time, without taking action. Then, they may abruptly roll up a bunch of spies at once after watching them for year. We saw that a few years ago with Operation Ghost Stories where a bunch of deep cover Russian intelligence officers got deported (there was a lot of media coverage of a particular attractive agent: Anna Chapman).
- prolikewh0a 8y agoI feel like Noam Chomsky's 'Manufacturing Consent' needs a 2019 update to the propaganda model.
- rapsey 8y agoIn what way? Nothing really has changed, it has only gotten more extreme and blatant.
- mtgx 8y agoSo something has changed then?
- drak0n1c 8y agoChomsky is already speaking out about how Russia scapegoating is promoting undue faith in intelligence agencies and distracting Americans from actual policy issues.
- pwned1 8y agoPower corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely.
- tptacek 8y agoI'm not sure what I'm reading here. The only documents in this tranche that discuss FISA orders make it harder to get a FISA order targeting an overseas journalist, not easier.
- motohagiography 8y agoWe need a list of lists and how you get on them, and off them, then a service for managing them.
- throw2016 8y agoIf China, Russia or any other country target journalists its oppression and totalitarianism. If the US does it its not? This is alarming double standards by jingoists who do not believe in any values. FISA courts, secret processes, secret orders are completely arbitrary and undemocratic. You can't hollow out the very things that define democracy and continue to call it that. How does a secret court fit in a democracy? How does targeting journalists with secret courts and orders fit a democracy? Then what is the difference between totalitarianism and democracy? Threads on China, Russia and others are full of commentators lecturing others about democracy and human rights. How can you hold others accountable for the very things you are guilty of yourself, how can this kind of hypocrisy pass in informed discussion? It's this alarming dissonance, hypocrisy and complete failure to hold anyone accountable since Snowden's revelations that is providing cover for these kinds of shocking overreach. And in the absence of mainstream protest and activism it will keep getting worse.
- hulton 8y agounConstitutional. Simple as that.