2 ms·
You are absolutely right but the problem started with the company selling the tracker [1]. The original reason why wearables and health trackers work in the clo
by Fnoord 8y ago
You are absolutely right but the problem started with the company selling the tracker [1]. The original reason why wearables and health trackers work in the cloud is because they are tiny and don't muster the resources to have everything within the device; hence thin client. However, smartphones work reasonably enough to have the data hosted there. Convenience of convergence? Then why isn't the data stored with zero knowledge principle? With smart speakers it seems the same story. Why not host an offline Wikipedia, have speech analysis, and have the device work offline 24/7 as long as its killswitch is disabled? Furthermore, what we need is a standard to self-host (such as Yunohost. OTOH, many homes are worse secured than clouds.
[1] We need legislation to make the practices illegal, or hold these people accountable, not in the least in case of data breaches. That's just the top of the iceberg.
- saagarjha 8y agoI’d like to point out that not every tracker does this; Apple Watch being the most notable example.
- adrianN 8y agoJust have the tracker store the data locally and sync with your phone or computer via a cable or bluetooth. "The cloud" was never necessary unless you eventually want to monetize the data. In fact it doesn't make sense for the manufacturers to provide that infrastructure unless they plan on getting money out of it. It's not like servers come for free.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y agoYou see, the problem is that people universally accepted "the cloud". When Alexa first appeared it was beyond me why anyone would buy. Turns out Amazon's marketing worked so well it's now a standard household item in many homes. The constant calling home by all Android phones is another example - we learned how to live with it. Health data tracking seems just another tiny step. Until people revolt against this huge issue, there is no way things change as greed has no limits as history shown us.