2 ms·
I have a mixed opinion on bonuses. On the one hand as engineers get more senior it becomes more possible for them to 'move the needle' in the parlance and do s
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
I have a mixed opinion on bonuses.
On the one hand as engineers get more senior it becomes more possible for them to 'move the needle' in the parlance and do something really impactful for the company. Its also possible that they might do something really great one year and nothing notable for the next four years. So bonuses allow you to reward for work done "above an beyond" without a long term salary expense hit that might not be as justified in later years. So in that regard I think making more of the pay variable as you get more senior makes a lot of sense.
But then bonuses can also be used as tools by managers to foster unhealthy behavior. When they are a 'beauty contest' (basically people who the manager likes get good bonuses unrelated to their contribution) then they are demoralizing to the group and promote sycophantic behavior over outstanding technical contribution.
When I was at Google they tried to have their cake and eat it too, on the one hand they said your bonus was all algorithmic (personal multiplier, company multiplier, salary) but they refused to tell you what your personal multiplier was. So your manager could give you a really happy sounding review and a personal multiplier of .1 or something and you had no way of knowing if what you did was really useful or if they were just blowing smoke. It was pretty clear that management reverted to what managers do, which is lean the rewards toward people that supported their agenda and away from people who didn't, regardless of "impact" (positive or negative!) to the company.
Bonus plans that work are ones where you establish clear measurable goals for the year which can be objectively adjudicated. If you make all the goals you get the full promised bonus, you make a fraction of them, you get the prorated bonus. Weak managers will push back on those because they don't have the tools to evaluate the difficulty of the goals. Something I suggested at Google could be peer reviewed (they still didn't like it).
I don't have any magic bullets here, having experienced no less than six differently structured bonus programs they all seemed to leave some folks feeling they were treated unfairly.