4 ms·
Alternatively: People with spare time/money are happier People with spare time/money can afford to put more time/money into their dog’s wellbeing. It reminds
by olliej 8y ago
Alternatively:
People with spare time/money are happier
People with spare time/money can afford to put more time/money into their dog’s wellbeing.
It reminds me of an article saying women who owned horses lived longer than those who didn’t. Then it was pointed out that women who can afford horses are vastly more likely to have health insurance and/or access to better healthcare. Which obviously wouldn’t make as good a headline.
- s0rce 8y agoThese factors are often controlled for (or attempted) in these sorts of studies.
- olliej 8y agoI don’t see any reference to controls in the article (and the paper is paywalled, because obviously it would be :D). That said reading more closely it’s a study of 36 people. 36 how does this get published? And then get an article???
- ekovarski 8y agoI believe it was a group of 76 people - 36 had dogs with separation anxiety and 40 were okay. The article can be summed up with this, "It is possible that humans with higher levels of stress do not have a relaxed relationship with their dogs." This is what stress does and it's not only applicable to the dogs as I am sure friends, family and co-workers would also have less than a relaxed relationship with the individual.
- Fomite 8y ago36 who reported behavior problems, and 40 who did not. Veterinary medicine generally has small studies, because there's absolutely no money in veterinary medicine. The authors note that for most of the variables people are talking about, the groups were pretty balanced. Which isn't surprising given they used snowball sampling for their recruitment - that's good at getting homogeneous groups.
- olliej 8y agoOops so 70 odd people. That’s still nowhere near reasonable to make the claims they’re making. Being hard to get a decent sample size isn’t a justification for making unreasonable claims. A few people have commented on the nature of the samples group (namely that they were homogenous, etc), but that’s not mentioned in the article, and the paper is behind a paywall. If you want a press release for your paper you need to make sure the relevant data is available to people who otherwise only have access to the article.
- canadapups 8y agoMy wife is a dog breeder. My anecdotal sample size is getting close to the sample size of the study. In one litter you will get such a large range of personalities even with same parents and being raised the same. And then there’s such a big range of behaviours between the breeds. For example, weimaraners are predisposed to separation anxiety. In addition, some owners adopt or rescue dogs who had bad experiences. With the article behind a paywall, I’m guessing a sample size of 70 is way too small to come up with something insightful. How on earth could they come up with a “negative spiral” from the data. Sounds made up. Anyway, I’ve stopped judging owners based on the behaviour of their dogs.
- adrianN 8y agoIt's the same for children.
- Fomite 8y ago"If you want a press release for your paper you need to make sure the relevant data is available to people who otherwise only have access to the article." You're assuming the authors of the article have more than a modicum of control over what appears in an unrelated print magazine. Having been on the end of that: They don't. Also, 70 subjects is decently well powered for their analysis, which is actually pretty simple. It's not nearly what I'd prefer, but it's just a bunch of Mann-Whitney U tests and chi-squared tests of association.
- Fomite 8y ago"No significant differences were found in the sociodemographic variables, as listed in Table 1" Those include age, marital status, education, and employment status. Now if you wanted to criticize the paper you might pick that the study is out of 76 dogs total recruited by snowball sampling, which actually explains the homogenity of the study population. Which makes sense, because there are very few veterinary medicine studies with large samples, because we don't fund vet. med.
- msiyer 8y agoSpare time is important, money not all. Homeless people (homeless due to circumstances or by choice) can have extremely well-behaved dogs. Gypsy groups, tribal people and wandering monks in India are examples I have seen.