3 ms·

Was that computer connected to the Internet? If not, then no problem.

EvanAnderson 8y ago
Define "the Internet". Do contractors plug laptops into the network with these "air gapped" computers? How about IoT devices? Printers? I can't recall who said it, but a venerable infosec practitioner once said "Think of an air gap as a very high-latency connection."
- caymanjim 8y ago
  Air gapping is often "good enough" protection for all but the most sensitive and desirable targets, even if people plug things into them all the time. An air-gapped PC might get a virus that way, which could be damaging in some way, but it's not something that most companies need to worry about. A counter-example is something like Stuxnet; that likely leapt an air gap, but it was exquisitely targeted for that scenario. I'd worry about this as a nuclear component manufacturer.
  - FactolSarin 8y ago
    Stuxnet was spread via a USB stick. You know what doesn't have a USB port? A computer from 1995. :) An ancient piece of air-gaped hardware is pretty bulletproof. I bet the NSA would have more trouble hacking it than a fully up to date install of <modern OS> that is on the Internet. It's very possible the biggest threat vector is leaving the door unlocked.
    - 3pt14159 8y ago
      Even though I'm largely against air gaps as a defensive measure, there is something to this. Though I think the breadth of the problem isn't properly appreciated. It's too dimensional. There are too many unforeseen interactions and complications with computers and the humans in the organizations that run them. Even leaving aside moles[0] people trust to easily and often have interests that are odds with their organization. [0] Which, why should we? The world has moles.
cuboidGoat 8y ago
Yes, of course it was. Anything with a network port was plugged into the lan, which was plugged into the free router that came with the business broadband package. Which was also the only firewall and it was still on factory defaults other than the wireless password. As far as I can tell this is more or less standard business practice in the small to medium enterprise sector here, which is to say, the vast majority of specialist engineering companies in the UK.
darpa_escapee 8y ago
Stuxnet.

Define "the Internet". Do contractors plug laptops into the network with these "air gapped" computers? How about IoT devices? Printers? I can't recall who said it, but a venerable infosec practitioner once said "Think of an air gap as a very high-latency connection."

caymanjim 8y ago
Air gapping is often "good enough" protection for all but the most sensitive and desirable targets, even if people plug things into them all the time. An air-gapped PC might get a virus that way, which could be damaging in some way, but it's not something that most companies need to worry about. A counter-example is something like Stuxnet; that likely leapt an air gap, but it was exquisitely targeted for that scenario. I'd worry about this as a nuclear component manufacturer.
- FactolSarin 8y ago
  Stuxnet was spread via a USB stick. You know what doesn't have a USB port? A computer from 1995. :) An ancient piece of air-gaped hardware is pretty bulletproof. I bet the NSA would have more trouble hacking it than a fully up to date install of <modern OS> that is on the Internet. It's very possible the biggest threat vector is leaving the door unlocked.
  - 3pt14159 8y ago
    Even though I'm largely against air gaps as a defensive measure, there is something to this. Though I think the breadth of the problem isn't properly appreciated. It's too dimensional. There are too many unforeseen interactions and complications with computers and the humans in the organizations that run them. Even leaving aside moles[0] people trust to easily and often have interests that are odds with their organization. [0] Which, why should we? The world has moles.

cuboidGoat 8y ago

Yes, of course it was. Anything with a network port was plugged into the lan, which was plugged into the free router that came with the business broadband package. Which was also the only firewall and it was still on factory defaults other than the wireless password. As far as I can tell this is more or less standard business practice in the small to medium enterprise sector here, which is to say, the vast majority of specialist engineering companies in the UK.

darpa_escapee 8y ago

Stuxnet.