3 ms·
The reviews are here https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-018-05739-8/MediaObjects/41467_2018_5739_MOESM1_ESM.pdf https://static-conte
by yorwba 8y ago
The reviews are here https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41467-018-05739-8/MediaObjects/41467_2018_5739_MOESM1_ESM.pdf https://static-content.springer.com/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs414...
The authors' final response to referee #2:
We thank the referee for the clarification of their earlier comment, which we indeed
misunderstood. It is of course correct that the observable of the measurement leading
to
z
does not commute with the one corresponding to the measurement of
w
. This
also means that the values
z
and
w
cannot be defined
simultaneously
(in the sense
of “at the same time”).
To explain how our argument avoids this problem, note first that the measurements
take place at different times (as pointed out in the reply above). Concretely,
z
is measured at time
n
:10 and
w
is measured at time
n
:30. Note also that, in all
statements we are using, we always explicitly specify the time at which a variable is
supposed to have a given value. Whenever we are talking about
z
, the corresponding
time lies (strictly) before
n
:30, whereas we only talk about what value
w
has at times
after
n
:30. We hence never need to assume that
z
and
w
are available at the same
time.
To clarify this in the manuscript, we have changed the labelling of all statements.
They now have a superscript which indicates at what time a statement has been
made by an agent.
- lostmsu 8y agoDisclaimer: in no way I am an expert in physics. I don't event have any degree in it. Plainly speaking, this argument does not make sense, because there's no such thing as simultaneity. The way I see it, the commuting argument tells what you, an observer to the entire system, can or can not see at some fixed point in spacetime, that is casually descended from the points where observations occur. Anyway, the whole discussion about validity of interpretations does not make any sense to me, as long as they represent the same underlying math.
- millstone 8y agoHere the argument is about commuting observables and isn't relativistic. For example, position and momentum are non-commuting observables. If you measure both, and then ask "what is the position of this particle," you have to know whether the position was measured first (in which case the position of the particle is still known), or whether the momentum was measured, so now the position is no longer known.
- lostmsu 8y agoI think mistreatment of causality might still be another explanation for the result. In particular, in the iterative process, that authors suggested to use to get w=ok, z=ok, each iteration must be connected to the previous in some QM encodable way, eg as { |continue>, |halt> }, that must be set in the last step, and measured in the first, therefore combining all participants into a single entangled QM system. It is not immediately obvious, that this addition would not affect the outcome of experiment, and hence should at very least be included in the paper.