3 ms·
It seems like a weird choice to me. Zig's standard library functions that require allocation take the allocator as a parameter, and return oom errors back up to
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
It seems like a weird choice to me. Zig's standard library functions that require allocation take the allocator as a parameter, and return oom errors back up to the caller to do with as they please. Usually, the caller will also just kick that error up until it reaches the top of the call stack and gets caught by the default panic handler, but at any point they can choose to handle it however they want. Handling the error by kicking it up the call stack is a single keyword at the callsite.
As a bonus, this means that when you're reading code you can easily spot the function calls that have a possibility of failing.
- steveklabnik 8y agoYeah, I specifically added the "in Rust" here because I know Zig really cares about this problem. I haven't actually used contemporary Zig enough to be able to say anything about its approach, though. > Zig's standard library functions that require allocation take the allocator as a parameter, and return oom errors back up to the caller to do with as they please. You could do something like this in Rust. Here's a function that accepts a vector and pushes something onto it: fn foo(v: &mut Vec<i32>, item: i32) { v.push_back(item); } (Keeping it non-generic to simplify.) Does the data structure hold the allocator, or the function? What if I created a list with one allocator, but called push_back with another? It'd have to be in the structure, right? Given that, here's what this feature would look like, roughly, if Vec<T> supported it: fn foo<A: Allocator>(v: &mut Vec<i32, A>, item: i32) -> Result<(), Box<Error>> { v.push_back(item)?; } This is significantly more boilerplate. The type signature is more than twice as long! You'd also have to adjust the caller: // before foo(&mut v, 5); // after foo(&mut v, 5)?; Of course, it'd be possible to maybe reduce this with langauge features. What does this look like in Zig?
- AndyKelley 8y agoHere's an excerpt from std.ArrayList[1]: pub fn ArrayList(comptime T: type) type { return struct { const Self = @This(); raw_items: []T, len: usize, allocator: *Allocator, // ... pub fn append(self: *Self, item: T) !void { const new_item_ptr = try self.addOne(); new_item_ptr.* = item; } pub fn addOne(self: *Self) !*T { const new_length = self.len + 1; try self.ensureCapacity(new_length); return self.addOneAssumeCapacity(); } // ... }; } test "std.ArrayList.basic" { var bytes: [1024]u8 = undefined; const allocator = &std.heap.FixedBufferAllocator.init(bytes[0..]).allocator; var list = ArrayList(i32).init(allocator); try list.append(1); try list.append(2); try list.append(3); assert(list.len == 3); } In summary, functions that can fail have an inferred error set, or an explicit one[2]. At the callsite of functions that can fail will either be `if`, `while`, `catch`, or `try`, in order to deal with the error case. [1]: https://github.com/ziglang/zig/blob/e3d8cae35a5d194386eacd9afa4f496111a37e16/std/array_list.zig https://github.com/ziglang/zig/blob/e3d8cae35a5d194386eacd9a... [2]: https://ziglang.org/documentation/master/#Error-Set-Type https://ziglang.org/documentation/master/#Error-Set-Type
- steveklabnik 8y agoNeat! So yeah, reducing Result to ! and inferring errors makes this way less boiler-plate-y. One of Rust's core design decisions is that we should never do type inference for function definitions, so we can't do this. And yeah, if you hold a pointer to the allocator instead of parameterizing by it, that helps too. With that in mind, fn append(&mut self, item: i32) -> Result<(), Box<Error>> { v.push_back(item)?; } In today's Rust, which is sort of what already happens; a given instance can't change the allocator, but refers to the global one. I don't have a great handle on the tradeoffs from keeping a pointer vs parameterization. Anyway, yeah, if we allowed for inferring the error type, that would make this almost the same as Zig here. Stealing your syntax: fn append(&mut self, item: i32) -> !() { v.push_back(item)?; } A four character diff from current Rust. Very cool! Thanks for the elaboration. That's quite nice.
- flurrything 8y agoWhat do these Zig functions do in systems with overcommit ? (that is, Linux, MacOS, *BSDs, Android, iOS, ...).
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoSame thing as everyone else: play russian roulette with the OOM-killer and hope that whatever was important to the user didn't get destroyed. Can't really do anything about the OS lying to you.
- flurrything 8y agoHow do Zig programmers using Linux or MacOS validate that their OOM handling is correct?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoThere's an allocator in the standard library that is specifically designed to fail. https://github.com/ziglang/zig/blob/master/std/debug/failing_allocator.zig https://github.com/ziglang/zig/blob/master/std/debug/failing...