9 ms·
I think people trying to interpret quantum mechanics are mislead by saying that probability wave upon observation collapses to precise value that upon next meas
by scotty79 8y ago
I think people trying to interpret quantum mechanics are mislead by saying that probability wave upon observation collapses to precise value that upon next measurement stays exactly the same. That's unrealistic because no measurement is of perfect precission. Next measurement will give slightly different value. So we really can't tell if we have one exact value or still a probability wave just reshaped to very narrow thing by interaction needed to do the measurement. We can make probability wave wider and fuzzier again just by scattering particle we measure of some other unmeasured particle.
That's how I understand quantum mechanics wave-particle duality. That there's no duality. There are just waves that interact and reshape each other through that interactions. And the only reason that we think of them sometimes as sort of little billiard balls is because annoyingly equations that govern evolution of narrow and sharp probability waves look (not accidentally) exactly the same as primary school level math that governs billard balls.
- sixo 8y agoIf you make 3 subsequent measurements of different but related variables (like a vector component wrt to 3 different axes) the 3rd's probability distribution will depend on the value you observed in the 2nd observation in a way that cannot be replicated without the 2nd. Meaning it's not just matter of poor precision. See the Stern-gorlach experiment.
- kurthr 8y agoI think the problem he points out is that the measurement (e.g.the polarizer/slit/field) is never perfect. In fact the measurements are also made of materials at finite temperature with quantum effects so the subsequent probabilistic results won't be "exact". Of course you can design the measurements to be exponentially insensitive to those variations. However, when you build a sequence of measurements each exponentially sensitive to that variation you make setting up each individual measurement ever more difficult. It still doesn't prevent the thought experiment.
- Thespian2 8y agoA simple version of this (not the exact experiment) is to take three polarizing filters. Put one down, and see it reduces the amount of light passing through. Put a second one down, in line with the first, then rotate it to 90 degrees off. You will observe the light dim until the second filter is completely dark, blocking all the light which passed the first filter. Finally, take the third filter, and place it between the first two, at 45 degrees off, and suddenly light will pass through all three. This very clearly demonstrates that each filter reshapes the wave's polarization, not to a single orientation, but to a narrow band.
- posterboy 8y agoThe inaccuracy persists, e.g. in your comment - "the wave" I can image along literal hand waving. I'm being cynic because this polarization filter experiment had me dumbfounded. Blocking the way between the second and third filter will show no light, as if the third filter wasn't there. It appears as if there is a wave but polarized in a way that doesn't reflect from the hand and the third filter would polarize it again. I believe that's also what you are saying. Only, what is "the wave"? > a narrow band. Are you agreeing with Scotty79 above? What band? But, anyway, I don't see the analogy to Stern-Gerlach (which I only skimmed quickly on wikipedia).
- scotty79 8y agoYes. Because 2nd measurement will reshape the probability wave of measuresed object. There can't be measurement without interaction and no interaction is without consequences. Also uncertainty principle.
- j1vms 8y agoAre you suggesting that either wave collapse does not occur, or that instead of wave collapse, that there is a wave "narrowing" which is imperceptible to the observer (who observes it as a particle)?
- nabla9 8y agoIt's more correct to say "apparent wave function collapse" because wave function collapse as a real physical phenomenon or event is just a hypothesis in some interpretations. Mathematically "appeared collapse" is explained by decoherence. It provides an explanation for the observation of wave function collapse when the system and the environment mix in irreversible way.
- phkahler 8y ago>> It's more correct to say "apparent wave function collapse" because wave function collapse as a real physical phenomenon or event is just a hypothesis in some interpretations. Wave function collapse is fiction IMO. There is no observable difference between a particle whose wave function has collapsed and one that isn't. If there was an observable difference we could place an emitter of entangled particle pairs mid-way between two observers (Alice and Bob) arbitrarily far apart. Alice could either turn on her measurements of the particles that arrive on here end or leave it off. This would cause Bob to receive either a stream of particles with collapsed wave functions, or a stream of uncollapsed ones. Alice can now transmit information to Bob faster than the speed of light using Morse code, which is not possible. The reality is that Bob can't tell anything about the superposition of states (or lack of) by observing his particles.
- kgilpin 8y ago> receive either a stream of particles with collapsed wave functions, or a stream of uncollapsed ones I don’t think there’s any way for Bob to determine whether the particle stream has been measured by Alice or not.
- 8y ago