4 ms·
> they make markets more efficient, deflate bubbles, root out fraud and delusion, and generally make the world better with their unpopular and negative activity
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> they make markets more efficient, deflate bubbles, root out fraud and delusion, and generally make the world better with their unpopular and negative activity.
This is true when they're shorting Enron or some other fraudulent entity. The issue is that you can short any high risk high reward play and make money if they fail. But then enough shorting can cause them to fail, because it makes it more difficult to raise money by selling new shares or using shares as collateral. And causing a large undertaking to fail when it otherwise wouldn't have is obviously not efficient.
It also increases volatility because on one side the existence of the shorts makes the company more likely to fail, but if the company succeeds anyway or even just stays the course then there could be a "short squeeze" as the shorts have to buy back the shares they owe when no one is really interested in selling, so the share price skyrockets. It's not exactly a moderating influence.
- bb2018 8y agoCould you provide an example where this was the case? I'm not familiar with any companies with a sound business model that were hurt by shorts.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoChoose any company that was shorted and nearly succeeded but didn't. Are you questioning the mechanism by which it operates? If you raise borrowing costs for a company it hurts them and the ones already at the margin may fold.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoSo you can't provide a single example of a company whose downfall was due to shorts? If it was that common, seems like it would have been easy for you to just list a few dozen examples instead of handwave it away.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> So you can't provide a single example of a company whose downfall was due to shorts? How is someone supposed to prove that in a specific case? It would be the case for a company that failed by a specific margin whose total borrowing costs were increased by more than that margin. Which requires speculating what their share price would have been in the alternative, calculating the resulting effect on their contemporary borrowing cost (which data is available where?), then evaluating their entire business to determine how much additional capital they would have needed to survive. It would take hours to calculate and be subject to unlimited debate about the reasons and margins by which they failed. But if you really want an example based on pure speculation, Kodak. They made their share of mistakes but if it had been easier for them to raise funding to compete in digital markets once they changed course they might not have ended in bankruptcy. And I still haven't heard any argument as to the flaw in the general principle.
- bb2018 8y agoThe flaw to that argument (from my perspective) is that if a company wants more capital they can find lenders, issue bonds, or even issue new shares. If Kodak has a real way to pivot they could have raised money. Instead, it is pretty clear their business was dying and they had no way to compete against larger tech companies who could provide a better product with cheaper costs to consumers.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The flaw to that argument (from my perspective) is that if a company wants more capital they can find lenders, issue bonds, or even issue new shares. Well yes, but that's the problem. If you issue new shares when your share price is lower, you get less money and it may not be enough. You can't just sell an unlimited number of shares, each one dilutes the others and at some point no one will buy them. And all the other lenders rely on your ability to issue new shares to pay them back if it comes down to that, so they won't lend to you if your share price is too low, or will demand interest rates you can't afford. > Instead, it is pretty clear their business was dying and they had no way to compete against larger tech companies who could provide a better product with cheaper costs to consumers. They could have at least been GoPro if not the company supplying the cameras in half the phones on the market.
- gbacon 8y agoPlease humor us with three examples where this actually occurred.
- wgerard 8y ago> The issue is that you can short any high risk high reward play and make money if they fail Or (as a short) you can lose massive amounts of money if they're incredibly successful - in fact, your losses are actually uncapped. And anyway, that seems like a good thing - there should be a force tempering high risk endeavors. > But then enough shorting can cause them to fail, because it makes it more difficult to raise money by selling new shares or using shares as collateral. That sounds like a good thing. If your company has an appreciable amount of short interest the likely reason is that the company's overvalued, not that Jim Chanos is colluding with Andrew Left and Bill Ackman just to bring down your company and profit off your failure. Further, I don't know that I've ever seen a mid+ cap company take any sort of significant hit from short interest where there was nothing to substantiate the short's claims, and there have been plenty of inverse situations (companies growing in value even when there were substantial issues brought to light by a short seller). EDIT: Actually I take that back, I have seen some - because the SEC brought fraud charges against them. It's the short version of P&D and it's just as illegal. > And causing a large undertaking to fail when it otherwise wouldn't have is obviously not efficient. On the flip side, causing a large undertaking to fail faster when it was doomed from the beginning is obviously more efficient. > It also increases volatility because on one side the existence of the shorts makes the company more likely to fail Many people are worried that volatility is too low these days (thus why Feb was such a big deal), so I'm not sure that's a great argument.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> And anyway, that seems like a good thing - there should be a force tempering high risk endeavors. The point is that it does the opposite. Suppose you have a high risk company with a million shares and a would-be share price of $1000, but 20% of the shares are shorted so the share price is $900. Now if the company fails, the total losses to the actual shareholders are 8% higher even though the price per share was lower because there are de facto more shares in existence. Meanwhile if the company succeeds, the shareholders make significantly more, because there are de facto 20% more shares in existence and the shareholders paid $900 each instead of $1000, with the shorts having to pay the difference. Which is why the total (e.g. $900 times 1.2M instead of $1000 times 1M) is more -- because it's attracting more total investment into the stock by having the shorts reduce the cost of buying shares today and then heavily subsidize potential gains tomorrow. > If your company has an appreciable amount of short interest the likely reason is that the company's overvalued, not that Jim Chanos is colluding with Andrew Left and Bill Ackman just to bring down your company and profit off your failure. Haven't they tended on average to lose money on shorting? > On the flip side, causing a large undertaking to fail faster when it was doomed from the beginning is obviously more efficient. True in theory, but is that actually what happens? Large companies rarely do anything fast. Even when the shorts are right, it's usually months or years before it all shakes out. And as above, when they're right what they're really doing is increasing total third party exposure to the loss. > Many people are worried that volatility is too low these days (thus why Feb was such a big deal), so I'm not sure that's a great argument. People are worried about volatility as an indicator, not because it's a good in its own right that society benefits from creating artificially.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> you can short any high risk high reward play and make money if they fail You can make a lot more money, much more quickly and with far less risk, squeezing misplaced shorts. There is a lot of capital in the markets scanning for accumulations or nonsensical shorts.
- Lazare 8y ago> But then enough shorting can cause them to fail, because it makes it more difficult to raise money by selling new shares or using shares as collateral. That's one of those ideas that looks kinda of plausible on paper, but doesn't really work in the real world. There's just no real evidence that this is a thing that actually happens, and the people who complain the loudest about it are invariably not victims of it. The current standard-bearer for the "shorts are evil and make people fail!" camp seems to be Musk right now, and there is absolutely zero evidence to support this in the case of Tesla. None of Tesla's issues (with funding or anything else) can be traced back to people shorting the stock. (Well, Musk's strange "taking Tesla private" tweet may have hurt Tesla's ability to raise funding, and perhaps that was part of some sort of incredibly ill-advised response to shorts, but even if so, the cause of Tesla's issue there is Musk, not short-selling per se.) > It's not exactly a moderating influence. On balance, overall, it is. There's extensive evidence of this. For example, China has a list of stocks which you can't short, and when stocks are placed on this list, their volatility increases, even controlling for other factors.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That's one of those ideas that looks kinda of plausible on paper, but doesn't really work in the real world. There's just no real evidence that this is a thing that actually happens, and the people who complain the loudest about it are invariably not victims of it. Can you explain what part of it doesn't really work? It seems kind of odd to ask for evidence of something which is a mathematical formula. If shorts reduce the share price by X before you sell Y new shares then you consequently have X times Y less new capital than you would have. Is the argument supposed to be that shorting the stock doesn't lower the stock price? Granted this doesn't always matter. If a company is not trying to raise funding, what does it matter their cost to raise funding? But sometimes they are. > On balance, overall, it is. There's extensive evidence of this. For example, China has a list of stocks which you can't short, and when stocks are placed on this list, their volatility increases, even controlling for other factors. I can see the argument for it can be, which goes like this: Buyers are overly exuberant so people take out short positions which keep the price from going too high. Then the news is middling and the stock falls somewhat, but the shorts closing their positions keep it from falling more as they buy back shares. But that's assuming the shorts were right. If they're wrong they push the price the opposite of the way it should be going and when the news comes it snaps even harder the other way.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]