14 ms·
I simulated California housing and learned about simulators
- microcolonel 8y agoI think simulation's scientific utility is misunderstood. A model with honest parameters and predictive ability can be used to hypothesize effectively about changes in policy or or the effects of external factors.
- panic 8y agoJust call your model "AI" and people will become interested. You're not p-hacking, you're hand-tuning hyperparameters!
- andrewflnr 8y ago> hand-tuning hyperparameters This is a delightful phrase. I'm going to try to find opportunities to use it.
- ericand 8y agoI loved the reference to the Zen and the art of Motorcycle Maintenance. Like you, A colleague of mine saw parallels in the book to data science (He wrote a series of talks about them. Here's a video with me explaining some of them https://youtu.be/iYRtVwqxjzM https://youtu.be/iYRtVwqxjzM).
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoA ton of good and interesting bits in here, but the real payoff I'm pasting below as I fear others might not make it to the end of the article: _________________________________ In turn, what this means is that the NIMBYs are not all crazy. If you try to improve your home, the neighbourhood, or the region, you will not improve the property values, so don't waste your money (or municipal funds); the property values are already at maximum. But if you build more housing, you run the risk of putting DSR below 1.0 and sending property values into free fall, as they return to "normal" "healthy" market conditions.
- nkurz 8y agoThis might also be useful knowledge to the currently non-voting renters who one day hope to enter the market. It's about half-and-half own vs rent for the Bay Area as a whole, but SF and Oakland are majority renter. Vote now to increase housing stock, and you might soon be able to buy in at a reasonable price!
- burlesona 8y agoFor some definitions of “soon” :)
- nabla9 8y agoSimulation is nonanalytical way to model complex phenomena and try to understand dynamics of it. Just like purely analytic mathiness, the main benefit is that others can point errors and omissions. Peter Norvig does it too: https://github.com/norvig/pytudes/blob/master/ipynb/Economics.ipynb https://github.com/norvig/pytudes/blob/master/ipynb/Economic... What you are simulating is just tiny part of the Economies of agglomeration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economies_of_agglomeration The only working solution to housing is building more densee cities with more housing. Productivity of workers and companies increases as the result of various agglomeration effects.
- salty_biscuits 8y agoOr to figure out how to get an effective distributed work force...
- dahdum 8y agoAuthor has a great grasp of the market, and this simulation is pretty cool. Another way to look at it is the house-price-to-income ratio, San Jose metro is the highest in the nation for individuals, #2 for households. [1] Even better IMHO is price-to-rent ratio, which is the rental price of a home compared to the purchase ($360k home rented at $36k/yr is 10x). SV runs from 35x in SJ to 45x in SF (highest in the nation). Home values can't rise much above this unless income rises. [2] 1. https://www.citylab.com/equity/2018/05/where-the-house-price-to-income-ratio-is-most-out-of-whack/561404/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2018/05/where-the-house-price... 2. https://smartasset.com/mortgage/price-to-rent-ratio-in-us-cities https://smartasset.com/mortgage/price-to-rent-ratio-in-us-ci...
- snarfybarfy 8y agoA Price-to-Rent ratio of 45 is indeed crazy. Implied total return only slightly above 2% with quite some downside risks AND running costs + depreciation. Rents are also quite high and it would still take 45+ years to have it paid off! Any reasonable person would want to rent in such a situation.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Any reasonable person would want to rent in such a situation If both the ratio and the prices were expected to be stable (or, for prices, declining) in the long term, sure. But would a reasonable person expect that?
- a008t 8y agoThere are two options here: 1. People value owning a home irrationally, the price is disconnected from fundamentals 2. People are pricing in future growth. With interest rates being low, this growth can be fairly long-term. The growth is primarily in future rent increases, but also potential interest rate decreases or irrational future growth (as in point 1). Now, for point 2, we can actually calculate implied future growth, and then try to decide whether it is rational or not - e.g. given the market future interest rate expectations. It would also be interesting to know who owns these houses. Did they buy them by really stretching themselves, and any downturn in the area would result in loads of forced sells, temporarily collapsing the market? Or are the owners in no danger of having to sell?
- cryptozeus 8y agoGreat article, this you articulate perfectly what has been on my mind lately “It means raising engineer salary to match the higher cost of living ("cost of living adjustment") is pointless: it translates directly to higher housing prices (X goes up for everyone, so R*X goes up proportionally), which eats the benefit.”
- pmalynin 8y agoWell except its not as simple as that, is it. There are a lot of second and third tier Tech companies in SV (not considering startups even) that can't raise salaries as quickly -- or at all. Also then there is the question of simultaneity, if I'm the first engineer to get a 20k raise then I will be ahead of everyone else, while everyone else catches up.
- almost_usual 8y agoThe landlord will be ahead while tech workers attempt to catch up.
- 01100011 8y agoYeah I'm surprised to see how many companies in the valley still pay low wages compared to the FANGs. I can make anywhere from $120k-300k+ depending on the company.
- sharkmerry 8y ago
- wyldfire 8y agoIs the talent pool more valuable there than elsewhere in the US or elsewhere in the world? Even if you allow for the effect of having drawn talent there over decades, is it that much more valuable? If not, it seems like corporations are making a mistake by investing there. If the government can't be convinced to change the zoning rules, then companies should take some attrition and expand elsewhere.
- qaq 8y agoThey are def. trying but the answer to your question so far seems to be yes.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- burlesona 8y agoThis is already being questioned and these days a lot of companies are moving out. However as an engineering manager who has done hiring in multiple locations around the US I will say the sheer size of the talent pool does matter. It’s like the Napoleon quote, quantity has a quality all its own.
- zellyn 8y agoThere's a certain critical mass to it. We moved out to SF for five years while I worked at YouTube, then back to Atlanta to be close to family (and afford a house). There are two or three awesome places to work in Atlanta. In SF I knew I could get out of bed, trip over my shoelaces, and accidentally land on six fantastic places to work before breakfast…
- zellyn 8y agobtw, if you're in Atlanta, or interested, you should come have (free) lunch with us sometime at Square Atlanta. If you're experienced, and interested in Go+Java infrastructure/tooling work, hit me up: I'm trying to help get an Atlanta PlatEng (“Platform Engineering”) presence off the ground and might be hiring soon…
- jpollock 8y agoWhen I bought, I noticed that every 10mins closer (rush hour driving) to Google was worth US$100k, and every point on the school rating was worth another US$100k. This led to an interesting gradient between downtown San Jose (bad schools) and Mountain View (good schools/close to Google). The same thing applied to Cupertino/Apple, with Willow Glen having better schools but a longer commute. We drew a circle on the map showing the longest distance I was willing to commute (on a bike), and bought on the circle.
- sand500 8y ago>We drew a circle on the map showing the longest distance I was willing to commute (on a bike), and bought on the circle. Walkscore makes it easy to figure this out but I don't know if Redfin or Zillow have this too https://walk.sc/2xuy0vk https://walk.sc/2xuy0vk
- jld 8y agoWalk Score was acquired by Redfin in 2014. Walk scores are on their listing pages, but I am not sure why they don't allow you to filter by Walk Score in the Redfin search UI. https://www.geekwire.com/2014/redfin-buys-walk-score-marking-first-acquisition-company-history/ https://www.geekwire.com/2014/redfin-buys-walk-score-marking...
- chroem- 8y agoMalicious startup idea: a company whose business model is driving rent-seeking real estate speculators into financial ruin. The company would buy residential real estate in a low cost of living area, followed by setting up offices there and paying its employees a high salary to do absolutely nothing. When rent-seekers inevitably drive up housing prices to as high as wages will tolerate, the company sells its real estate holdings in that location and moves somewhere else.
- itchyouch 8y agoI'd imagine that something like this would need to be done on enormous scale to make such a dent. How many engineers would a company need to hire? 1000? 5000? 100,000?
- PHGamer 8y agoso basically we need to reduce zoning laws and kill the market which has always been in my mind. No one wants to say it but the truth is a healthy market means housing isnt worth that much which means its not a good investment (which it shouldnt be, it should be a place to live)
- segmondy 8y agoBTW, I'm a bit disappointed that this didn't use pysim.
- SethTro 8y agoI really Identified with 'Is simulation "real science"?' IMO it's no small wonder that AI look and feel human to us. As a heuristic we've prematurely discarded all the ones that don't.
- torgian 8y agoFunny startup idea: buy a bunch of real estate in those areas, then rent out capsule homes for a hundred bucks a month. Stuff them into these overpriced homes and take a bunch of cash-strapped renters away from those that are pushing the rent up. You’ll lose money on upkeep and taxes probably, but its still a fun idea.
- a008t 8y agoSo does social housing make the situation better or worse? Looking at London, for example. There are surprisingly few nice areas in London to live in with a family, in close proximity to the City, even if you had loads and loads of money. That has always seemed very odd to me. As a result, the few reasonably nice houses that you do find, have prices that are "maxed-out" - that is, if you are in the "high-earning class" - e.g. working in finance in London - and buy them, all your "excess earnings" are sucked into mortgage or rent, and you are left no better off than if you were in a median job, except now you live in an ok neighbourhood close to work. If you had no planning laws etc. and it was easy for property developers to develop how they like, you would think that the area around where the highest paying jobs are would be more uniformly nice, developed in such a way that the people working in those jobs would want to settle there. So the supply of houses for those workers would increase. At the same time, low-income workers would likely be pushed further out, with some finding that the extra commute makes working in the city centre not worth it. Thus the wages for the low-income workers will probably go up as the supply of labour goes down. It seems like the overall utility would go up - London would become a nicer place to live in, crime rates would drop, etc.
- rustyboy 8y agoUnfortunately for London property has become a massive asset. If you look at who owns most of the houses you'll see that it is foreign buyers, the wealthy with multiple houses, and extreme landlordism. This is artificially raising the price, even though there are plenty of empty lots sitting around, forcing crowd out without actually creating any better property. Socialized/affordable housing might help, but typically once the market is so distorted not many people can afford to live there and thus even if their rent is cheap they're going to leave. This property is then bought by the wealthy and traded for an asset, repeating the cycle.
- a008t 8y agoBut is the price really disconnected from rents on comparable properties? The way I think about it, is that if buying a house can yield you 2-3% - either through expected house price growth or through rental income or both - someone will be buying it at that price, because it makes economic sense in a low interest rate environment (i.e. you won't find any other assets with similar risk that will give you a higher yield). Who ends up being the buyer is not particularly relevant - as long as the yield is there, somebody will be buying at that price. The question then is, 1. Are rents too high? Unlikely, rents are very much supply/demand driven. 2. Are yields too low than what is justified? Possibly. Rental yields in central London seem to be around 3.5%, which seems quite low if you take into account the costs and the risks. 3. Are investors pricing in too much price growth? Possibly - related to point 2 above. But it doesn't seem like current buyers are paying completely irrational prices for the houses. So it does not seem like we are in a bubble. Of course, if interest rates go up, we will see housing drop, and as expectations of future price growth are reduced because of that, we should see a bigger decrease in house prices than is warranted by interest rate increase alone. Add to that the potential of some people not being able to pay their mortgage at higher interest and being forced to sell, and the prices should dip even more than "intrinsic value". If this effect propagates to the wider economy, people might lose their jobs, forcing more people to sell, resulting in a full-blown liquidity event where it becomes a buyers' market for a short while. Now, whether interest rates will go up significantly and whether once there are signs of such a liquidity event they will stay high is anyone's guess.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoAnother "solution" - one that requires no action from homeowners - is to fix the demand side of things. Engineers without family could park a van nearby and (optionally) commute in and out over the weekend to a nice area further out. For the cost difference I'd be willing to put up with a pretty significant amount of hassle like that.
- lozaning 8y agoMy manager's manager kinda does this. She flies her airplane back and forth between Yosemite area and the Palo Alto airport everyday. She loves flying and the numbers apparently penciled out for her to be able to afford to buy a house in Yosemite with access to a private landing strip, and buy the plane, fuel, and maintenance for cheaper than she could buy a house in the bay.
- snarfybarfy 8y agoThe numbers might work out for HER, but maybe not for her kids that inherit a wreck of a planet.
- a008t 8y agoHow long is the overall commute? That sounds like a potentially interesting solution.
- lozaning 8y agoI think flight time is around 50 minutes. Depending on what time I leave the office she sometimes gets to her house up there before I get to mine in Cupertino.