6 ms·
Many suburbanites, however, have the entitled attitude that cities should accommodate their car trips to dense areas at the expense of people actually living th
by Sharlin 8y ago
Many suburbanites, however, have the entitled attitude that cities should accommodate their car trips to dense areas at the expense of people actually living there. Often their mindset is that cities are strictly where people go instead of where people live. In the US this mentality is exarcebated by the white flight and the decay of inner cities, but does also exist in Europe.
- deelowe 8y agoAs one of these so called "white flight" people, I can't describe how much such statements frustrate me. I didn't move from the city because I'm a racist or don't want to be around people of color. I don't want to be around people period. Living in the city stresses me out. The constant noise, the issues with drunk people randomly knocking on my door at 2am, the couple of times I woke up to people fighting in the parking lot, the sirens, the random music festival 3 blocks over that I didn't know about, the fact I had 2 motorcycles stolen in 5 years, my kids not having a convenient place to play outside and more led to me leaving the city. I didn't move because I'm white, I moved because I wanted peace and quiet. Most of the people I know who live around me moved away from the city for the same reason. Amazingly, non white people feel this way too...
- Sharlin 8y agoCall it "middle-class flight" if you want. The end result is the same.
- strictnein 8y agoIt's quite a different thing to be accused of racism than it is to not be able to afford to live in the nicer areas of a metropolitan area.
- wott 8y agoPeople fleeing city centres is often not a matter of affordability but a choice on other criteria.
- deelowe 8y agoI have no issue with that. I just don't like being labeled a racist.
- CompelTechnic 8y agoThere are good reasons to believe that highly urban environments are bad for your mental health (in ways that I think are worse than how bad they are for your physical health). Sometimes I feel like strong advocates of increasingly-dense construction feel that the denser your lifestyle, the more prosocial your behavior. Maybe these advocates are among the most extraverted people, and they have little experience with the stress it causes others. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3230535/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3230535/
- Sharlin 8y agoAnd to what extent the hostility of urban environments is due to cars and car-centric planning hostile to human-scale activity? The whole point of new urbanism is creating livable, hospitable urban environments, and usually people-friendliness means car-unfriendliness. Your generic suburbs have their own problems – massively artificial, claustrophobic rows and rows of almost identical houses, with zero character and nowhere to go without a car.
- amyjess 8y agoI agree wholeheartedly with you; like you I'm a proud suburbanite who can't tolerate cities, noise, and people, and to that I'll add one thing... > Amazingly, non white people feel this way too... On this note, almost the entire Asian population of the Dallas area lives in the suburbs, and those who can afford it are starting to move to the exurbs. Only people without the means to leave are staying in the city because the city sucks.
- oftenwrong 8y agoThis article is about a city that doesn't suck, largely because it was made car-free. Not much "noise" when cars are gone.
- amyjess 8y agoPeople make noise. People shouting in the streets, nearby festivals, etc. I don't like people, and there's no such thing as a dense city that doesn't suck for me.
- ummonk 8y agoIt's a town with a population of 90k. It wouldn't suck either way.
- deelowe 8y agoAlmost none of the noise issues I experienced while living in the city was from automobiles.
- liveoneggs 8y agotraditional white flight (1970's style) mostly ended in the early 2000's when traffic got bad enough and baby boomers started to age out of power. It's an outdated term in most cities I think.
- InitialLastName 8y ago> Amazingly, non white people feel this way too... Part of the reason the trend is called "white flight" is that for a long time and in many places non-white people were prevented by bank, municipal, real estate office and HOA policy from purchasing houses or even getting mortgages in the suburbs. Calling it white flight isn't always an accusation of racism against the people who were fleeing, more against the people who openly prevented people of color from leaving as well.
- NPMaxwell 8y agoYes. If folks are interested, here's more about that: http://books.wwnorton.com/books/The-Color-of-Law/ http://books.wwnorton.com/books/The-Color-of-Law/
- amyjess 8y agoThat's not what "white flight" refers to. While the 1940s-1950s move to the suburbs consisted almost entirely of white people due to systematic racial discrimination preventing POC from moving, that is not "white flight". The phrase "white flight" refers to a 1970s phenomenon where white people repeatedly moved from one suburb to another (often in circular patterns) in order to avoid POC after desegregation and civil rights legislation made suburbs accessible to POC for the first time. This was exacerbated by real estate agents engaging in a race-baiting, unscrupulous practice called "block busting".
- bogomipz 8y agoNo, the OP is actually correct. The origin of the term "white flight" was a phenomenon that that followed the "great migration" of people from the rural south during the war and immediate post war years in the US.[1][2] >"The phrase "white flight" refers to a 1970s phenomenon ..." No, the 1970s may have seen a recirculation of the original phrase but it is commonly understood that "white flight" refers to phenomenon around the war years. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_flight [2] https://priceonomics.com/the-great-migration-the-african-american-exodus/ https://priceonomics.com/the-great-migration-the-african-ame...
- NPMaxwell 8y agoAt least one of your challenges is addressed by the OP: "The constant noise"
- astura 8y agoNobody (and especially not the person you are replying to) said everyone who is white and moved to the suburbs is/was participating in "white flight."
- asveikau 8y agoI think you may be neglecting the extent to which you are describing the self-reenforcing downsides of "post white flight" urbanism. Given the age demographics of HN, it's more likely than not that the city life you (or any of us) experienced was well after white flight ran its course, with consequent effects on crime and noise in cities. If you imagine a world in which the people who wanted quiet never left, the picture of urbanism looks a bit different. If you read about American life in pre-war cities, or the late 19th century, urban areas were a place where all types of people lived, including families, the elderly, and people who seek calm and quiet.
- 3pt14159 8y agoI don't know how it is outside of Canada, but here in Toronto what drives me insane is that Cities are essentially completely beholden to the province and it makes everything worse. Something simple like setting up a toll to use city streets to reduce congestion is completely off the table. We end up highly taxing corporate zoned housing to try to kinda indirectly tax the work place of the suburbanites that are making a mess of our city, but it's only a partial fix and it's distortionary. Meanwhile, people that actually live in Toronto pay way more in income tax than people that live outside of it, and our taxes are indexed to inflation, unlike the petrol taxes. Add in the three way split of the left vote and the FPTP system and we end up with a vindictive moron in charge of the province fucking up representation by changing our riding map in the middle of a city election. Cars have ruined so many things. The amount of times a car has honked at me for not putting my own life in danger because I need 5 seconds to get to a safer place to pull over with my bike is crazy. I'm not "taking a lane" I'm just keeping myself from getting doored. Imagine if cars had never been invented and we could have stuck with trains for everything? Way more green space. Way healthier population. Way more 4 or 6 story buildings. Way more parks. Way less time wasted behind the wheel. Fewer deaths. No road rage. And what would we have to give up? 3000 sqft suburban houses and their shitty pools that get used 5 times a year. Instead of watching TV at night alone at home people could walk over to their friends place or go out to a cute restaurant or well groomed park.
- alkonaut 8y agoI left the city when we had kids, and the thing that drew me to suburbia is that kids can just roam around outside unattended, biking around, building tree houses etc. Basically it's centered around 2 themes 1) As a parent I don't want my kids outdoor time to be limited to the times I can follow them, and 2) The idea that since my childhood was happy, I should give my kids the same experience. I don't necessarily think suburbia is the culprit for traffic though. It probably is in North America where suburbs often means "not even public transport available to the city". They were planned for and built for cars! My suburb was not. People lived here before cars too. I use public transport for most of my needs (including commuting) and drive very few miles per year - but I use my car many times for short distances, mostly things like picking up kids from daycare etc.
- ummonk 8y agoTo live within reasonable walking / public transport distance of my workplace in SF, I'd be paying about a thousand dollars a month more in rent. If you don't want me to commute in from the suburb, build more housing in the city and bring down market rent there.
- liveoneggs 8y agohow about they just charge you really high tolls and congestion tax instead? ;)
- thousandautumns 8y agoThereby driving up demand for living downtown, further driving up rent? Excellent solution.
- Karrot_Kream 8y agoOr encouraging people to take the train into SF. Of course, not everyone has a convenient train option because the patchwork of cities makes it incredibly difficult to drive a joint transit initiative.
- strongtown 8y agoI'm surprised nobody's mentioned building more housing.
- Sharlin 8y agoSure, that's exactly what urbanists are trying to do. But they're prevented by NIMBYs and car-centric regulations, like mandatory minimum parking spaces per inhabitant.
- munificent 8y agoMany urbanites have the entitled attitude that cities should not accommodate people who are not rich enough to live within walkable distances of their job. Many of the cities in the US that are dense enough to be reasonable walkable/bikable are also incredibly expensive in those areas.
- Barrin92 8y agoI haven't met many urbanites who would deny that cheap and reliable public transport also is the backbone of any large urban area, precisely for this reason.