3 ms·
Wow, sorry but I strongly disagree! Reddit has good value as a customizable and personal web site. Over time I adjust the subreddits on my home page as my tech
by mark_l_watson 8y ago
Wow, sorry but I strongly disagree! Reddit has good value as a customizable and personal web site. Over time I adjust the subreddits on my home page as my tech interests change and I enjoy seeing the community top ranked pictures every morning. I have met and talked with Alexis and this article provided interesting background on how he and Steve got back into running the company. He explained to me why he and Steve dropped the Lisp version of Reddit.
BTW, I gave you +1 Your honest opinion does not deserve to get downvoted.
- charlesism 8y agoThere's plenty of positives to Reddit. The trouble is that the prevailing philosophy behind Reddit (and FB, Youtube, etc) doesn't accomplish what everyone thought it would. We have been operating under the assumption that "filter bubbles are bad" and that private businesses should uphold "free speech" the way the judicial system does in the public realm. In practice, it looks as though online conversations aren't constructive unless the participants share a certain amount of common ground (eg: "first principles" like whether the strong should dominate the weak, or whether all "MSM" are part of a conspiracy and untrustworthy). I think in the future social media startups will have a "point of view" and not try to cater to everyone.
- pathseeker 8y ago>We have been operating under the assumption that "filter bubbles are bad" The entire premise of Reddit is that filter bubbles are the solution. You get to create bubbles for your own views called 'subreddits' where you can moderate out any wrong-think until the remaining subscribers reinforce the correct-think with their upvote/downvote mechanisms. A system that operated under the assumption that "filter bubbles are bad" would not allow its members to upvote/downvote each others' content so simply.
- charlesism 8y agoI worded that poorly. I mean filter bubbles are the right idea, but don't go far enough. A site should should hold specific enough values that its users can debate each other in good faith, and so that admins can stamp out (what they consider to be) toxic behavior without shocking half their users.
- miemo 8y ago>specific enough values that its users can debate each other in good faith you agree with me? great. wonderful debate thanks guys
- charlesism 8y agoJust because two people are, say physicists or atheists or believers in liberal democracy, doesn't mean they agree about everything (or even much at all). The past few years make me think that without sufficient common ground, rational debate is impossible: •Alice: "Rosemary's Baby is the best film ever." •Bob: "Devil woman! Satan is speaking through you. But you can't fool me!" •Alice: "My father just died. Everyone, give your dad a hug. You'll miss him when he's gone." •Bob: "Cry me a river, loser! Cow farts. Cow farts. Hitler was right!" •Alice: "I didn't vote for Trump, but I am glad he's talking to North Korea" •Bob: "Of course you are, Russian bot! I hope your handler is happy" •Alice: "I used to be a cop, and this video is way over the line." •Bob: "Antifa scum! How much does Soros pay you to write this BLM propaganda?" •Alice: "Just a reminder that you can get a free vaccination today, if you live in Charleston." •Bob: "Great, free autism everybody! Bet you'll trot out your MSM 'facts' now. Science is the new religion." The web is so full it's bursting with "debates" like these. They are not worth having. They do not change anyone's mind. They cause people to dig in. They just further divide society.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoIn all of those cases, Bob is being a dick. A rule to not be a dick is pretty straightforward and can be enforced by moderators.
- jandrese 8y agoModerators don't scale very well though. Those filter bubbles are really just letting the users do their own moderation. This reduces the scope of the site moderators job down to enforcing the rules. If you try to do everything through the global site moderators you immediately get pulled into arguments like this: User 1: You need to ban User 2 because he is a racist. User 2: I only said that User 1's views are not supported by evidence. User 1: My views are well supported by my life experiences, and there is no good evidence because the government outlawed funding for research into them. It's a no win situation, and neither side is going to change their mind and there's no clear winner. They're going to bicker and raise your noise floor constantly though. It's much better for site health if they can be isolated from one another, and better for your moderator's health if they do it automatically by themselves. This is the messy messy world of real life.
- cirgue 8y agoPeople say this all the time, but I absolutely do not see it. The main subreddits are troll cesspools and the ones that are interest-specific are generally not nearly as good as other purpose-built communities on the internet. For any topic I have significant personal experience with, the general discussion on most subreddits seem to me to be amazingly uninformed, and I am sure that pattern is not limited to the tiny part of the world I know well.