5 ms·
In related news, Bombardier is deploying a battery powered train in Berlin: https://montrealgazette.com/business/local-business/bombardier-debuts-battery-train-
by jillesvangurp 8y ago
In related news, Bombardier is deploying a battery powered train in Berlin: https://montrealgazette.com/business/local-business/bombardier-debuts-battery-train-in-berlin-in-challenge-to-diesel https://montrealgazette.com/business/local-business/bombardi...
Most of the rail system in Germany is electrified anyway. With batteries to power the non electrified bits, why bother with hydrogen?
- pintxo 8y agoAccording to [1] less than 60% of the rail system is electrified in Germany. [1] https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronik_der_Streckenelektrifizierung_in_Deutschland_seit_1994 https://de.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chronik_der_Streckenelektrif...
- _Codemonkeyism 8y agoAll main lines are electrified, many small towns are connected by diesel currently.
- blattimwind 8y agoBy rail kilometres, yes, but not by usage. Virtually every line experience heavy traffic (cargo, RE) is electrified, but there are many lines covering branches of the network where no heavy traffic occurs, which is not electrified. That's what this hydrogen train is for; it's base (LINT) is one of the most common trains used on those "backroad lines". (Coincidentally, the lint is also one of the most uncomfortable trains to ride if you are larger than a twelve year old boy)
- jillesvangurp 8y agoThe article I linked uses the same statistic. Basically this train is intended for local trains on such tracks. I imagine that with some power just at the stations, it could recharge there as well.
- kuschku 8y agoBecause the hydrogen trains are planned to run in regions with lots of wind energy — whenever there is too much electricity on the grid, just produce hydrogen from the excess energy, and use it later in trains. It's a much better solution for handling the spikes in wind than most of the alternatives.
- tehbeard 8y agoIs that an option for offshore wind farms? Or would seawater be too expensive to "purify" before splitting into hydrogen/oxygen?
- TomK32 8y agoSplit the water onshore, building those things offshore wouldn't make much sense when all you need is a cable to bring the electricity on shore to larger conversion installations
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hokkos 8y agoLarge scale hydrogen electrolysers are capital expensive, so there is no such thing as to only use them when electricity is cheap.
- azernik 8y agoBecause fuel cells provide range equivalent to diesel (600km, says the article), while these battery-powered trains can only go 40km or so between charges.
- jannes 8y agoThe grandparent said that most of the rail network in Germany is already electrified anyway. So no need for diesel or hydrogen trains. He/She states that at most a battery would be needed to cover the non-electrified parts.
- Freak_NL 8y agoThe intercity network is fully electrified, but there are plenty of long regional stretches without overhead power. The need exists. These trains are being considered for use on similar regional stretches currently served by diesel-electric trains in the Netherlands as well.
- woodpanel 8y agoAnd it's not only the poor and forgotten areas that aren't electrified. - The link between Hamburg and the island of Sylt isn't (one of the most profitable ones) - The ICE-link between Hamburg and Puttgarden (to Copenhagen) isn't (one of the most busiest around 110%++ capacity) - Large parts of Swabia, one of the most industrious areas of Germany are completely un-electrified apart from the ICE-link between Munich and Stuttgart. Getting from Aalen to Lake Constance or Kempten via Ulm you will see a lot of "Mittelstand"-Companies but not a single electrified track.
- progfix 8y agoAlso the shunting tracks at the train stations aren't electrified most of the time.
- adrianN 8y agoHow much better is the energy density for fuel cells?
- jnty 8y agoOverhead power lines require maintenance too, and getting 100% coverage often involves disproportionate spend on short sections that are expensive to cover and maintain. Getting rid of masts on those sections - or even whole lines - could be a massive cost saving. Additionally, Germany is a big train tech exporter, and there's lots of unelectrified route miles in Europe and the world, many of which would be totally uneconomical to electrify.
- athenot 8y ago> Additionally, Germany is a big train tech exporter They are, but the article mentions that these particular ones are built by the French TGV-maker Alstom.
- nebalee 8y agoThey are built by their german division Alstom Transport Deutschland (former Linke-Hofmann-Busch) in Salzgitter and Alstom is about to merge with Siemens Mobility.
- frabert 8y agoThe batteries are supposed to eliminate the need for 100% coverage, though, isn't it?
- ed_balls 8y agoyou don't want to remove 100% since you want to charge the batteries somewhere. Also it maybe more economical to keep 1km of power lines after the station when the train is accelerating - main power consumption.
- aembleton 8y agoThat's a great idea. You could just put the overhead charging infrastructure at a few stations on the line. Just enough to top the batteries up. Most of the energy could probably be recovered through regenerative braking, but of course some will be lost through mechanical and air resistance. This would be so much simpler than electrifying the whole line and much easier to maintain. This infrastructure is often already at key stations, and so it might require no extra work to implement them. Just more money for the battery powered trains.
- christophilus 8y agoI'd be interested in seeing an analysis of batteries vs hydrogen when it comes to environmental impact. Does anyone know which one wins? I suspect hydrogen due to the environmental impact of mining / producing the battery materials, then disposing / recycling them later.
- gambiting 8y agoAlmost 100% of commercially sold hydrogen is made as a byproduct of producing fossil fuels though. Yes, batteries take a lot of materials, but you can recycle them over and over again.
- xTWOz 8y agoWhat happens with all the water that evaporates? This process will bring massive problems.
- davedx 8y agoThey can store excess wind energy as hydrogen and transport and store it with existing natural gas infra.