3 ms·
Commentators on Popehats article with more experience than me in Cali defamation law have also pointed out that California has a "totality of the circumstances"
by gamblor956 8y ago
Commentators on Popehats article with more experience than me in Cali defamation law have also pointed out that California has a "totality of the circumstances" analysis of defamation, meaning that all of Musk's statements would be evaluated together rather than separately.
And to the dead comment below: 8 figures is simply $10,000,000 or more, which is a fair amount for a series of defamatory statements made to a worldwide audience during a time of significant publicity. Any apology Elon makes would have far smaller of an audience, meaning that if there is a large possibility that people heard and believed the original statements but never heard Elon's apology. Also, Popehat is a well-established legal commentator on the field of First Amendment and IP law that is frequently cited on HN. Torts/defamation is a little out of his bailiwick but his analysis is relevant to this HN discussion.
- ta76567656 8y ago$10,000,000 sounds like the judgement I'd expect in a wrongful death suit, not a single episode of mud slinging. Not saying you're wrong I'm just surprised.
- gamblor956 8y agoA man with a global audience accused another man, in multiple public statements, of pedophilia, sex trafficking, and statutorily raping his wife. When confronted with these statements, he doubled down each time and went further in his attack on the other man's character. Each of those, by itself, could constitute its own act of defamation per se. $10m being too much? On the contrary, $10m seems about right. OTOH, if this was just one guy in a small town saying those same things about another guy, I'd be surprised if you even got into the six digits. Unfortunately for Elon, scope matters.
- ta76567656 8y agoSure, but that's enough money to retire comfortably at any age in a first world country. Did Musk do a lifetime's work worth of damage to the man? Did he make it impossible for the other man to work? Was the other man even fired? How many people actually believed Musk?
- maxerickson 8y agoThey other poster isn't pulling the numbers from somewhere to say Musk did a bad thing, they are analyzing his actual potential liability under existing law. (so your questions are misdirected; they should be aimed at the people of California)
- ta76567656 8y agoI understand that, which is why I ended my original comment with: Not saying you're wrong I'm just surprised.
- ksherlock 8y agoTake a look at comments on r/elonmusk or r/teslamotors, etc. Many people believe it, insisting that Mr. Musk probably hired a team of investigators to fact check and verify all his claims.