4 ms·
In general, muscle is 'consumed' before 'fat'. Quotes since it is more complex than just what regular muscle and fatty tissues do. Not "in general." Only speci
by gamblor956 8y ago
In general, muscle is 'consumed' before 'fat'. Quotes since it is more complex than just what regular muscle and fatty tissues do.
Not "in general." Only specifically in cases of starvation or caloric deficit. In general, your body burns carbs, then fat, and then muscle. Muscle is by far the least efficient energy source, so the body spares muscle in normal circumstances and only consumes muscle in times of extended caloric deficit, like fasting, starvation, marathons, etc.
- naasking 8y ago> In general, your body burns carbs, then fat, and then muscle. Muscle is by far the least efficient energy source, so the body spares muscle in normal circumstances and only consumes muscle in times of extended caloric deficit This is a common belief but it's not true. You can't prevent your body from burning muscle in any kind of caloric deficit, you can only stimulate protein synthesis to counterbalance it by 1) ingesting high amounts of protein and 2) resistance training.
- gamblor956 8y agoSome muscle is consumed in a state of caloric deficit, yes. But muscle isn't the body's first choice for fuel until you enter into a state of extended caloric deficit. If the opposite were true, then triathletes would consume a pound or more of muscle during their training activities and especially during competitive events, instead of burning visually significant quantities of fat.
- naasking 8y ago> But muscle isn't the body's first choice for fuel until you enter into a state of extended caloric deficit. I'm honestly puzzled how people in this thread got the idea that I said that muscle was a preferred fuel. Literally no sequence of words I actually used imply this statement.
- arcticbull 8y agoYeah, sorry bud, you're just not in the right on this one. Your body always turns over muscle, sure, so some is going to be consumed. Your body produces huge quantities of HGH during starvation specifically to conserve protein and protein consumption goes down during fasting compared to steady-state. Otherwise our ancestors in periods of famine would turn into fatty puddles unable to drag themselves around. Starving means you need to get food, that's why noradrenaline levels go up, HGH production spikes (which many studies show changes your body composition to favor muscle over fat), your body switches to consuming primarily fat, and yes, some protein but not all protein is muscle. Your body also switches to producing what little glucose it actually needs via gluconeogenesis - which has many feedstocks including the glycerol backbones from triglycerides and yes, protein. But to say your body prefers to burn muscle over fat when starving is ridiculous, and just not supported by facts. [1] https://idmprogram.com/fasting-and-muscle-mass-fasting-part-14/ https://idmprogram.com/fasting-and-muscle-mass-fasting-part-...
- naasking 8y ago> Yeah, sorry bud, you're just not in the right on this one. Your body always turns over muscle, sure, so some is going to be consumed So you say I'm wrong, and then immediately agree with me? You have a strange way of disagreeing with someone. > But to say your body prefers to burn muscle over fat when starving is ridiculous, and just not supported by facts. Please quote the passage or link the comment where I said that.
- arcticbull 8y agoAh my bad I think I replied to the wrong post. I’d delete but I stand by my points just not which post they were at, so will keep.