2 ms·
The two percent of researchers who aren't in agreement deserve to heard. But they do not deserve equal time in the media. Imagine if you owned 98% of a business
by BerislavLopac 16y ago
The two percent of researchers who aren't in agreement deserve to heard. But they do not deserve equal time in the media. Imagine if you owned 98% of a business but your less-knowledgeable partner with only two percent had as much sway as you. It's a ridiculous way to approach business and a ridiculous way to present such an important issue.
This gets on my nerves -- science is not the same as running a business. I'm pretty sure that a large part of the said 98% are dogmatically accepting the view of the majority and are too afraid to test any hypotheses...
- TomOfTTB 16y agoI'll admit there is something troubling about surveying only Climatologists in that they've built an entire industry around Global Warming. If someone could prove man-made GW didn't exist you'd probably see 2/3 of the available Climatology grants disappear overnight. That said I think there's a bigger flaw in this survey and that's the question itself. The question, as stated in the graph, is "Credibility of Evidence for Anthropogenic Climate Change". Not "Scientists who believe Climate Change will cause a cataclysmic change in our environment" I think everyone agrees that our presence on Earth is having some impact on the environment. It seems insane not to believe that. The question is to what extent and that isn't addressed in the survey.
- steve19 16y agoI agree. It is like doing a survey on the importance of AI research and only surveying AI researchers. A much less biased survey would also include CS and statistics researchers.
- brc 16y agoThe other little nugget in there is 'but your less-knowledgeable partner'. The intent here is that disagreement is a sign of stupidity. It's the unmistakable mark of a closed mind heading down the avenue of groupthink. Whether you agree with everything about climate change or not, you would have to agree that dismissing your opponents views as 'less knowleadgeable' is disengenious and shows a dogmatic love of position rather than a desire to increase knowledge. I appreciate this works both ways, but it's a feature of the 'debate' nowadays - the entire process is so full of dogmatic positions it's hard to be clear of where anything is. Science is a weighing machine and not a voting machine. Consensus matters for very little, results matter a lot.