4 ms·
> I'm saying that the independent distributors of gasoline have no monoply on the market, but still manage to ensure that they all get the same cut anyways. Na
by randomdata 8y ago
> I'm saying that the independent distributors of gasoline have no monoply on the market, but still manage to ensure that they all get the same cut anyways.
Naturally. That has to happen if you are selling a commodity. By literal definition, there is no way to differentiate yourself in the market. You cannot build a better OS for your gasoline or wheat to try and extract more profit. All you can offer is basic gasoline or wheat. The exact same gasoline or wheat as the guy across the street.
Why would a customer ever pay you more for the exact same thing as the guy across the street? Matching the price of your competition is the only hope you have of making a sale. If you don't take an identical cut, you won't have a business at all.
> There's nothing stopping them all from agreeing to fix the market far above what the price could be because they see an opportunity for profit.
You mean other than the practicalities of the real world that make it almost impossible to pull off?
Milk is another commodity. Being Canadian, you likely know that subject well given the events that are going on right now. Why do you think Canadian dairy farmers are shaking in their boots right now given that they can simply get together as a group and fix the price to fend off any changes that may come? They've already had decades of practice.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- xg15 8y ago> Why would a customer ever pay you more for the exact same thing as the guy across the street? Matching the price of your competition is the only hope you have of making a sale. If you don't take an identical cut, you won't have a business at all. But if that were the case, I'd expect that e.g. gasoline prices roughly follow the ups and downs of crude oil prices. However, the reality seems to be different: > ... in Canada [...], and even though crude oil is half the price it was half a decade ago the gas prices seem to have crept back to where they were pre-plummet.
- randomdata 8y ago> But if that were the case, I'd expect that e.g. gasoline prices roughly follow the ups and downs of crude oil prices. Why? Oil is an input for gasoline, no doubt, but it is also an input for wheat. If wheat diverges from the price of oil, nobody thinks twice. What's special about gasoline that requires that it follow the price of oil, despite being traded as a separate commodity? There is a relationship between the price of oil and the price of gasoline, but not a direct one.