3 ms·
I've been using DDG for years now, and the results are exactly as good as Google. I've never had a case where going to Google returned better results for me. Ma
by StavrosK 8y ago
I've been using DDG for years now, and the results are exactly as good as Google. I've never had a case where going to Google returned better results for me. Maybe it's because I tend to search for programming/hardware questions, but that's my experience.
Also, I don't use bangs, I use the browser's built-in searches. So, for example, "i <movie name>" will take me to IMDB (actually Rotten Tomatoes nowadays) by searching for "site:imdb.com ! <movie name>" on DDG.
- detaro 8y agoI still have to fall back to Google every now and then or tweak the request more. Random example I encountered today: "Mastodon API". DDG does not find the api documentation on the first two screens, on Google spot 1 is the old location of the docs that has a link to the new, spot 2 is the new location of the docs. "Mastodon API documentation" and DDG understands it too.
- wruza 8y agoI’ll second that. DDG is good for regular searches, but can stumble upon rare particular queries and/or what one calls ‘deep googling’. Otoh, it is good that I can hide everything except few queries from google, so it wastes its money on irrelevant ads that I block anyway.
- utopcell 8y ago..and by DDG, you mean Bing.
- wruza 8y agoYahoo, actually, if you insist that DDG is not a fair search engine on its own. Both shown very similar results on my areas of interest.
- utopcell 8y agoDDG was built on Yahoo! BOSS, which was backed by Yahoo search engine results until Yahoo switched to Bing (almost 10 years ago.) So, if we are insisting on being accurate, SSG's main backend is Bing.
- wruza 8y agoDidn't know that. So, is it safe to use ddg in a sense of not gifting your data to ms/ggl/etc tech pigs? Or is it just Bing with a new skin?
- utopcell 8y agoI don't think it is just a re-skinned Bing, the people behind DDG have done a lot of work to built features around the "10 blue links." The question is: Do you trust a trillion dollar company, with everything to lose if it is revealed that they are misusing user data [1], or do you trust a 50 people team who is trying to get you to switch using FUD techniques. [1] ..and by the way, have waaay better results than their closest competitor
- wruza 8y agoI trust my eyes. The ads that get through filters show that a trillion dollar company tries to earn another cent of my data and ddg team doesn’t, at least it is not instantly visible. Chances are, their business model really implements my privacy, while a $1T guys openly sell it asap. Health, porn, food, tech, politics — everything. If ddg datamines me too, then, well, data buyers remain the same and there is no way to hide the fact of sale. Given that, is there a reason to trust them less?
- utopcell 8y agoYes, of course! They have little to lose compared to Google, which has _everything_ to lose. Lack of personalization is not a "feature" that DDG implemented. It is a lack of feature that they had to justify. The results that they were getting back from Yahoo! BOSS were not personalized, because Yahoo! (and now Bing,) would not trust a third-party with your ID, let alone your data. More importantly: Google is not selling your info to anyone. They use it to personalize their two main search engines: web and ads. Non-personalized ads means smaller revenue per ad, which in turn means more ads shown to you (which is what you get with DDG.) If you see Google ads on a third-party site, it is still Google that is directly serving those ads, not that site. Think of it this way: Here is a company that screams that Google is evil, but is happy to provide you with direct functionality ("!g") to visit Google, and oh, by the way, says nothing about their main partner, Bing, that also personalizes results. On the other hand, look at Google's behavior. They own duck.com through their acquisition of On2. What do they show when you visit duck.com ? "If you meant to visit the search engine DuckDuckGo, click here." Who does that ?! Brands build trust over many years, and in my (and most of the planet's) opinion, Google has earned mine. I could be more worried about ISPs logging URLs and selling them, but I'm not: I'm just not that interesting to track and I bet this is true for most of us. Maybe you're different.
- TylerE 8y agoWith respect - how you possible state that? If you are not searching on google most of the google magic isn't going to work? For instance - when I google "python" google knows I mean the programming language. For another user, they may mean the snake.
- StavrosK 8y agoWhat do you mean? I search for <x> on DDG, results are unsatisfactory, I search for <x> on Google, results are equally unsatisfactory. Sure, Google may know I mean the language, not the snake, but I never search for "python", I always search for something like "python regex", which clarifies it for almost all cases.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tmaly 8y agoOne use to be able to help contribute niche type search support to DDG. I went on their forums a year or two back and it did not see as if they were still accepting this.
- conatus 8y agoI have to fall back to Google for almost every search for specific coding information. I want it to work but it really doesn't.
- dagoat 8y agoI have to frequently fall back, so every time I make the switch to DDG - I quickly switch back out of frustration
- new_guy 8y ago>I've been using DDG for years now, and the results are exactly as good as Google. That's mostly because DDG use Googles API, they don't actually search anything themselves.
- Fnoord 8y agoI thought they mainly used Bing; not Google. DDG says they use "over 400 sources" [1] direct link [2]. They don't mention Google at all. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DuckDuckGo#Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DuckDuckGo#Overview [2] https://duck.co/help/results/sources https://duck.co/help/results/sources
- Tehnix 8y ago> Maybe it's because I tend to search for programming/hardware questions, but that's my experience. I feel like I have the reverse experience—that only non programming queries work well on DDG. I have literally switched my programming searches a bunch of times today alone, from DDG to Google by simply prepending the !g bang. Google would then give me way better results on the exact same query. This is sometimes I very often end up doing. I would love to not use Google, so DDG is still my default, but I sure end up there a lot anyways :(
- konart 8y ago>I've never had a case where going to Google returned better results for me Only if the search query is something trivial as "ruby Array" or "SQL WHERE". As soon as you ask more general question (yeah, sometimes it is pretty hard to come up with a strict search query) DDG does not understand what the heck do you want to get in return unlike google which as results for a queries similar to the you've provided.
- EpicEng 8y agoI tried DDG for a while and had the opposite experience. Worked fine for trivial stuff (looks like Bing), but I whenever it was tricky to come up with a solid query, DDG failed and Google worked. Can't use it.
- awaywopassd 8y agoI have been using DDG for over a year now. I have to use Google/!g at least once daily. Especially with forums/blog posts, it shows older, outdated info more often than Google. And my searches mostly consist of programming related topics too. I continue use DDG to support them but I do wish their results were better.
- pitay 8y agoDDG has been working well enough for me that I haven't had a good reason to compare on technical or other topics. However, DDG is worse looking for local information for things like store opening hours, Google knowing your location is an advantage there.
- tuxlifan 8y agoFor opening hours I now often use http://openpoimap.org/ http://openpoimap.org/ It can be a challenge sometimes to find the right category to activate to get the markers but when using the search box it usually tells you in brackets which category to switch on for more information and it even centers the map for you. YM(and expectation)MV, obviously.