3 ms·
>> 1. The Passion Hypothesis Sucks For me, there are two fundamental assumptions in this piece of advice, both mistaken: that you only get one ("true"?) passio
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> 1. The Passion Hypothesis Sucks
For me, there are two fundamental assumptions in this piece of advice, both
mistaken: that you only get one ("true"?) passion in your entire life and
that's that, and that this passion is for one very specific ...thing, that
exists in a particular space and time.
For instance, under those assumptions, Charles' Babbage's "passion" would be
about "mechanical computers", based on the fact that he dedicated the majority
of his resources working on those, towards the end of his life; so they must
have been what he was passionate about.
In reality, reading his autobiography, it's obvious that Babbage simply had a
mind that would not be constrained and would jump from interest to interest
throughout his life. He happened to get his teeth sunk into something really,
really big with mechanical computers and, having so dug his way into a rich
seem of new ideas, he invested most of his resources in mining it for all it
was worth. But he was simply interested in anything and everything- and,
particularly in things that worked.
As to the second fundamental mistake, the fact that Babbage became interested
in mechanical computers was a happy accident: he was born at a time and in a
place that enabled this interest. Were he to be born 1000 years prior, or half
a continent away, he would have probably never have heard of such things as
mechanical calculators and never have gone down in history as the inventor of
the first ever general computer (and also, btw, of feature creep).
Perhaps -no, certainly!- "find your passion" is bad advice when it makes
these two assumptions about how a "passion" is a very specific thing that can
only exist in one place and time. But, when "passion" points to something
deeper about how one's mind functions and where one's natural proclivities
lie, then it's actually good advice: to find your strengths and your
weaknesss, and play to your strengths and avoid your weaknesses.
Then, there's those of us who can only really apply ourselves to a job if it
is scratching an itch- for working with our hands, for things that work, for
abstract ideas, for the wonderment in the physical world, for inspiration and
creativity, for hard work and contributing to the community- etc, etc. Only
when we are really interested in the thing we do can it keep our full
attention and our full focus for long hours and longer days. For such people,
"find your passion" really means: "find something that makes you work hard and
use it to live a productive life". It means: "maximise your potential".
- shawn 8y agoI like your comment. This was a perceptive reframing: the fact that Babbage became interested in mechanical computers was a happy accident: he was born at a time and in a place that enabled this interest. Were he to be born 1000 years prior, or half a continent away, he would have probably never have heard of such things as mechanical calculators Usually people point out that Babbage was incredibly unlucky to have been born just before computers were made practical.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoAye, that's true. They miss the point: that he was the first to plant his flag in a vast, undiscovered country. To be that person- I'd accept being born ten thousand years before my time and dying in complete obscurity.
- darepublic 8y agoHow do you know he was the first. By your own example, that person may die in complete obscurity.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoYeah, XP for the skepticism. But not for anything else.
- knorthfield 8y agoIt doesn't help that the word passion has become distorted from it's original meaning, originally more to do with suffering. It's more helpful to ask one's self: "What am I willing to suffer for?" rather than: "What am I passionate about?" where passion today seems to mean what would I prefer to do rather than work.
- dorkwood 8y agoI agree with your comment. I use my curiosity as a compass for what I should be working on. I find that I'm much happier and learn a lot faster if I follow my natural inclinations towards certain things, rather than force myself down a single, potentially-lucrative path in the hopes that I will eventually become passionate about it.