4 ms·
What I find remarkable about this kind of articles is how a situation in which economic activity and employment is going so well that the labor market might shi
by xg15 8y ago
What I find remarkable about this kind of articles is how a situation in which economic activity and employment is going so well that the labor market might shift in favor of employees/workers is described as "the economy is running hot", a self-evidently bad state that sensible economic policy should seek to avoid.
I'm kinda baffled by that. I'm no economics major, but this seems to imply that keeping wages low (or at least decoupled from economic growth) is actually a goal of economic policy. Is that true?
- Arnt 8y agoPolicy seeks to increase the pay of the employed and reduce the unemployment. Increasing pay increases unemployment in principle, but the the bond between the two is fickle and difficult to predict. Sometimes it's an extremely weak bond, sometimes it's strong. Its precise strength is difficult to pin down even with hindsight.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoThere’s nothing bad about a ‘hot’ economy. It simply presents a different set of challenges that haven’t really been an issue for quite a while. Rising employment means rising inflation, to reduce inflation you increase interest rates, but if you do that too much you’ll slow down growth, and if that happens employment will slow down. I think you really could have benefitted from reading the article.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIt’s bad if it gets so hot that defaults start happening and cascading through the system. Loans are given based on expected future revenue and costs, and if they start going varying too much from expectations, then defaults start happening, and if too many happen, then it can start cascading through the system. Overall wages, especially at the low end, are typically last to increase because people don’t hop around jobs as much as they should and the social element makes it look bad if people ask for too many wage increases (e.g jobs) too quickly. Whereas prices for capital (land, commodities, equities, equipment), are allowed to rise and fall as quickly as the market allows so capital owners get to reap those gains while wage earners get “stretched”.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoHaving over-leveraged institutions isn’t related to growth at all. I think what you’re kinda getting around to saying in your second paragraph is that inflation hurts wage earners? If so, the Fed agrees with you, which is why it’s continually adjusting interest rates. In fact, that’s the entire focus of the OP article.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoYes, but I think they’re always late and the inevitable bailouts inevitably hurt the wage earners more than the capital owners, as history has shown. Wouldn’t the “over” part of over-leveraged only be true if an error in expectations of future growth (either through increase in revenue or decrease in costs or both)? Growth is what the leverage is presumably based on. Everyday I see land and business sold for multiples more than even 2 or 3 years ago. All those loans are pricing in quite a bit of “growth”.
- AmericanChopper 8y ago>I think they’re always late and the inevitable bailouts inevitably hurt the wage earners It's pretty obvious that you don't actually know what you're talking about. Inflation has been pretty much under control for the past few years, and it's projected to go down slightly over the next few years. I'm really confused why you're talking about leverage or bailouts at all. Downturns in 'hot' economies tend to be caused by demand-pull inflation, which is exactly what the fed is managing, as discussed in the OP's article. Your discussion of leverage is not related to this situation at all. Leverage isn't based on growth, and doesn't require growth to service. The risk of a 'cascading default' is based primarily on the leverage ratios of large financial institutions. Those ratios were reformed from the ground up recently, and there's no indication that there's anything wrong with them. It's really quite hard to have this discussion with you, because you're talking about a few different unrelated topics, which you appear to not really understand at all.
- mcguire 8y ago"..because people don’t hop around jobs as much as they should..." I suspect you are over-generalizing from the relatively rare situation of a group of high-earners. Job hoping isn't really a good strategy for convenience store clerks.
- codelord 8y agoI think there's too much focus on raising wages. While that's not really the way to improve the situation for low incomes. One should seek to raise the buying power. A stronger dollar, can mean higher buying power for imported products. Keeping the inflation low is also as important as raising wages. Another positive factor is increasing the productivity. The more you produce, means there's more stuff for everyone to buy and that drives the prices lower.
- dalbasal 8y agoRemember that for most below average households, not much of their expenses aren't currency dependant. Housing, transport, education, food...
- codelord 8y agoHow can you say that these aren't currency dependent? If the US dollar was 10 times stronger you could buy 10 times more food. If the prices stayed the same you'd see a surge in imports. When imported products are cheaper everything becomes cheaper, it might just take some time.
- xg15 8y ago> If the US dollar was 10 times stronger you could buy 10 times more food. "You" being the distributor, not the final consumer. I don't see why the distributor (or other middlemen) wouldn't simply pocket the price difference themselves. What would force them to pass it on to consumers?
- codelord 8y agoThe middleman always wants to maximize profit. Nothing is stopping them from raising prices at anytime. However, unless you have a monopoly on the food market, competition will force the prices down.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> "You" being the distributor, not the final consumer. I don't see why the distributor (or other middlemen) wouldn't simply pocket the price difference themselves. What would force them to pass it on to consumers? This would only work if the distributor had a monopoly on food sales in the US, or a monopsony on food imports to the US. Thankfully, this is not the case for anything except for specialty imports.
- Applejinx 8y agoYes. The interests of humans are not the interests of capital, and the purpose of the economy is to maximize capital.
- dalbasal 8y agoErmm...not exactly. The relationship between median wages, marginal unemployment and "hotness" is not causal, it's just expected to correlate. There isn't an overall agreement on what "too hot" is, but to generalize a "conservative" perspective it'd be "mal-investment," investments chasing an overavailability of money that will "sow the seeds" of future market crashes.
- xg15 8y agoI haven't heard that definition of "hotness" yet. This sounds interesting. Thanks.
- isolli 8y agoTangentially related (2014): http://cepr.net/blogs/beat-the-press/wage-price-inflation-and-the-way-things-work-in-economics http://cepr.net/blogs/beat-the-press/wage-price-inflation-an... "Thanks to the eccentricities of Alan Greenspan, the Fed did not raise interest rates. Instead it allowed the unemployment to continue to fall. It fell below 5.0 percent in 1997, it crossed 4.5 in 1998, and reached 4.0 percent as a year-round average. And inflation remained tame. The result was that millions of people had jobs who would not have otherwise. Tens of millions of workers at the middle and bottom of the wage distribution saw substantial real wage gains for the first time in a quarter century."
- conanbatt 8y agoThe concept of "hot in economics" relates to inflation. If you spur people to spend above their productivity prices rise eating away at the gains. Another interpretation of "hot" is the over-utilization of capital. When you over-utilize capital, its productivity increases are short-termed because the capital has to be refurnished which means in the future you will have a slump. In economics, there is a proverbial equilibrium that all situations tend to go to: forcing it to move around often has more negative consequences than positive ones.
- eli_gottlieb 8y ago>I'm kinda baffled by that. I'm no economics major, but this seems to imply that keeping wages low (or at least decoupled from economic growth) is actually a goal of economic policy. Is that true? Well yes. Today's policymakers were mostly taught to work under the assumption that stagflation occurs if you explicitly target wage increases, as policymakers prior to the '70s sometimes did. They're fighting the previous war, so to speak, since their policies brought about a deflationary crisis.
- JDWolf 8y agoThank you, I think that economics has some very bizarre notions. The over-use of aggregates such as GDP, inflation, and Dow Jones levels frustrates me. It would be nice to have charts that show distributions of these types of measures rather than averages or weighted averages.
- Animats 8y agoI'm kinda baffled by that. I'm no economics major, but this seems to imply that keeping wages low (or at least decoupled from economic growth) is actually a goal of economic policy. Is that true? It's an inherent goal of capitalism to keep costs down. Wages are a cost. From a capitalist perspective, wages should be just above survival level. In the absence of political or labor organization pressure, that's what happens.