3 ms·
> At any reasonable tempo, 1/16th, 1/32nd, etc. note symbols bring little value considering the visual noise they add Such notes are commonly quite heavily use
by chrismorgan 8y ago
> At any reasonable tempo, 1/16th, 1/32nd, etc. note symbols bring little value considering the visual noise they add
Such notes are commonly quite heavily used in classical music. Whether they might be better doubled in length with the tempo doubled, is another matter.
It can go the other way, too: if you look in hymn books from the 19th or early 20th century, you may also find hymns that use whole and half notes, with the occasional breve and quarter note; whereas if you look at a later edition of such a hymn book, you may find those notes got halved, to use half and quarter notes, with the occasional whole and eighth note. I certainly find the latter easier to play.
- mathw 8y agoI mostly play baroque music from notation, where the convention was to use roughly doubled note values compared to today - most of what I play has the beat in minim/half-note sized values, so we're often in 4/2 or 6/4 rather than 4/4 or 6/8. The lack of visual noise from the sparser notation, hollow note-heads etc. is rather pleasing compared to some later music where you're into demisemiquavers where you could have just had semiquavers. We see semiquavers in my viol consort we know they're going to be teeny little notes in most pieces. There's just less ink on our pages! I don't really understand why it shifted to shorter values. I guess it probably wasn't deliberate though. These things usually aren't, they just... happen. ETA: maybe the increased visual grouping of beamed quavers and smaller notes was considered valuable for conveying the composer's intentions with regard to phrasing, especially as printing technology became increasingly capable of properly reproducing them.
- chrismorgan 8y agoMy experience with scores in both /2 and /4 is in hymn books, playing the piano. I find the /4 version decidedly easier to read than the /2 version, and my brother and dad have said the same thing. It generally conveys the flow better. Naturally, there are other differences in the engraving as well, some for the better and some for the worse, so it’s not a fair comparison.