3 ms·
Yes, but it's also difficult to say there is strictly a modern/classical dichotomy and which method or material would belong in which bin. Someone could certai
by colechristensen 8y ago
Yes, but it's also difficult to say there is strictly a modern/classical dichotomy and which method or material would belong in which bin.
Someone could certainly do some studies comparing methods and results, but anything of that matter would be very easy to bias.
What is clear is that classical methods are being employed by artists and not scientists. Mythology and visual appeal are being used to sell things, not quantifiable facts.
- mirimir 8y agoYes, I get that. What matters now is mostly appearance. And maybe vague stuff about ability to keep an edge. But back in the day, you were in deep shit if your sword shattered. Or even got notched, if that put you off the flow.
- Pristina 8y agoWhat scenario am I in where I would have a sword, have it shattered and be in trouble? In war, people mostly use polearms. In a sword fight, as has been shown in many HEMA videos i have seen, it's over in a single exchange. At that point it doesn't matter if your sword is shattered or not. And the idea that your sword being notched will 'put you off the flow' just doesn't buy it for me.
- colechristensen 8y agoBasically whenever you are using a sword that isn't some ritualized combat. If you are using it in a battle and your sword breaks after the first exchange, what then? Here is an hour long documentary answering your question: https://www.pbs.org/video/nova-secrets-viking-sword/ https://www.pbs.org/video/nova-secrets-viking-sword/