3 ms·
The major mistake proponents of these licenses make is IMHO trying to get to close to "Open Source" with their labeling/marketing. We have a quite clear definit
by detaro 8y ago
The major mistake proponents of these licenses make is IMHO trying to get to close to "Open Source" with their labeling/marketing. We have a quite clear definition of what "Open Source" means, if your license is not compatible to it and you market it as if it is this will dominate discussions of your license and people will assume bad intentions. Don't call people insisting on the meaning names.
Find a new term and establish it instead of trying to capitalize on an existing one that means something else.
"Source available" is a fine term (if there's a more specific one for a specific license, present that), and gets the entire meaning debate out of the way, so one can discuss the merits of the license as it is, not purely in comparison to something it somewhat pretends to be.
(this specific blog post is better at this than other messaging, but this at least partially explains why the climate is so unfriendly)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kemitchell 8y agoThanks for this. Very well taken. I agree with you on the need for a new coinage, in the middle, so to speak. Without meaning to overshadow that positivity, I'd offer two tiny quibbles: The OSD is pretty clear ... if you ask easy questions. I tried and failed to find the strongest copyleft license that OSI would approve. The main upshot of that laborious process was that OSI wouldn't likely approve such a license, even if it met the OSD. As for creating confusion with an established "brand", I tried to address this in the post, by analogy to vote splitting. That may have got buried too deep, in the final edit. My point there is basically one I've made here on HN before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17823328 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17823328