3 ms·
A slowgoing development for him, still I sympathize and wish him the best while wondering ironically if personal issues aside what works best. It brings to min
by Nasrudith 8y ago
A slowgoing development for him, still I sympathize and wish him the best while wondering ironically if personal issues aside what works best.
It brings to mind fundamental organizational and management. Is it better to have a "rude" organization? Calling bullshit early and often instead of polite everything is fine stacks of lies since it would be impolite to point out having O(N!) code just can't work for anything of appreciable size? The optimal approach likely varies on several variables.
- dstroot 8y agoCan’t you blend them? In other words I’d love to work in an organization that can politely call bullshit early and often. It is possible to fundamentally disagree without making it personal. Really good to see him acknowledge this and tackle it head on. I hope he gains a better perspective. Thank goodness for Linus and Linux!
- webkike 8y agoI don't see why you'd ever need to go further than "I strongly believe that your view is incorrect, and here is why". Attacking people is not "calling bullshit"
- chillacy 8y agoIn my experience saying the words "your view" often makes it personal for the other person, which can lead to them defending that view much stronger than if the criticism goes towards "this view", which invites objectivity. Probably not a huge game changer, but it's definitely a little hack that I think has served me well over the years.
- dx87 8y agoI think it's possible to blend a polite environment and a no-nonsense environment as long as you're physically working together, or at a minimum doing video conferences. IIRC, Linus said that one of the reasons he used such strong language and is so abrasive on the mailing list is because so many communication cues are lost when you don't have tone of voice and body language to add context to the actual words. Being over the top aggressive and harsh was his way of ensuring that his message was completely unambiguos. That said, most people don't want to work with someone like that, and he addresses this when he talks about people leaving kernel development specifically because of him. If they continue using the mailing list for development, I think we need to expect that development will slow a little at first since there will probably be more back-and-forth between developers. That said, hopefully having a better working environment will encourage more people to be kernel developers, negating the slowdown caused by a more cordial mailing list. I'm also really happy to see Linus setting a positive example for taking care of yourself in addition to your project.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- village-idiot 8y agoThere’s a difference between negative feedback and being rude. The former is necessary when crappy work gets submitted, the latter drives people away before giving them a chance to improve. The way you phrased your question implies that there’s an exclusive choice to be made here, which is not the case. How much toxicity a project can tolerate is in inverse proportion to how important it is, but every project has its limits no matter what. I think this is a wise choice. Either Torvalds needs to figure out people better, or he needs to bring in a lieutenant who can handle people more effectively than he does.
- trjordan 8y ago"Given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow." - Linus Torvalds A rude leader drives people away from the organization. It is directly counterproductive.
- Nasrudith 8y agoDepends on how rudeness is defined as well. Based soley on people's feelings or above and beyond objective truth. Saying that Bob hasn't proven good at network programming and is prone to spaghetti code may be absolutely true yet he would likely take offense to it.
- geezerjay 8y ago> It is directly counterproductive. Linux is by far the most successful floss project in the history of mankind. God knows there are plenty of floss OS projects out there, most of which have far nicer leaders but a small fraction of the success. Either you're overplaying the effect on productivity or the relevance of being nice.
- joshuamorton 8y agoCorrelation does not imply causation. It's absolutely possible that Linux is the exception. There are many oss projects which don't have the same level of abuse.
- village-idiot 8y agoThere's another way to view it: some projects are so important that they can tolerate a large level of rudeness and not fail.
- davidgould 8y agoActually this was written by Eric Raymond in "The Cathedral and the Bazaar". Raymond dubbed it "Linus's Law" which may be the source of the confusion.
- kryptiskt 8y agoIf someone reviews your code, it will sting when they point out silly mistakes. The insults that the kernel devs fling about just aren't needed to drive home the point.
- branchless 8y agoAgreed. What can be worse than having a comment to the effect of "if x is -1, which is feasible, this will cause undefined behaviour resulting in a crash". For most people this stings more than enough.
- crdoconnor 8y agoHe reserved the insults for bad design decisions defended by senior committers. It's not like he threw out insults to anybody who ever made a mistake.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Twirrim 8y agoCode reviews fly around our team without any trace of vitriol or insults, even when the mistakes are mindnumbling stupid or disagreement on approach is strong. You don't have to be insulting to maintain code quality. If insults are the only way you can make your point, you've got some way bigger personal issues to deal with. The thing is, being insulting is largely counterproductive. Even where the best response from the person being insulted is that they shrug it off, it still modifies the relationship and attitudes towards the insulter.
- UncleMeat 8y agoCriticize the behavior, not the person. Linus often included personal attacks against people who were making errors. You can get a message across without telling people that they are worthless scum.
- kyberias 8y agoHe used strong words but where did he actually attack the person? Tell them they're "worthless scum"?
- NegativeK 8y agoI flat out don't understand why people keep suggesting that it's a choice between eggshells or vitriolic insults.
- moosingin3space 8y agoWhy do so many people on this forum seem to believe that being polite inherently implies lying to each other? I just want to understand this line of thinking. My workplace is extremely polite to each other AND we don't lie to each other. I recently submitted a code review that was full of violations of the style guide, and nobody was rude nor dishonest.
- a_tractor 8y ago>AND we don't lie to each other How on earth could you possibly know that? >so many people on this forum >polite inherently implies lying That understanding of "polite" is at least centuries old and spans almost every culture where the concept exists. There is an entire structure of unwritten social rules that is designed to avoid the not-so-obvious dishonesty of politeness. For instance, in some cultures, it is polite to offer food to a guest, even to the point where a host might offer all food they will have for a week. They obviously do not want to go hungry for the week, but they will feel compelled, in the name of being polite, to offer it anyways. They will also never admit this to a guest, but as a guest if you are aware of their poverty then you will probably try to politely decline the offer, even if you are hungry. You could not in good conscious take the last of their food, but you also do not want to expose your reasons and embarrass them either... it goes on and on. Hopefully you get the point.