13 ms·
Edward Snowden Reconsidered
- pessimizer 8y agoUnintelligible and endless. I don't know what's being "reconsidered" because this adds nothing other than an weird-ass attempt to associate Wikileaks, Snowden, Poitras and Greenwald with Putin and Russia, Nazism, and the Australian far-right(?!).
- AndyMcConachie 8y agoAgree. Don't know why you're being downvoted. This is a dumb piece.
- shard972 8y agoThe Australian far right, also known as the shooters and fishers party... Yea I don't know if I can take someone serious who thinks a party focused on recreational hunting and gun rights is some fringe far right party. Also the claim of "alignment" comes from preference runoffs, because wikileaks put them ahead of the greens. Seems like a lot of bias packed just in this one sentence.
- plugger 8y ago> Yea I don't know if I can take someone serious who thinks a party focused on recreational hunting and gun rights is some fringe far right party. Are you Australian? The shard in your username makes me think you might be.* Regardless, down here the handful of people who would be considered as proponents of gun rights would also most likely align with the far right (One Nation, Shooters and Fishers, etc). * Don't know about elsewhere, but in Australia "shards" is a slang term for ice/crystal meth.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- shard972 8y ago> An earlier version of this essay misstated the number of documents that Edward Snowden released; that number is not known. The figure of 1.7 million was an intelligence estimate given to Congress of files accessed by Snowden. An earlier version also misstated that the DuckDuckGo search engine allows partners to collect user data; it does not. The article has been updated. So the author spent all this time writing this article couldn't even bother to confirm how many documents were leaked and seemed to be under the assumption that DDG is data mining it's users? This article just feels like it was written by a 3 letter agency and dropped on someone's desk.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pvg 8y agoIt was written by a three letter agency because it contained and corrected some relatively minor factual errors?
- yellowapple 8y agoAccusing DDG of doing the very thing it claims it does not and will never do is beyond "relatively minor" in my opinion.
- pvg 8y agoIt's not 'accusing'. It's just making a mistake. And either way, that's not any sort of evidence of the piece being written by some three letter agency.
- JoachimSchipper 8y agoDuckDuckGo just really doesn’t matter to this piece (which is about ideology and power, not tech). Still an error that they shouldn’t have made, but it is a “minor” error.
- tptacek 8y agoThere's a credible argument that Snowden didn't even bother to confirm how many documents he extracted from NSA intranet servers before disclosing them en masse to people he barely knew, so there's an irony to trying to ding this article for getting a count wrong.
- dandare 8y ago> The question of whether or not Snowden was a Russian asset all along has been raised and debated. No evidence has been found that he was, just as no evidence has been found that he was a spy for China. ... We can’t know. Wikipedia: Fear, uncertainty and doubt (often shortened to FUD) is a disinformation strategy...
- skybrian 8y agoUncertainty and doubt are not actually bad. There are a whole lot questions we don't have good answers for, and so we should be comfortable admitting what we don't know. You can keep questions in mind without immediately answering them. On the other hand there are what I call the "instant experts" who are quick to take sides on something they were ignorant of yesterday, just because they read something about it in the news.
- ivanhoe 8y agoYou're confusing the scientific rational doubt, and projected, induced, completely irrational and paranoid feeling of doubtful fear and uncertainty that distorts peoples' perception and makes them panic and act irrational, and do and accept things and compromises they otherwise never would. The fear of the dark, if you will. And whether it's government pushing for more control, or pimps/mafia/molesters pushing their victims into submission, the mechanisms are very similar, they always first sell you the fear and then offer the protection from it (if you do as told, of course).
- skybrian 8y agoOne person's rational doubt is another's paranoid doubt. I thought the original article expressed rational doubt. Without evidence, I lean towards assuming Snowden's motives are what he says they are. But after all, none of us (I assume) actually know him. He's a person in the news.
- notafraudster 8y agoThis claim struck me as especially dumb. We can easily determine whether or not he was a Russian asset by asking the question "Why is he in Russia?" He is in Russia because the U.S. cancelled his passport after he left China and before he got to Ecuador. He hasn't been able to leave because the U.S. won't restore his passport. And he's still on a temporary Russian visa. And even if he found a way to fly, the last time the United States thought (incorrectly) he was on a plane, they forced the plane (which was registered as a diplomatic flight) to land. The conspiracy that he was flipped by Russia after he got there is at least not contradicted by the obvious facts, but a claim that he was a Russian agent all along is asinine.
- twblalock 8y agoThis is a pretty smart article. The author makes a solid attempt to explain one of the weirder things about Snowden, Assange, and Greenwald, and the other people in their orbit — why do people who care about transparency and revealing government wrongdoing appear to defend and/or support Putin? I’m not entirely convinced by the explanation, but it’s the best one I’ve seen so far, and a lot of these people’s actions make more sense if the author is right about what motivates them.
- kgarten 8y agoCan you point to one instance where Snowden supported/defended Putin or opinions of Putin? Couldn’t find one in the article.
- pvg 8y agoSeveral such instances are listed in the article, the argument is pretty clearly stated. If you don't find it convincing, that's one thing but claiming it's not there when it plainly is is just odd.
- kgarten 8y agoThe article claims a lot ... yet I cannot find any source interviews where Snowden defended Putin.
- pvg 8y agoThat's not what you asked. The article lists several occurrences which the author interprets as support for Putin. You said you read the article and found no such thing. That's not a reasonable representation of the article. Or of reading.
- kgarten 8y agoSeveral? Snowden is brought into association with Assange and Greenwald, a lot of the instances you are talking about mentioned in the article are not related to Snowden but to Wikileaks etc. I don’t know any instance where Snowden was in direct support or defended Putin (even from the article). The only “Support” from Snowden was showing up in a TV show with Putin asking him 2 questions. Still my question holds: when did Snowden defend Putin? (and can you get a source interview or statement directly from Snowden … not associations over actions of 3rd parties).
- Aqueous 8y agoI can come up with no better summation of the damage Snowden has done to liberal democracies and the rule of law than his quote near the end: "...Politics will take us only so far and if history is any guide, they are the least reliable means of achieving effective change" In other words Snowden's taught millions of young people he influences that working within the frameworks of politics and the law is pointless and can't create the lasting change they hope for. This is not only incredibly childish and destructive - it's inaccurate. Politics and the rule of law have have provided protections for racial, sexual, religious minority populations in dozens of countries around the globe, have destroyed institutional slavery, and have created the largest sustained creation of broad-based wealth in human history. It's provided universal health care for millions of people across Europe and the Americas, defeated totalitarianism in two global conflicts, launched people into space, and created the technological revolution without which we wouldn't be having this debate today. We're not perfect. Nobody claims we are. But politics and law are how we improve ourselves.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoWhen were there two global conflicts between "politics and the rule of law" on one side and "totalitarianism" on the other side? Perhaps the strategies you're referring to under the term "politics and the rule of law" are more effective at promoting some goals than they are at other goals?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- abtinf 8y agoThis is like blaming the underground railroad for the civil war.
- kgarten 8y agoSo what happens if a you realize your government is not adhering to the law? Shouldn’t you inform the public? That’s what Snowden did, with high costs to himself. Snowden taught a generation to have a moral compass. This article adds no new insides. Instead it drifts off in conspiracy theories.
- the-red-herring 8y agoWell, there is always some degree to "fake news" in every article you read, but yes I agree that Edward Snowden is a patriot. William Binney probably had the perfect solution to counter domestic and international terrorism, however his program was shutdown because the majority of the people working for Uncle Sam at the time wanted something far more than stopping terrorists. Sure, they may have had good intentions, but with power like this, there is no stopping others from coming along and corrupting it for their own purposes.
- NN88 8y agoSo we're supposed to be OK with this? >Snowden’s tweets and lectures have real-world impact. After his disclosures, Tor’s usership shot up from a million to six million. He repeatedly tweeted to his followers that they should use Tor and Signal. Tor’s default search engine DuckDuckGo, which claims to protect privacy by refraining from the profiling that other browsers do in order to provide personalized searches, saw a 600 percent increase in traffic over just a few months. One of DuckDuckGo’s partners is Yandex, Russia’s government-controlled search engine, although the company says it does not allow the collection or sharing of user data by its partners. Certification by the Snowden brand may well be the chief reason that so much faith is now placed uncritically in these platforms. Really?