2 ms·
The idea of older individuals being flightless is specifically addressed in the Plos article linked at the top. Basically, the large individuals still have lots
by andrewflnr 8y ago
The idea of older individuals being flightless is specifically addressed in the Plos article linked at the top. Basically, the large individuals still have lots of flight-optimized characteristics that you would expect to have atrophied if they weren't flying.
- curtis 8y agoFrom the referenced article [https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0013982 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...]: > It is possible, however, that giant pterosaurs represent old, flightless individuals of a species that were capable of flight when younger, their flight anatomy simply being retained from a previous stage in their life history. However, if the maximum flight sizes suggested by Sato et al. [17] and Chatterjee and Templin [19] are correct at 41kg (5.1 m span) or 70 kg (6.65 m with ‘heavy’ estimates), then the largest azhdarchids would have grown up to six times the mass and twice the wingspan of their terminal flight size. It seems unlikely that enormous azhdarchids would continue to develop their physiologically expensive flight apparatus, and coincidentally with a mechanically appropriate scaling regime, throughout such extensive growth under flightless conditions. The same point is true, though to a lesser extent, for large Pteranodon that also bear obvious flight characteristics despite having exceeded the suggested wingspan limits of flight. If anything, the scaling regimes of pterosaur wings dictate that the flight characteristics of giant pterosaurs (the size of their deltopectoral crests, robustness of their joints) - become more exaggerated with size and age (e.g. [76]), precisely the opposite of what would be expected in animals that lost their flight ability as they grew older. This doesn't help me understand the physics of large flying reptiles, but it does make a plausible argument that they were in fact real.