9 ms·
I was totally on the hate train with how ridiculous it was to remove the headphone jack, and how unnecessary Bluetooth headphones were... ...but once I got my
by crazygringo 8y ago
I was totally on the hate train with how ridiculous it was to remove the headphone jack, and how unnecessary Bluetooth headphones were...
...but once I got my first pair of Bluetooth headphones and realized I never need to deal with tangled/frayed/broken/caught wires again, I'm never looking back. Charging turned out to be, surprisingly, a non-issue.
I'm totally convinced Bluetooth headphones are the way forwards, and it's silly to have a jack for old tech. And for the small x% of the time or x% of the users where things like latency or line-out are needed... there's a dongle, it works perfectly, and it's fine. And if you need to charge at the same time, get a dongle that charges at the same time.
That's the whole point of dongles -- a smaller/simpler device for 90-99% of people, at the cost of a tiny bit more expensive/complex solution for the remaining 1-10%.
Feels like the right tradeoff to me.
- chewz 8y agoI own really good bluetooth headphone and they work great. But at the same time I own really expensive jack phones which are tiny and I can keep them in my pocket. And I have always string of various 10$ headphones (Philips mostly) that I loose when jogging and destroy when biking. My point is - bluetooth getting better and more accessible - there is a place for compact and cheap headphones that do not require charging. And getting rid od headphone jack takes that away.
- jonknee 8y ago> And getting rid od headphone jack takes that away. Why? You can use your wired headphones just fine...
- tomc1985 8y agoWith an adapter, which is what a lot of people don't want.
- mrep 8y agoNot to mention those adapters break constantly and you can lose them. I'm on my fourth one and have been in a few situations where I wanted to use my headphones but low and behold, I don't have the adapter with me.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoAnd they only work one way - you can use the adapter to use 3.5mm headphones with your iphone, but there is no adapter to let the iphone lightning headphones with an imac or ipad or macbook.
- derefr 8y agoThe lightning headphones are accepting a digital signal and have a DAC inside the cable. Even with the correct physically-wired adapter (you could create one by bridging a regular USB to Lightning adapter to the Lightning headphones, if you wanted), a computer attached to them would see a USB DAC, and would need a driver for said DAC. Until such a time as such drivers are written, for every OS, that adapter wouldn't function the way people expect it to (i.e. universally), so they don't bother making it.
- ianai 8y agoYou just wrote the argument for lightning being the wrong protocol for headphones.
- derefr 8y ago"Not having a headphone jack" doesn't imply "Lightning connector headphones", though. Plenty of other phone manufacturers are also shipping phones without headphone jacks now. They tend to ship with earbuds that have a micro-USB or USB-C connector; which have a DAC inside; and where said DAC uses the USB audio standard. That being said, there's nothing stopping Apple from making earbuds with a Lightning connector that are USB Audio compatible as well. There's nothing about the "Lightning protocol" that makes this impossible. They just... didn't, with their current Lightning earbuds. Maybe the number of people it would benefit didn't outweigh the cost-savings of eliminating USB signalling components, or added too much audio-latency, or something.
- reversecs 8y agoI haven't used one myself but I've heard the dongles are horrific. They overheat, and sound quality fades as temperature rises. This was a couple weeks ago my friends were telling me they couldn't get anything decent for their pixel2 on Amazon everything is cheap and produces the same result.
- salutonmundo 8y agoDefinitely true. I don't have one, because I'm not an idiot, but I know someone who does -- the dongle outright stops working when it gets too hot.
- briandear 8y ago..and when those Bluetooth headphones are AirPods, it’s very easy to never look back. I do a fair bit of work with Logic and Ableton and consider myself reasonably advanced when it comes to audio production. When I am doing recording or mixing on my Mac, the built-in headphone jack is never used: it’s always a fairly high end audio interface. Since AirPods, I can’t remember the last time I actually plugged into the Mac’s headphone jack: it’s either using “pro” headphones via the audio interface or AirPods. While I can appreciate the headphone-jack vitriol on iPhone, I can’t help but drawing parallels with the ditching of the DVD drive. At the time that happened, people were losing their minds for a variety of similar reasons. I used to own mixers that only took 1/4inch plugs and remember to have a 1/8inch adaptor was a real pain, however it just became commonplace. My point is that having a lightning to 1/8th adaptor is no bigger of a deal than having a 1/8->1/4 inch adaptor.
- fossuser 8y agoI must be in the small % of people with ears that don’t work for AirPods. My right ear doesn’t hold it and if I’m moving at all (walking) it’ll fall out. I wish they made in ear phones like the shure style ear phones - even Apple’s old design was better for me.
- TheJoYo 8y agothe latency will bone you if you do live sampling.
- amluto 8y ago> ..and when those Bluetooth headphones are AirPods, it’s very easy to never look back. Indeed. Because if your ears aren’t the same shape as the prototypical Apple ears, and you look back, or anywhere else, the earphones fall out.
- philjohn 8y agoQuestion - have you tried the airpods themselves? Because they weigh far less I know people who always had Apple ear pods fall out have no issues with AirPods. And remember - other wireless headphone manufacturers are available, Beats do over ear ones that use the same W1 chip (super simple pairing with mac devices).
- tomc1985 8y agoUgh, no. Those considerations are fine for people who are like you. Some of us have different considerations and we're sick of being run over by these convenience freaks To all the downvoters, these are some reasons: * Low latency applications * Existing high-end hardware one may own (old Sennheisers mop the floor with a pair of "high end" Beats) * same port in use everywhere for past 50 years, there are a ridiculous amount of products for it * Ability to connect a non-USB headphone amp * Everybody understands it * No need to charge your headphones(!) * No stupidly expensive tech to license to make something as simple and dumb as headphones * No stupidly complicated tech to master to make something as simple and dumb as headphones * WHY would you put logic and circuitry in a simple mechanical device?? Do manufacturers just LOVE skyrocketing costs? * Do any of these guys value simplicity in design any more? Or is tech charging full-steam into unnecessary complexity? And on the subject of wireless standards: * Other 2.4ghz wireless standards have way better range. (I used to work in a large factory-type building with literally thousands of consumer printers all turned and broadcasting their individualized ad-hoc 802.11 signals. We would have chronic issues with the Wi-Fi (on account of thousands of networks) and I could be on the other side of the building with my headphones and still get clear audio. (Oftentimes it would cut out depending on location but the range I saw was a good 3x what I could get with bluetooth) * * * C'mon this is like 100-year-old tech that everyone understands and loves, EXCEPT for the cable. Way for the technology makers to throw out the baby with the bathwater, so that they can sell you their crap all over again.
- TheJoYo 8y agoI have high end sennheisers and airbuds. The only time I pull out my sennheisers is when im doing recording or live sampling. Bluetooth is opensource, it's not overly complicated it's just new to you. This technology was already being used in live performances with no one complaining.
- userbinator 8y agoit's not overly complicated it's just new to you Download the Bluetooth specification and try to read it. How is that not "overly complicated" compared to three copper wires?
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoSome of us don’t want extra radiation right next to our brains for the sake of convenience.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoWhen I used plug-in headphones, they’d all break within weeks and start automatically skipping and enabling Voice Control, when I have all voice command options disabled. Bluetooth headphones come with a headache, but mine haven’t broken in a month. I call it a clear improvement.
- codethief 8y agoWhat plug-in headphones were you using? Honest question because I've never had any trouble.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoA variety of brands. Sony, UiiSii, SoundPEETS, for the ones I bought online. (I bought more pairs elsewhere.)
- chris11 8y agoYeah, I have the same problem. Cords on my headphone are always the first to go. But it's not really an issue, my cheap pairs are cheap enough that I don't care, and higher quality headphones have detachable cords that can be replaced.
- 4ad 8y agoThat's because you buy shitty headphones. My Stax SR-3 headphones are 50 years old.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoI was buying earphones in the 20-30 dollar range. Yes, they were cheaper (though not the cheapest), but I didn’t want to spend a lot of money on headphones on my grad student budget. How much should I expect to pay for quality headphones with the jack that last?
- mixmastamyk 8y ago
- shkkmo 8y ago> That's the whole point of dongles -- a smaller/simpler device for 90-99% of people, at the cost of a tiny bit more expensive/complex solution for the remaining 1-10%. I like your completely made up numbers. Basing of the sales numbers from the article, this is the argument you are making: A smaller/simpler device for 17% of people and a solution that is up to 2x more expensive and far less convenient and functional for the remaining 83%.
- tastyface 8y agoIt still makes me mad that I can't use my Apogee JAM in any practical way with new iPhones. Bluetooth is way too laggy and there doesn't exist an adaptor that lets you use data and analog-out at the same time. The only option is to use the built-in speakers.
- jpalomaki 8y agoAfter getting new fairly expensive Bose Bluetooth headset I started wondering about the lousy sound quality when making VoIP calls on PC (Windows/Lenovo). Turns out others have similar complaints [1]. Vendors seem to claim that the problem is the low bandwidth available. I suspect the real reason is that they don't want to standardize on more modern (complicated) codecs for this purpose as it would make the headset more complicated and increase cost. [1] https://www.howtogeek.com/354321/why-bluetooth-headsets-are-terrible-on-windows-pcs/ https://www.howtogeek.com/354321/why-bluetooth-headsets-are-...
- vonseel 8y agoAgain, like the other guy below, ugh - no. I’m a musician and have thousands of voice memos from writing tapes over the years. Those effing dongles disappear on me. I actually prefer the dongle + old iPod headphones to newer Lightning headphones, because I can plug them into EVERYTHING ELSE. Bluetooth headphones don’t play voice memos (built-in iOS application) back at a normal (acceptable) nitrate. It’s been that way for years and Apple refuses to fix it. I’m sure there are plenty of other arguments for including headphone jack. I mean, I have probably 10 sets of nice headphones in my studio that all use a standard connector. It’s real frustrating to have to consider going Android just to get a headphone jack on my device.
- bigtunacan 8y agoBluetooth is alright for audio only like listening to music. For games though (a huge percentage of users) Bluetooth is trash on the iPhone. The latency is a huge issue; something will occur in game and then there are noticeable delays before you here the accompanying sound. This ruins the immersion of games when it happens.
- screye 8y ago> a smaller/simpler device for 90-99% of people, This is exactly my complaint. The device is just the same with zero improvements to show for this change. The proportions are also closer to 60-40 than 90-10.