6 ms·
Is there enough bandwidth available in a cubicle farm or 787 for everyone to use their airpods? I doubt it. Headphone jack was a nice reliable piece of hardwar
by exabrial 8y ago
Is there enough bandwidth available in a cubicle farm or 787 for everyone to use their airpods?
I doubt it. Headphone jack was a nice reliable piece of hardware. Thank goodness some other brands are rooted in reality.
- newsbinator 8y agoThat's a good question. What number of AirPods users would there have to be on a 787 for the interference to become a problem?
- threeseed 8y agoHeadphone jack is a nice reliable piece of hardware. But it comes at the expense of more space for batteries or features that more people will use. Ethernet is more reliable than WiFi. Power is more reliable than batteries. But the world doesn't want wires so Apple has to listen.
- e1ven 8y agoA) They could make it thicker. It’s not an either/or. B) No one was calling for the elimination of the headphone jack. Every poll shows broad support for it. Apple themselves said it took ‘courage’ which is not the adjective you’d use to describe an action that the world agrees with.
- threeseed 8y agoSure they could make it thicker. But they won't because I suspect over the last decade they have done market research which tells them IMHO the obvious: nobody wants a thicker phone. Common sense suggests that if the world wanted a thicker phone then one of the hundreds of OEMs would have made one and been successful at it. But yet that has never happened.
- huntie 8y agoI've consistently heard people say that they would prefer a thicker phone if it meant greater battery life, so clearly there isn't nobody who wants a thicker phone.
- isostatic 8y agoBuy a mophie or similar batterycase. What I'd like is a mophie with a 3.5mm jack in that connects to a modern iphone.
- tonyjstark 8y agoIt probably takes "courage" to make a phone thicker... I see myself using my phone less and less to listen to music, sometimes because I forget the dongle. Mind you, I also have bluetooth headphones but they're not very handy on business trips where I need to think about yet another cable and about actually recharging them.
- yardstick 8y agoI’m someone who always has the smart battery case on my iPhone, effectively doubling its size. I wouldn’t dream of leaving the house without the case attached. Apple has demonstrated that they can offer multiple models of differing dimensions and internals, but they won’t even consider this.
- detaro 8y agoRecent iPhones have been getting slightly thicker though, afaik the 6+ was the thinnest.
- coupdejarnac 8y agoThe strange parts guy on youtube added a headphone jack to the iPhone 7. So, I think the stated reason for removing the headphone jack to make room for the battery is complete BS. https://youtu.be/utfbE3_uAMA https://youtu.be/utfbE3_uAMA Also, why are you responding to the question about limited RF spectrum? It's like you have an agenda in this thread.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoOnePlus did a poll that got the answer 88% of customers wanted them to keep the headphone jack. Which they then got rid of anyway. Presumably the poll was hoped or expected to reinforce a decision already made. It's very clear consumers aren't clamouring for losing the jack. There are a lot more dollars selling wireless and they have an inherent limited life thanks to battery lifespan. The SE, with a headphone jack, is roughly the same thickness as the new XS without. They both have bluetooth for those who might like wireless. That's not Apple or whoever listening, that's them imposing.
- threeseed 8y agoOf course consumers want the headphone jack. Nobody likes having any functionality taken away. But did the poll ask them which they want: Thinner iPhone/No Headphone or Thicker iPhone/Headphone
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoThe XS is 7.7mm thick, the SE 7.6mm. It's not a relevant question. Were the new generation of phones thinner than the jack I'd have to concede you may have a point, but that is not what we're getting. If the question becomes "would you like 0.2% more battery or a headphone jack?" I doubt many would vote to remove.
- timjver 8y agoI doubt the difference will only be 0.2%.
- zaroth 8y agoMy rough calculation is that you get 165 mAh for every 1 cubic cm. A headphone jack will take approximately 1 cubic centimeter inside the case. The iPhone X battery is rated for 2716 mAh. So if you could use 100% of that volume efficiently for increasing battery volume, I think battery capacity increases approximately 6%.
- 8y ago
- reustle 8y agoComparing the headphone jack and Ethernet port is silly. A great majority of users use the jack for headphones which are always within 1 meter of the device. Ethernet is often much further away, meaning wireless adds more value / convenience.
- cesarb 8y agoNot to mention that with Ethernet (and wired power) the user is tethered to a fixed place, while with wired headphones on a cell phone the user can get up and move freely, since both ends of the wire are moving together.
- po1nter 8y ago> But it comes at the expense of more space for batteries or features that more people will use. Yet Samsung did fit a 4000 mAh battery, a headphone jack, wireless charging, expendable storage, fingerprint sensor, 512Gb of storage AND a PEN in their IP68 Note 9.
- discordance 8y agoAnyone that has walked through Shinjuku, Tokyo or Shinagawa station in peak hour with Bluetooth headphones will be able to confirm that there is not enough spectrum. I get audio drop outs with airpods everytime I pass through one of the above stations.
- bschwindHN 8y agoOh wow that's good to know, I pass through Shinjuku every day but I don't have bluetooth headphones.
- raverbashing 8y agoGood job Apple! Funny how they really should have worried about this but apparently haven't. But you can still use the lightning earphones that come together (or buy a dongle, since the newer model phones are dropping the adapter). 3rd party dongles are cheaper and some allow you to charge and listen to music at the same time.
- pjmlp 8y agoAre they even allowed to use them on the 787?! I fly regularly and have yet to be on a EU flight where Bluetooth is allowed. And even for wlan only since one year we started to get planes where it is allowed at cruise altitude.
- tachion 8y agoSince a year or two in entire EU using any electronic devices is completely allowed (except for a takeoff and landing but that's for security reasons in case of emergency) so I'm not sure where are you flying. I've been using my Momentums' without a single issue for few years now and I fly a lot.
- pjmlp 8y agoMostly Eurowings, Ryanair, TAP, Alitalia, Aegean, British Airways, Austrian Airlines, Lufthansa, Iberia, Condor, Thomas Cook, Finnair. I am yet to hear that I can turn Bluetooth on after the security debriefing and even though I fly regularly, so far just boarded like two flights where there was on-flight wlan available.
- SSLy 8y agoIf you're on a Lufthansa flight I'd recommend reading the safety card or the in-flight magazine. One of them usually mentions BT is allowed at cruise altitude.
- pjmlp 8y agoI will have a look at it next time, thanks.
- toyg 8y agoYou have to turn everything off for takeoff and landing, but inbetween it's all fine - the only difference left between airlines is whether they'll leave people use airplane-mode during takeoff. But don't ask attendants - regardless of actual regulations, when in doubt on a technical point they will always err on the side of caution and tell you to shut it down.
- cimmanom 8y agoOr a crowded subway car. Or a midtown NYC street at 8:45am. Argh. Apple, not everyone lives in the suburbs and uses their phones primarily at home or in personal vehicles.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- semitext 8y agoI am amazed this issue isn't raised more often. The majority of my headphone usage is in downtown San Francisco. Any wireless headphones will break up like every other second. For my purposes they are useless.
- jpalomaki 8y agoSome adaptive system for adjusting the transmission power might help. Now I can leave my phone on the desk and wonder to the other floor and other end of the apartment with my AirPods working just fine. Or do they already have something like this?