3 ms·
> Am I just missing some information in this regard? A major, and non-negotiable, design goal of Lua is that it targets the ANSI C environment to maximise port
by jacques_chester 16y ago
> Am I just missing some information in this regard?
A major, and non-negotiable, design goal of Lua is that it targets the ANSI C environment to maximise portability. ANSI C does not define Unicode support.
Incidentally, those two libraries might be unchanged because they're stable. The rate of change in the main lua implementation is quite measured.
- kylecordes 16y ago(I'm the guy in the video.) I haven't had a need for Unicode in Lua, but when I stumbled across some information about it, the essential story was that there is nothing stopping you from writing code to manipulate Unicode data (obviously), but there is also nothing built in to help you. All the built in string stuff is ANSI/ASCII/whatever. However, the language Io (which often gets mentioned in the same breath as Lua, though it's quite different in some ways) has a stronger Unicode story: http://www.iolanguage.com/scm/io/docs/IoGuide.html#Unicode http://www.iolanguage.com/scm/io/docs/IoGuide.html#Unicode
- metamemetics 16y agoAre you affiliated with Lambda Lounge in STL?
- kylecordes 16y agoYes! I know the guy who started Lambda Lounge (Alex Miller http://tech.puredanger.com/about http://tech.puredanger.com/about ) and heartily supported its founding; I spoke at it every once in a while; and my firm (Oasis Digital http://oasisdigital.com/ http://oasisdigital.com/ ) sponsors Lambda Lounge by paying for travel expenses for out-of-town speakers. Lambda Lounge is the best software dev user group ever.
- puredanger 16y agoI'm Alex Miller, the founder of Lambda Lounge. If you want to drop me a line email me at contact at puredanger.com
- benatkin 16y agoThe Lua philosophy is far different from the philosophy of other languages. That's why videos like these, that cover the advantages before the tradeoffs, are a good thing. Knowing the positive things about something really effects my perceptions of the tradeoffs. Also, Unicode is an odd thing to consider to be an essential part of a programming language. Usually when I hear it I think the person must think it's a part of accepting those that speak other languages. I would point out the fact that Ruby took much longer to get Unicode support than Python as a counterpoint to that, as Ruby's creator, Matz, is Japanese.
- jacques_chester 16y ago> Also, Unicode is an odd thing to consider to be an essential part of a programming language. It really depends on what the language is used for. Web-facing applications are, in general, going to received unicode input, so for them it matters. But for an embedded programmer, for example, it might be utterly irrelevant. Horses for courses, really. It just so happens that Lua has other properties that are very attractive to web apps too, which the presentation outlined. -- and yes, still alive and commenting :P
- arkx 16y agoAs a Finnish software dev I can say that in these days native support for Unicode is a must. We have a couple of special characters in the alphabet (åäö) and if you have to do a lot of manual work to use these, the programming language is pretty much unusable for real world stuff that involves any use of Finnish. The fact that Ruby took so long to get real Unicode support is due to Japanese resisting Unicode in favor of their own encodings, EUC-JP and Shift JIS, just like Finnish used to cling to ISO-8859-1(5) for so long.
- silentbicycle 16y agoIs Unicode something that needs to be in the core of a language, or is it sufficient to leave it to libraries, if the language's design doesn't prevent it? On this computer (OpenBSD/i386), icu has over 1 MB of libraries and a 15 MB data file. The whole Lua distribution fits in one 200k library. Bloating the core language with that seems impractical.
- silentbicycle 16y agoMore specifically, Unicode is one of those things (like bignum support) where Lua's design for embedding assumes that if it's a priority, your project will already have settled on a library for it, so anything Lua came bundled with would just get in the way. The GMP library, for example, is almost four times larger than the whole Lua runtime. Besides, Lua strings are interned raw byte-arrays (like atoms in Erlang or Lisp atoms), and can have \0s and other arbitrary binary data. While the standard string library is ignorant of Unicode, there's nothing preventing extra libraries from providing Unicode-aware string operations. Lua also left out native regular expression support, because it would be larger than the rest of the standard libraries put together. You can just load LPEG if it matters.
- indigoviolet 16y agoI wouldn't have a problem with external unicode support if there was one "standard" recommended library that had a strong community behind it. My whole point is that that doesn't appear to exist.
- silentbicycle 16y agoSure. This is a real issue for new Lua users, though in the long run it's not a showstopper. For roughly half the people using Lua, library choices have already been decided by the big C++ (or whatever) project they're adding Lua to, so the question never arises in the first place. That's the primary use case for Lua. It's a really nice standalone language, too, but it was designed for embedding. Many of its strengths (such as the small, orthogonal, clean design) come from that focus, but so do some quirks. If you use Lua as a standalone language, you'll occasionally need to do some digging for libraries, particularly if you're not comfortable with C. The situation has been improving significantly over the last year or two, though. I don't have a specific Unicode library recommendation, but would suggest checking the mailing list archives (http://lua-users.org/lists/lua-l/ http://lua-users.org/lists/lua-l/).
- indigoviolet 16y agoslnunicode hasn't changed or been updated, and has no forum posts or bugs since 2006 [http://luaforge.net/projects/sln/ http://luaforge.net/projects/sln/] ICU4Lua hasn't been touched since April 2009, and is at 0.2B. [http://luaforge.net/projects/icu-lua/ http://luaforge.net/projects/icu-lua/] That sort of status just doesn't inspire confidence in a language. I understand you can use it for game programming, or that you can write your own libraries for it, but that sort of thing doesn't encourage adoption.
- silentbicycle 16y agoICU4Lua is a wrapper for an existing, stable library. Does (for example) the Python wrapper for sqlite get a lot of commits these days? And if not, does that make it dead and abandoned?
- indigoviolet 16y agoWhy is it in beta? Why does the mailing list [http://lists.luaforge.net/pipermail/icu-lua-users/ http://lists.luaforge.net/pipermail/icu-lua-users/] have no activity on it?
- silentbicycle 16y agoUnless something is a major standalone project, discussion usually happens on the main Lua mailing list instead. About the beta label - I don't know. gmail was in beta for a long time, too, though.