8 ms·
If Jeff Bezos wants to help low-income people why not just pay them better?
- Zarath 8y agoThis was my exact thought when I saw he was donating his money. How about encouraging unions and providing healthcare and better pay?
- jimmaswell 8y agoWould you rather he just donate nothing and keep everything else the same, rather than donate? The scrambling to condemn this act of charity doesn't make any sense.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWhen Roman emperors were horrible enough, their own Praetorian guard took them out. The rich and powerful get their wealth from the masses and significantly impact the lives of the masses. World leaders need the people more than the people need them. An individual with a hard scrabble subsistence existence is similarly well off whether they have a hut and must hunt for food or live in a trailer and have some shit job. But wealth at the top has increased tremendously as world population has increased. Bezos is not exempt from people getting tired of his crap and he would be wise to listen up and do something more effective.
- late2part 8y agoThe rich are well aware of the risk of pitchforks. That’s why this is done.
- DoreenMichele 8y agohttps://www.bloomberg.com/features/2018-rich-new-zealand-doomsday-preppers/ https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2018-rich-new-zealand-doo... Articles like the above suggest the rich aren't really aware enough or trying hard enough to avoid a dystopian nightmare future. Their luxuries require a functioning world. Locking themselves away in a bunker like a self imposed prison after they make sure everything goes to hell appears to be their current idiotic plan.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoThe leaked Citigroup memos indicate their advisors are telling them about the voter threat if they didn't already know. The response is to pay media to brainwash them into thinking it's a good system where they can become well-off, too. https://politicalgates.blogspot.com/2011/12/citigroup-plutonomy-memos-two-bombshell.html https://politicalgates.blogspot.com/2011/12/citigroup-pluton... Plus, they give people plenty of distractions to shout at instead of improve their situation. Human nature takes over from there.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIf the world comes apart at the seams, it won't matter whether or not the people are sheeple who have all been bamboozled. It will still negatively impact the people at the top creating these problems. It may be "stupidity" rather than malice driving this. What I'm saying is they need to up their game out of enlightened self interest, even if they don't care one bit about the people. If the de facto pie shrinks due to global mismanagement of resources, the richest of the rich have the most to lose.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoI think the financial crisis taught us that clearly enough. Going on some of the surprised reactions from senior bankers they all appear locked away in their bubbles just as securely as any post-apocalypse bunker. Looking at politics around the world it seems like the world is slowly demonstrating that we learned nothing from the history of the 1930s.
- wholinator2 8y agoThey're not condemning the act of charity, they're condemning the working conditions he subjects his employees to. Yes, the act of charity is better than nothing but it seems people think that money might be better spent on improving the quality of the jobs he offers from the dismal self-destruction they are famous for. Also pointing out that donating to charity ends up being tax deductible so it is truly the most selfish public display of giving and that treating your workers with human decency would be a selfless act he seems unwilling to do.
- leetcrew 8y ago> Also pointing out that donating to charity ends up being tax deductible so it is truly the most selfish public display i mean, he still ends up with less money. he just doesn't get taxed on the money he gives away. one could argue that donating is more tax efficient than paying workers more, because then their income would be taxed.
- bostik 8y ago> donating is more tax efficient than paying workers more, because then their income would be taxed. Eh? Taxing a corporation less is better than having its employees earn more?
- leetcrew 8y agoI was talking about tax efficiency in that post, not any grand moral claim. although since we're on this topic, I would note that the US already spends as much or more money per grade school student than most of the European countries that we look to as models. this leads me to think that just shoving more tax dollars into the bureaucratic rube goldberg machine might actually be less impactful than a targeted charity effort.
- brodyprice 8y agoSo condemn the working conditions of the company then. What does that have to do with his personal act of charity? Sure, charitable donations are tax deductible, but you say that this equates to "...truly the most selfish public display of giving..."? Why is the assumption that a wealthy person is only capable of charity for tax benefits? As if he needs the tax deductions to retain his wealth? As if he personally mistreats employees? Imperfect people are capable of honest charity.
- smhost 8y agoThe lower class is angry at the billionaires because their working/living conditions are bad. The middle class is angry at the billionaires because they're the ones who end up subsidizing the poor. Bezos dumping money on poor people is not a real solution, because it doesn't address any structural problems.
- ardy42 8y ago> Would you rather he just donate nothing and keep everything else the same, rather than donate? The scrambling to condemn this act of charity doesn't make any sense. It's not really charity if you have a hand in creating the problem. A thief who pledges to contribute 10% of his loot to help his victims isn't doing good. Likewise a multi-billionaire businessman who employs people at low wages isn't deserving of kudos for setting aside a little of his wealth to help the poor, especially when he could make decisions that would help much more.
- vixen99 8y agoCreate a fabulously successful business that puts 350,000 jobs on offer (that didn't exist before Amazon was built), and you're likened to a thief? What in this press release, https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/response-to-senator-sanders/ https://blog.aboutamazon.com/company-news/response-to-senato... - is inaccurate? It would be headline news if it was. Currently it appears that the US is enjoying extremely low unemployment so presumably there are plenty of other jobs around. People can vote with their feet.
- ardy42 8y ago> Create a fabulously successful business that puts 350,000 jobs on offer (that didn't exist before Amazon was built), and you're likened to a thief? No, and if you'd read more closely you'd have realized I didn't do that. I merely used a analogy involving a thief that clearly illustrates one characteristic that's relevant here. Analogies don't map one-to-one onto a topic. You really should have gotten it, too, since I didn't just stop at the analogy. I went to apply the concept it was meant to illustrate directly to the situation. Furthermore, the fact that Amazon is a "job creator" doesn't hold it, its labor practices, or the jobs it creates above criticism.
- Zarath 8y agoI mean I'm happy he's donating, but why bother with the exploit -> profit -> donate to exploited cycle when it is fully in your power to break it in the first place? I think the reason it is getting flak is that it seems disingenuous considering the massive amount of power he has to improve the lives of his workers.
- sieabahlpark 8y agoProbably because he's trying to improve the roots of poverty than just for his company. To do that unfortunately he needs exploit. It's not great, but if people are dumb enough to still do the jobs at those rates it's not going to change. The wages would go up if all the people actually created a need for them to go up.
- Thriptic 8y agoTo play devil's advocate, if Bezos donates two billion, that's basically a one time fixed cost. He can decide not to donate any more money down the line if he chooses. If he raises wages, he will be paying at least that much in labor costs in perpetuity. He can't easily walk back his salary bumps later without enraging his workers. In addition, if he gives people raises, they will be pleased....for about a year. Then people will establish that as the new normal and demand further raises because he capitulated the first time so why not try again.
- nickpsecurity 8y agoThat's not what happened at his competitors that invested in workers like Publix and Costco. They were happy enough with their wages and work environment being better than the rest that they stick with the company working hard. The industry has a tracker for customer satisfaction. They're high in it regularly. Your hypothesis didn't play out when management were committed to taking care of employees with a good baseline.
- dghughes 8y agoI'd say Amazon can start with just simply allowing employees to use the bathroom without it affecting their performance target. It seems some employees piss into a bottle while at their work station.
- elvirs 8y agobecause charity is an ideal for stroking his ego while writing off taxes.
- goatherders 8y agoAmazon is a publicly traded company. As CEO, even though he has a lot of sway, Bezos has a responsibility to maximize shareholder value. Half of that is maximizing profits. Half is controlling costs.
- melling 8y agoThat old myth: http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-warren-shareholder-myth-20180816-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-warren-shareho...
- slededit 8y agoNot the best article - if it’s a myth why does Senator Warren need to introduce new legislation?
- neltnerb 8y agoBecause it looks good, and companies need some pressure to adopt new practices that go against their institutional assumptions, even if the new practices are better. Not sure if I agree with her about employee votes or community votes or thresholds, but they're interesting ideas to think about. Obviously it's not getting passed anytime soon, so I read it as a starting point for a conversation. I think both make logical sense, thinking of it as required unionization and an adjustment to require companies that have more power than towns take those towns into account somehow. Definitely an approach to think about. Occasionally, industries will ask as a group to be regulated because it's too hard or risky to take a step on their own, even if they all agree it's a good idea. Salt would be an example where the big companies all generally agree they can easily reduce it without anyone noticing if they all do it at the same time, but if only one does it they'll taste noticeably worse. So the only way they can figure to start reducing salt is by getting a regulation written to make it happen. It's a curious system.
- slededit 8y agoI’m actually interested in proof it is a myth - but this article is not it. It’s an ad for Senator Warrens re-election campaign
- dfischer 8y agoWow this is ridiculous. The fund is aimed at homeless and educating early. This is not relevant to anyone he employs. Some people are so ready to get their pitch forks. Damn.
- eganist 8y agoWalmart recently learned that paying people more than enough to get off of government benefits would more often precipitate better engagement and loyalty to the company, resulting in less frequent turnover, etc. (https://qz.com/work/1094309/walmart-yes-walmart-is-making-changes-that-could-help-reduce-income-inequality-in-america/ https://qz.com/work/1094309/walmart-yes-walmart-is-making-ch...) Amazon has yet to learn this one little trick. They think they're being clever by underpaying unskilled labor and leaving them to rely partly on government benefits, but then they end up having to make up for it by hiring more often, losing time to training, having to load up schedules to make up for lost time (making each employee more expensive anyway), and ultimately defending themselves against nasty articles documenting their work practices. If Walmart--the company which practically invented the practice--can move on from it, so can Amazon... a company that's mastered the art of reinvesting profits both for continual growth and to dodge Wall Street payouts for well over a decade.
- P_I_Staker 8y agoI definitely think this is true. Paying as little as possible doesn't necessarily result in increased profits. It can be so shortsighted, when all your employees are miserable and hate the companies guts.
- rsj_hn 8y agoAlso, CostCo. But the king has to be in-n-out -- no one treats their employees better than industry peers. https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/nation-now/2018/01/25/n-out-mangers-make-160-000-per-year-reports-show/1065434001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/nation-now/2018/01/25/n... But, if I'm allowed to be cute and meaningless, Bezos' wealth comes from Amazon stock, whose value comes from its future earning potential. Pay workers more, and that stock becomes worth less, so there is less to give away. But because Amazon doesn't earn any money today, the present valuation comes from promises of future fat profit margins, so a simple statement by Bezos that he will continue to increase worker wages with revenue would instantly make the stock almost worthless. And of course, Amazon can't really pay workers more today, since it doesn't have fat margins, all it could do is shift expenses down, but that doesn't really end up being so significant. At a 5% discount rate, Bezos networth of, say, 100 Billion, would be enough to pay each current Amazon employee an extra $5 per hour in perpetuity, and over time, inflation would eat away at that.
- P_I_Staker 8y agoHe has an ethical responsibility not to. This is a big problem I have with capitalism and publicly traded companies. It's a problem without an answer, since I don't intend on trying other forms of government. Ultimately, his responsibility is to the shareholders. If mistreating employees is legal, and is in the best interest of shareholders, he has a responsibility to mistreat them. Doing anything else is unethical. We can haggle about whether it actually helps shareholders, especially in the long run. We can even encourage more corporate responsibility. At the end of the day, this is a tough issue to get around. This is why we need regulations with teeth.
- Mononokay 8y agoHe has a legal responsibility not to.^1 Legal does not equal ethical does not equal legal. ^1 Arguably, although even that's a topic of debate.
- P_I_Staker 8y agoI agree, the way my comment was worded was unfortunate, but I'm looking at it from a very narrow perspective. Ethics don't tend to be absolute. What's fair for one person, may seem unfair to another. The devil is in the details. It all comes down to the way you do the calculation. I think that process is perverse for many businesses.
- IntelMiner 8y agoI think you're mixing up "ethical" and "legal" responsibilities Putting humanity first over shareholders is not an "ethical" problem
- sokoloff 8y agoHe doesn’t even have the claimed legal responsibility to do so either.
- rgbrenner 8y agoHe doesn't have a legal responsibility either. This is a myth. CEOs have broad discretion to act in ways that are beneficial to a company. Costco is not acting illegally, or even against their own interests, by paying workers higher wages. They can make the very true argument that paying higher wages results in happier employees that reduces turnover (and therefore training costs), increases sales (since employees are more knowledgeable about products), and results in happier customers that increases repeat visits/member retention. If the shareholders disagree with the way that the CEO is maximizing company value, then the correct response is to replace the board through a vote, who will replace the CEO. There's no legal or ethical argument here. Costco doesn't exist in a hypothetical world where everything stays the same, but wages get reduced to minimum wage. Taking that action has costs for Costco, and the end result may or may not result in an increase or decrease of company value. Hypotheticals aren't valid legal cases.
- gesman 8y agoBecause it's expensive and has low PR value.
- omegaworks 8y agoI so wish this article went full wonk and went instead into the structural incentives and policies that cause corporations to behave in this way. Instead we got a piece about how CEOs use philanthropy to boost their image. It leans more on a moral argument against the practice while ignoring the practical, political barriers put in place that prevent CEOs from actually doing anything about addressing wealth disparity. It almost gets there with the lobbying against tax, but not quite. Corporations are structurally sociopathic. They are legally bound to maximize shareholder value above all other concerns.
- dr1337 8y agoExactly the reason why unbridled capitalism is terrible. I'd imagine that if we had a genocide going on today, a company like Bayer would be rewarded by its shareholders for manufacturing Zyklon B since the only reason for a corporation to exist is to generate profits right?
- notSupplied 8y agoBecause profits convert to a valuation multiple. Currently Amazon enjoys a sweet sweet PE ratio, so it's more efficient to maximize profits, get rewarded by investors, and then donate personally.
- billions 8y agoWhy not give A's to C- students? Because it sets an inaccurate perspective of the rest of the world's expectations, setting them up for future failures. Homelessness is a real problem that requires creative, focused and ambitious solutions. If Bezos can even partially match Bill and Melinda Gates' accomplishments the world will be a MUCH better place (https://www.businessinsider.com/charts-bill-gates-loves-2017-2#4-extreme-poverty-is-slowly-going-extinct-4 https://www.businessinsider.com/charts-bill-gates-loves-2017...). Here's hoping Bezos gets some singles in philanthropy paving a path to home runs.
- atomical 8y agoPerhaps Bezos will make investments in research on cost effective air conditioning for warehouses.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- propman 8y agoBecause he’d go out of business and then couldn’t: grow and create billions of wealth for everyone, create and improve new technologies and have thousands of employees gain a bunch of skills and then have to downsize and employ less or raise prices which will kill their competitiveness and harm millions who buy their product. They are following the rules. The rules have given us soooooo much over the last 100 if not 10 years. They can be vastly improved but lazy, monolithic ideas that take no consideration of cause and effect is the wrong populist movement to effect meaningful change.
- Noumenon72 8y agoI imagine it's much easier to maintain a company culture where everyone is directed toward only profit than one where it's well known they are passing out extra goodies and everyone would like some.
- johnalamosisi 8y agoDirty commie
- mgarfias 8y agoMaybe because if he paid people at amz more, he has to face the shareholders? If he does it privately, he answers to himself.
- yumraj 8y agoThis doesn't make sense to me and are not mutually exclusive. Amazon Inc. employes and pays people, where as a CEO he has certain responsibilities and duties, and is answerable to the board, which he needs to take into account. Here he's donating his personal money which does not require any such considerations and he can do what he wants.
- 0xmohit 8y agoWhy should Bezos pay them better if he can get the state to compensate the workers? A new study found that 700 Amazon employees in Ohio are on food stamps: https://www.businessinsider.in/A-new-study-found-that-700-Amazon-employees-in-Ohio-are-on-food-stamps/articleshow/62511480.cms https://www.businessinsider.in/A-new-study-found-that-700-Am...
- pravinva 8y agoThe right way to look at it is that workers already on state support are people who already have a bare minimum wage lower than which they won't get out of bed for. i.e Amazon would have had to pay LESS if the state support didn't exist.
- pravinva 8y agoPoor logic. Without state support or food stamps Walmart or Amazon would pay the lower wage employees even less - because the food stamps establish a minimum bar which the employees can expect. Without that support, the market for low wage employees would be even more competitive resulting in lower wages
- em3rgent0rdr 8y ago> "Bezos has long been criticised for his glaring lack of a philanthropic arm, long after he became the richest man in modern history" Bezos only just became richest person in the world this July 2018. It is perfectly reasonable for him to wait till he gets rich enough to claim the richest person title once before entering philanthropy. Also, he is only 54. Give him a break...most CEOs haven't even retired by them. Also as CEO, Bezos has a fiduciary duty to make as much money for the company, which might unfortunately mean paying workers market rates. However by starting his own personal philanthropic fund, he can spend money for that however he believes best helps people, without worrying about what is best for a company.