3 ms·
You don't need a IOMMU with USB. USB isn't an RDMA protocol like firewire and PCI-E, so an IOMMU doesn't really even make sense in that context. But no, you'r
by monocasa 8y ago
You don't need a IOMMU with USB. USB isn't an RDMA protocol like firewire and PCI-E, so an IOMMU doesn't really even make sense in that context.
But no, you're not safe because crappy USB drivers can probably be exploited if they're expecting the USB device to be playing nice.
- tptacek 8y agoYou're not necessarily safe, but obviously no matter how isolated you make the cell baseband, you can't get past "crappy glue code can still bone you". The reality is that the HSIC interface between the AP and the baseband is --- conceptually, at least --- about the best you can possibly do.
- monocasa 8y agoSure, I was mainly addressing "If my PC satisfies those and I plug in a random USB device am I safe?" rather than the constrained case of a known baseband and single driver.
- bri3d 8y agoThe basic USB protocol does not allow for direct peripheral mastering of DMA (unlike IEEE 1394 or PCIe for example). So, barring a protocol exploit in the USB host controller, which is certainly a theoretical possibility given the enormous size of the specification, fencing off the USB host controller using the IOMMU is just an additional layer of protection, rather than a necessary boundary like it is for a PCIe or 1394 device which has access to memory natively. A USB-C/USB3 physical port makes things a bit more complicated, as it also could be attached to a controller supporting Thunderbolt, which is PCIe. The unsafe part of plugging in a USB device is probably at the OS level rather than the protocol level - in my opinion you're much more likely to be owned by something like connecting a device with a buggy or compromised driver, mounting a filesystem containing an FS exploit, or reading a file containing an application exploit than by a USB-level protocol exploit.
- monocasa 8y agoRight, that's why I said "but no, you're not safe because crappy USB drivers can probably be exploited if they're expecting the USB device to be playing nice." Finding a USB protocol level exploit would be like finding an exploitable bug in how a NIC does scatter/gather of packets. Like, notings impossible, but damn. You still shouldn't stick random unknown USB devices into your computer though.
- tzs 8y agoAlso perhaps it should be noted that if it is a USB-C connector it may be a Thunderbolt 3 port in addition to being a USB port, which may support PCI-E and allow direct access to memory by a peripheral even if there is no driver installed for that peripheral.