3 ms·
> Almost a century later, it is time for a new set of statistics. It’s time for measures that do a better job of capturing the realities of modern American life
by crazygringo 8y ago
> Almost a century later, it is time for a new set of statistics. It’s time for measures that do a better job of capturing the realities of modern American life... Fortunately, there is a nascent movement to change that. A team of academic economists... has begun publishing a version of G.D.P. that separates out the share of national income flowing to rich, middle class and poor.
I'm 1,000% for the idea of a statistic that captures a more holistic view of economic improvement.
The problem is, nobody's come up with a single number that feels ideologically neutral, because there's no agreement on what the "right" level of inequality is.
GDP is a sum you can't argue with (and easy to argue that more = better, even if not always true), and likewise unemployment is a percentage you can't argue with (and easy to argue that less = better, again even if not always true).
But even if we separate out GDP by class... it isn't clearly actionable. There's no obvious equivalent of "more = better", because it's clear that wealth increases should be spread out, but it's not clear they should be spread out equally.
The puzzle piece that seems to be lacking is some kind of rigorous justification for what the right level of inequality is in a society. But no political scientist, economist or philosopher has yet developed/proved that in any way that people generally accept.
We can't measure the economy all "right" until we collectively decide what "right" even is.
- Gustomaximus 8y ago'Median GDP' is a good version of GDP to give a somewhat balanced view of a typical citizens share of the pie. Also, we need to stop expecting a single number to track. Any metric will always be flawed or managed. People need financial literacy and critical thinking to see the picture from altitude or I suspect many will be easily manipulated via relevant powerbrokers touting message appropriate single statistics.
- crazygringo 8y agoA median would do a great job of not being affected much by the top 1% or even 10%... ...but at the same time could be virtually unaffected by bringing the bottom 5% completely out of the worst poverty, which some people argue is the top priority, so I'd be worried about adopting this. I think we do need a single number though. As soon as you have multiple metrics, nobody knows how to balance them anymore. And it's infinitely easier and more realistic to ask our 'intelligentsia' to develop a more easily digestible metric, than to somehow turn all citizens into financially literate critical thinkers. Most people are too busy earning their salary to support and raise their families, to be able to spend the significant time investment required for that kind of critical financial thinking. It's too much of a burden to ask.
- freeflight 8y ago> and likewise unemployment is a percentage you can't argue with (and easy to argue that less = better, again even if not always true). Actually one can. Increase in productivity often comes from an increase in efficiency. More efficiency means you have spare resources, as you can now do the same work with less effort. What we do with these spare resources, that's a matter that isn't even discussed, they are pretty much always fully invested in furthering "economic growth" as in GDP, by investing all that spare time we now have, thanks to increased efficiency, into being even more productive for even longer periods. But how sustainable is all of this? Can Earth sustain a population of 10+ billion humans, the majority of them working full time and for longer times, using up resources at a rapidly increasing rate? It's a problem of thinking too short term on a global scale, everybody acts like this is some kind of race. But I don't think anybody will like what the finishing line will look like, there won't be prices there for anybody, there will be pretty much nothing.
- goatlover 8y ago> Can Earth sustain a population of 10+ billion humans, the majority of them working full time and for longer times, using up resources at a rapidly increasing rate? The alternative view is that all this activity generates innovation and problem solving, which increases th carrying capacity of the planet.
- freeflight 8y agoBut that whole view is still based on perpetual growth ideas, which imho are quite risky. They have their place to drive expansion, and as you say innovation, but I fear we are giving it too much weight. It's a bit like the "super long-term view", we just assume that we will be constantly able to expand and grow. What lacks in this perspective are the resource restrictions of physical reality. By insisting on constant growth, with barely any considerations for sustainability, it's very likely that at some point in the future we will end up in a resource dead end with no escape. Case in point: Many of us realize Earth only has finite resources, the common counter-argument to that is that we need to innovate and expand into space, to get at these resources. By just assuming "We will get there anyway, so let's keep using up Earth resources at increasing rates" we are acting rather irresponsibly because there are no guarantees we will be able to be a sustainable space-faring species.
- ArchTypical 8y ago> GDP is a sum you can't argue with That's tone deaf. The manipulation to change how it's calculated (always upward!), means it's a sum without meaning in every major world power.
- nicoburns 8y agoDoes it need to be ideologically neutral? The current numbers aren't ideologically neutral either...