3 ms·
It's fine for doctors to intuit that "the cost and side effects of HipNewDrug outweight the benefits". It's not fine for a doctor to be unaware that HeretoforeU
by SilasX 8y ago
It's fine for doctors to intuit that "the cost and side effects of HipNewDrug outweight the benefits". It's not fine for a doctor to be unaware that HeretoforeUncurableCondition now has HipNewDrug as a possible treatment -- i.e. to not have unlearned that HUC is a death sentence.
- emodendroket 8y agoThat's not really what the article is about. It's actually about someone finding HipNewDrug is actually not effective at curing Frobulitis and in fact has adverse side effects, and yet doctors continuing to prescribe it for that condition.
- SilasX 8y agoIt's the same failure mode though.
- emodendroket 8y agoIt's not the same. It's a bigger problem than the one you're talking about, according to the article. It's easier to get doctors to adapt some procedure than to get them to give one up.
- SilasX 8y agoBoth are the same failure mode: "You used to always do X. You shouldn't do that anymore." In my example, X was "tell patient they have a death sentence". The fact that yours is closer to a specific situation in the article does not make it "a different failure mode" with different dynamics and causes.
- emodendroket 8y agoI don't know what to tell you. You are saying the opposite of what the article says and not offering me any reason to take your word over the article.
- SilasX 8y agoNo, I'm not. I said that "thinking Y is uncurable" is the same kind of failure mode as "prescribing X for Z after the science starts to indicate that X is harmful". I then offered a very good reason to "take my word" on it: I stated the general form of the failure mode, parameterized over X, and showed what X would be in each case. Did you miss that, or did you not consider it a good reason? If you can take a moment to review the thread, I only brought it up to distinguish valid vs invalid reasons for not proposing a kind of treatment, and thus why a doctor's intuition would vs wouldn't be defensible given the state of the literature. Where specifically is the article saying the opposite of any of that? Unless the article talks about the topic of appropriately classifying failure modes, which it isn't, it wouldn't bear on that topic.
- emodendroket 8y agoThe article identifies a discrepancy where it is much easier to get doctors to introduce a new treatment or practice than it is to get them to stop using or recommending it after it is discredited. I don't see how that could be the case if they're "the same failure mode."
- SilasX 8y agoPeople can fail to realize two failure modes are the same and merit the same treatment. And I don’t see what that would bear on my original point (which was just distinguishing between valid vs invalid reasons not to recommend a treatment).
- emodendroket 8y agoPeople can equally well fail to realize that two modes of failure are different.