4 ms·
I hope this isn't an obvious question: Why aren't there safeties in the system to control these kinds of problems? For example, I have a giant gas meter outsid
by gwbas1c 8y ago
I hope this isn't an obvious question: Why aren't there safeties in the system to control these kinds of problems?
For example, I have a giant gas meter outside my home. How come it can't turn the gas off when the line is over pressure? Massachusetts state law requires that the gas company change it every few years. (I'm a MA resident)
My breaker box will turn off if there is a fault.
- tonyarkles 8y agoCouple of thoughts about gas and electricity and the similarities and differences: - an overpressure situation is specifically trying to blow through whatever "off" means (e.g. a ball valve or whatever the valves are). If the pressure rises too much, that valve is going to fail. That's true of circuit breakers too, but the "overvoltage fault voltage" of a circuit breaker is likely going to be way way way higher than anything you could reasonably expect from the grid, although lightning could probably flash over it. - Your breaker box will turn off during certain forms of fault, but not all. A line overvoltage probably wouldn't trip a breaker until the line voltage gets high enough to cause a fault in some piece of equipment connected downstream of the breaker (e.g. it blows up a switching power supply in your house and that fault current trips the breaker) - In the gas overpressure case, if all of the houses had gas meters that automatically turned off... the pressure in the community gas line would rise higher and higher. This is going to sound a bit cold, but it's likely better to have some houses blow up due to overpressure than to have a gas main explode after all of the houses have already shut off the gas. Bad situation all around :(. While acknowledging that I'm not a Mech E, my guess would be that the best solution would be to have periodically-placed blow-off valves on the gas main that could flare the gas if there were an overpressure situation. You don't really want to just release it, because then you've got a cloud of gas floating around that could get ignited by... whatever random ignition source.
- maxsilver 8y agoThis is probably a stupid idea, (I know absolutely nothing about natural gas) but why can't we emergency vent the gas outside? My gas meter is already outside the house, more than 30 feet away from anything flammable. In an emergency overpressure like this, shouldn't I be able to pull some sort of emergency lever to vent the gas outside. Yeah, that gas is flammable, which is risky. But that has to be less risky than just sitting around waiting for my house to blow up, which seems to be my only option today.
- tonyarkles 8y agoIf your gas installation is anything like mine, you could go outside and shut off the feed into your house. There's a valve that you could turn with a crescent wrench. Mine, at least, has a hole in it that the gas company can put a lock through when the valve is shut (which is what they do when they cut off your gas service). That way you're at least not going to have the inside of your house fill with gas. The trick with an overpressure gas main is that pulling that lever isn't going to be a "gas vents off for a few seconds and then things are good again" event. You won't be just reducing the pressure for your house, you'll be reducing the pressure for your entire neighbourhood, and there's going to be a pretty significant amount of gas that needs to vent. Also, I'm not sure if this is the case with methane, but propane has a really fun property... Going from compressed/liquified propane to gas propane has a high enough latent heat of vaporization that it can cool the surrounding liquid enough to freeze it (!!!). There was a court case around here a few years ago with a propane truck that blew a valve and started venting propane to the atmosphere. The liquid->gas transition cooled off the valve so much that a solid propane plug formed and stopped the leak (-188 degC!). Temporarily, of course... the plug eventually thawed, the gas continued escaping, and things got bad again. Having devices that could experience similar behaviour installed at peoples' homes seems pretty dangerous to me. It's all a shitty situation. Really, this is on the gas company. Their pumps should have never gotten the lines pressurized like this, and they should have had mechanisms in place to vent it in a controlled and safe fashion.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoOr ya know put the gas meters outside so they don't vent into a confined space when the regulator seal fails
- jlv2 8y agoThe gas meters are outside. (MA resident here)
- kalleboo 8y ago> My breaker box will turn off if there is a fault. If this was infallible there wouldn't be a market for surge protectors
- jacquesm 8y agoThere are lots of such safeties in the system, it's just that unlike electricity an 'open' connection in a gas line is called a leak... So the problem is much harder, and there is no safe configuration where you can force a valve to shut down in a passive way if the other side is not playing nice. Above a certain pressure anything will go and to design for even higher pressures would be cost prohibitive. So burst plates and other non-resettable safety devices are deployed in strategic locations, and their default mode is to vent. What exactly went wrong here is still unknown but the smart money is on an uncontained overpressure and a failure of one or more safeties. All it takes i the right set of circumstances. For instance: a very short pulse of very high pressure followed by a lower pressure not high enough to cause venting to occur. That would do nicely: every membrane in the line that was at or near the end of their service life would break causing high pressure to end up on the low pressure side but it would not cause the main safeties to trip. Keep in mind that all this stuff is passive, mostly mechanical and in many cases decades old. Something similar can happen to circuit breakers: there is an effect that causes the breaker to weld itself into position rather than to break the circuit, and there are plenty of examples of the breakers themselves catching fire due to high resistance between the breaker contacts. Then there is lightning, which can zap your house to the point that your electronics gear is nicely plated on the inside of empty casings and the breakers are all still sitting there as if everything is fine. It is super hard to create a safety system that will always work under every circumstance, especially if you want to do this maintenance free. More so, if you did not design it maintenance free but someone decided to skip on the maintenance.