3 ms·
I am not aware of having any form of vestibular disorder, and it has generally taken fairly deliberate effort to cause any discomfort when looking at a screen—A
by chrismorgan 8y ago
I am not aware of having any form of vestibular disorder, and it has generally taken fairly deliberate effort to cause any discomfort when looking at a screen—A Slower Speed of Light was able to make me feel mild discomfort after ten minutes, which I understand to be not uncommon, but it’s almost alone in that.
But this site is awful. I was feeling fine before, but within half a minute I was feeling mild pain in the back of my eyes and the beginnings of stomach churning. The animation was choppy and severely disorienting. Scrolling switching pages is not normal and is always, uniformly a bad idea. So after only half a minute I closed it. (That is, half a minute after the it finished loading—before that, there was a loading screen for perhaps fifteen or twenty seconds, which is never a good sign. In the normal way of things, I’d probably have closed it before it ever finished loading, but I had been expecting some sort of article on combining WebGL and GSAP, rather than a demonstration that would make me feel sick.)
My stomach is not feeling any better a few minutes later. I shall now go and have a drink and a walk around.
Just because you can do something, does not mean you should. As implemented, this is terrible.
- iamaelephant 8y agoSo just because you personally have trouble with something, no one should ever use it?
- chrismorgan 8y agoI will not be unique in this. Many people will be negatively affected by it, some far, far worse than me. (For some history on far more subtle things than this causing problems for some people, look into what happened in iOS 7 (I think it was that version) in what led to the “prefers reduced motion” setting.) Quite apart from the how it will made some people feel sick, there is simply too much that is different about the site, so that a great many people, when they encounter it, will get lost very quickly. It’s not as bad as mystery meat navigation, but its navigation scheme is very dubious, because it lacks the “tells” of normal web browsing. It’s an interesting technical demonstration, but not a good website for normal people to use. For a film-maker it may or may not backfire, but I’ve seen a couple of sites of developers, designers and such agencies, that looked and behaved vaguely like this from a navigation perspective, and the main thing that I take out of such sites is that the the creator of the site didn’t care about accessibility. And I don’t mean making the site usable for disabled people, I mean making the site usable for anyone. I would never hire any such person or organisation for any web development work. (I failed to notice this the first time, but this site is also enormous. I killed it off as it hit 75MB, and I think it was still loading more video. I will freely and precisely describe such a page size as absurd and insane. I would not have loaded the site even once had I realised what and how large it would be.)
- girvo 8y agoWhereas it was 60FPS, perfectly smooth and quick loading on my iPhone SE. Weird.
- weego 8y agoWhy did you keep looking at it then? If you can't manage yourself why should anyone pander to you?
- panic 8y agoThe main scrolling didn’t bother me, but scrolling inside the “hamburger menu” made me feel sick almost immediately. I think it was a combination of the scrolling and the motion of the video I was mousing over. Be careful with this stuff folks!