19 ms·
It depends on whether you want to stay grounded in real-world physics, or if you want to spin off on flights of fancy. If you want to stay in real-world physic
by jerf 8y ago
It depends on whether you want to stay grounded in real-world physics, or if you want to spin off on flights of fancy.
If you want to stay in real-world physics, at the moment there is no reason to expect any civilization to use anything other than electromagnetic radiation for communication. Other than the low speed of light, which is a characteristic of the universe that it does not seem to allow any faster-than-light communication so it's not specially a disadvantage for EM, electromagnetic radiation basically has every characteristic you're looking for in a communications medium, and there's little reason to believe even an advanced civilization would use something orders of magnitude worse on numerous dimensions simply because maybe they can. This is for much the same reason that we could transport everything in our civilization by people carrying things around on Segways, but we don't, because why would we deliberately choose something suboptimal?
If you want to go off on flights of fancy, then anything is possible, but there's no way to say anything useful about it.
The "grounded in reality" answer is subject to change as our understanding of physics improves, but at the moment I wouldn't say there's any particular reason to expect this answer to change much. Even on the crazy fringe frontiers of real science, I am not aware of any candidates for communication any better than EM.
Most of the whacky ideas proposed as alternate methods fail by orders of magnitude vs EM. Might you be able to build a better neutrino detector than we can? Maybe, but it's still easier to build EM detectors, and EM emitters, by a lot. Gravity waves? Why on not-Earth would anyone spend the massive, massive amounts of energy required to do that, very klunkily and with very low bandwidth, when for literally a trillionth of a trillionth of a trillionth of a trillionth the energy expenditure you could use EM, and get higher bandwidth to boot and better reusability to boot? Quantum entanglement and teleportion are non-starters, because they both require a conventional channel to work at all, and the best tool for that communication is EM.
- SilasX 8y agoI think the parent meant -- or a least a steelman of the point would be -- whether there could be some kind of particle/field/force/form-of-energy we're missing out on that could be used to communicate (even if slower than light), and whether there's some way to rule that out. I don't think that's dismissable as being a flight of fancy any more than the existence of radio waves would have been in 1500.
- 21 8y agoWell, we already know that we don't know what dark matter is. Something might be hiding in there which is useful for communication.
- jerf 8y agoWe do not know what dark matter is, but we do know several things it is not. Among the things that it can not be is terribly strongly interacting with itself. We know this because dark matter appears to surround galaxies with spherical halos, rather than in discs. If it did strongly or even moderately self-interact, it would also be in the disc, because that's precisely why normal matter galaxies are in a disc. So this excludes, for instance, the idea that there are dark matter civilizations using dark matter machines to send some sort of dark communication that we can't see. It is not quite impossible to eliminate the possibility that there is some sort of dark radiation we could eventually create and detect. There's currently no particular reason to believe such a thing is possible, but it is not currently excluded necessarily. Whatever forces dark matter interacts with could have its own radiation. But it is difficult to imagine in what way this would be superior to EM-based communication, because, again, EM is just so perfect for communication that it's hard to beat. It's the question people don't want to deal with because they're too busy being "gee whiz golly gosh" about the possibilities... in what way is this other communication method going to be better than EM? Dark matter communication would quite likely look in practice a lot like neutrino communication does today. It's already possible. We know that because we've built it. We don't call it a transmission method, though, because the bandwidth is soooo atrocious that it's reasonably approximated by "0 bits per second", so we just call it a "detector".
- 21 8y agoWe know one way in which it would be superior - very low interaction rates which ordinary matter which would mean much longer propagation ranges. And their difficultly is a bonus in itself - if you want to hide your communications as much as possible. Cost is not always the only metric to optimize. Even today, people try to use quantum entanglement to create communication channels where snooping is detectable.
- 21 8y agoEven with EM, they could have a highly advanced encoding format which is barely detectable about the random noise floor (spread spectrum like). US army uses these kind of techniques to make the signal both hard to detect and hard to jam. Who knows how far you can push this, maybe to the point where it's essentially impossible to detect the signal if you are not the intended target.
- wongarsu 8y agoMost signals would presumably also be highly targeted. The narrower the beam you are sending, the less energy is required to send the information. Unless aliens cheap out on antennas or prefer to waste lots of energy on broadcasting in all directions, we are very unlikely to be in the path of their communication beams.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoI thought we could Van Eck phreak the aliens.
- joering2 8y agoWouldnt heavily advanced civilization wanted to remain silent? If they know they are less sophisticated aliens out there like us humans, then for sure there are civilizations more advance than they are. I suspect they are not interested of sending their own signal to someone who could anihilate them with a push of a button (even higher civ.)
- dbingham 8y agoWait, why is Quantum Entanglement a non-starter? How does that require a conventional channel? Once you have the two entangled, assuming you have some way to change the state of one with out breaking the entanglement, then how is that not enough for communication?
- metalliqaz 8y agoBecause once the particles are entangled, one has to be moved by conventional means to the destination while the other stays behind.
- dbingham 8y agoSure, but you could still create a two way walkie talkie that couldn't be eavesdropped on and would allow faster than light communication this way, theoretically.
- simcop2387 8y agoYou can make it secure from mitm with this but it doesn't allow ftl. You can't use the entangled particles themselves to do the communication since you cant control how the superposition collapses when you measure it. This allows you to get two streams that nobody but you and the party knows but they're fundamentally random and unpredictable, you can't encoded information into it, just use it as a one time pad essentially.
- bduerst 8y agoBut that in itself is a signal, right? Say you have two sets of two entangled particles, all four particles in similar states. You have one particle from each set, your partner has the corresponding particles in the sets. You check both particles you have, and: - if both particles have similar state, then your partner hasn't checked any of their particle states, because neither have collapsed. - if one particle has collapsed and is in a different state than the other particle, then you know your partner has at least checked the state of one of particle sets, possibly both. If you partner is 50 light years away and checks it only seconds prior to your check, then they are signalling you at faster-than-light travel, right?
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> electromagnetic radiation basically has every characteristic you're looking for in a communications medium Communication by electromagnetic radiation suffers from the fact that the radiation diffuses indiscriminately in all directions. Consider two models of "communication" -- in model 1, messages are sent by lighting a lantern and waiting for the other party to see it, and in model 2, messages are sent by propelling a less wave-like rock into the other party. Model 1 is faster. But in model 2, my messages don't get broadcast to the entire world as I send them, all the energy I put into sending the message goes into delivering it (whereas most of the energy given off by the lantern is wasted), and if I start throwing rocks at my friend, that will not in general interfere with the rocks thrown between you and your friend.
- jerf 8y ago"Communication by electromagnetic radiation suffers from the fact that the radiation diffuses indiscriminately in all directions." While lasers technically do not need to be beam-like, I would point out that beam lasers do exist, as well as many other directional effects, as seen in flashlights and such. It is a bizarre alien race that people are hypothesizing that apparently uses whatzamamagic communication that we currently can't even conceive of, but aren't capable of building the things we already know how to build that can provide very good directionality today. A very particular sort of powerful.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoBeam lasers exist and stay narrow on the scale that we use them. They are tighter flashlights. Turn on any flashlight and the rapid diffusion of its light will be extremely apparent. And I'll note that I responded to the comment "electromagnetic radiation basically has every characteristic you're looking for in a communications medium", with no mention of aliens at all. It is not true that electromagnetic radiation basically has every characteristic you're looking for in a communications medium.
- saagarjha 8y agoThere is a fundamental difference between a laser and a concentrated flashlight–lasers are coherent while ordinary light is not and cannot be made so no matter how much you focus it.
- Mithorium 8y agoI don't know if I'd describe the speed of light as "low", more like the universe is really, really big
- OtterCoder 8y agoYou don't sound like you do a lot of distributed/network programming. The speed of light is achingly, infuriatingly slow.
- terryf 8y agoThings would be a lot simpler if it were faster though :) Consider a modern cpu running at 3ghz. It can retire some instructions on every cycle. Light can travel one mm in that time. That means the part of the core that decodes the incoming stream of insns is effectively outside the lightcone of the part that retires instructions.
- mjw1007 8y agoI make it 100mm, not 1mm.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- earenndil 8y agoThen the speed of light is still not slow, cpus are just really fast. Point being, everything is relative, and lightspeed isn't necessarily the limiting factor.
- pizza 8y agoc * (3 ghz)^-1 ~= 10 cm
- abdullahkhalids 8y agoA related point is that we can't just make a single CPU do more computations per unit time by making the CPU bigger because the finite speed of electricity (which is upper bounded by the speed of light), determines the largest size of the CPU before the different paths that electricity takes through the CPU logic gates become out of sync.
- CodeSheikh 8y agoOr perhaps we are a only advanced civilization in the known universe and other civilizations are using some lo-tech method of communication like creating sounds or fire signals. Add we are looking for only high-tech modes of communications.
- Filligree 8y agoThanks, I am now imagining interstellar smoke signals. I feel like that's pretty unlikely, though. :X
- function_seven 8y agoI'm assuming parent meant they're communicating across their own world using those forms, and we should be looking for timed puffs of smoke :)
- russfink 8y agoFantastic - but at what interval? Our lives may be measured in years, while another life form may measure itself in eons. How rapid must their oscillators be to download their own equivalent of Netflix? 1E-08 Hz? (Can we detect such slow oscillations? Is there a minimum timescale for consciousness?)
- function_seven 8y agoUsing an SDSSD¹ they wouldn't need to tune to any specific oscillation. Just collect the data and start Fourier-ing it to find the signal. 1: Software-Defined Smoke Signal Detector
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoHow about soliton pulses in a plasma? Isn't interstellar space mostly plasma? Its still EM radiation. Such pulses can survive incredible distances undiminished, and they are point-to-point (not broadcast). So other civilizations might be using this, and we'd never notice unless we got between them and their target by accident And of course it would be compressed or encrypted or both. So it would be indistinguishable from noise (as mentioned in other replies)
- ethagnawl 8y agoPerhaps, if it gets a sequel, this (or similar) will be revealed as the cause of the "event" in _Seveneves_?
- reaperducer 8y agoI put "soliton pulses in a plasma" in a search engine and everything that came back was well above my head. Does anyone have a link to something that explains this in plain language?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoIn a plasma (or certain nonlinear media) a wave will not diminish in size. Its why waves in shallow seas can go for hundreds of miles unchanged, why light pulses in fibre optic cables can cross the ocean bottom without diminishing to noise. These waves are called solitons. It was my EE Professor's (Lonngren) favorite research topic back in my undergraduate days
- koolba 8y ago> And of course it would be compressed or encrypted or both. So it would be indistinguishable from noise (as mentioned in other replies) The perennial optimist in me thinks that that all the work on cracking Tor is finally going to pay off when we can decipher alien's sending each other selfies.
- earenndil 8y agoNo reason to assume that they use the same encryption schemes we do.
- dhimes 8y agoTo me the most straightforward thing to think about is EM waves at frequencies we can only imagine. Very different sources and detectors from what we have, therefore the radiation is undetectable to us (also very line-of-sight), but still the same physics in terms of the properties-of-the-universe required. I would imagine this increase would be developed for the same reason we have gone from KHz to GHz in a hundred-odd years: The higher the frequency the more information you can transmit per second.
- saltcured 8y agoSo, you're thinking those cosmic rays are really symbols in an alien modulation scheme? Quasars are really light houses...?
- dhimes 8y agoHa ha yeah that would be scary-cool-- the cosmic charts showing black holes to avoid and such.
- saagarjha 8y agoThe issue with high frequency communication is the power needed to sustain it, since energy goes up as wavelength decreases.
- dhimes 8y agoI suspect that's not the biggest issue. Developing the tech to create a and detect a modulated wave at these frequencies is way bigger, IMHO. You might be using nuclei as detectors, for example. But in my imagination I can see this being solved.
- Procrastes 8y agoMaybe it looks something like this: https://www.technologyreview.com/s/611977/get-ready-for-atomic-radio/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/611977/get-ready-for-atom...
- colordrops 8y agoI think the idea is not whether we could speculate in a useful way about an FTL or otherwise seemingly impossible phenomenon that we are not yet aware of. It's more about the probability that phenomena and technologies that are far beyond our current understanding can exist or not. In all likelihood we would have the intelligence and technology of ants relative to a million year old civilization. We shouldn't limit what is possible in this universe to what ants are able to comprehend and achieve. Even without such an argument, we only need to look at what we thought was possible 500 or 1000 years ago, and extrapolate forward that in all likelihood our currently understood limitations of physics will all but be irrelevant in 1000 years. Agreed that it's a flight of fancy to speculate on these yet unknown capabilities, but that doesn't mean they aren't highly likely to exist.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI don't see it that way. 100 years ago we had a million questions about physics, and lots of fundamental values were a mystery. Today the fundamental values have all been measured to a high degree, and we have a few questions about physics and lots of them epistemological. If in 1M years we have a different view about the universe it won't be because we were wrong about physics today. It will be about something underlying or outside physics?
- hutzlibu 8y agoErm, seriously? Or do you only mean classical, newton physics? Because as far as I know, (quantum) physic is far from explained. Shure we do know a LOT more than we did 100 years ago, but I doubt we have fewer questions. I even suspect it can never be fully understood. Some basic principles, yes. But if the universe is infinitely big and small and it seems it is, there is no full understanding nor resolving all questions. I thought that mindset died out allready. Because before quantum mechanics etc. physicist actually did thought they allmost solved all questions. And then: oh. There might be more ...
- shkkmo 8y agoI thought the whole idea behind quantum physics is that the universe is NOT infinitely small and that the minimum size / amount is a quantum.
- stcredzero 8y agoThis is for much the same reason that we could transport everything in our civilization by people carrying things around on Segways, but we don't, because why would we deliberately choose something suboptimal? In some high profile military simulation exercises, the "Iran" side used motorcycle couriers to side-step the "US" advantage in signals intelligence. Perhaps other civilizations which manage to survive know something that prompts them to use highly directed, highly efficient spread spectrum technologies which are very hard for us to detect? Perhaps the universe is much more dangerous for intelligent beings than we know in our youthful naivete as a species?
- bredren 8y agoPerhaps other civilizations which manage to survive know something that prompts them to use highly directed, highly efficient spread spectrum technologies which are very hard for us to detect? Perhaps the universe is much more dangerous for intelligent beings than we know in our youthful naivete as a species? This is terrifying.
- robterrell 8y ago"The Three-Body Problem" (& its sequels) are a fantastic exploration of this terrifying idea.
- abecedarius 8y agoBesides emissions security, perhaps there's the equivalent of "never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of mag tapes" (with, say, a lattice of atoms of different types instead).
- webnrrd2k 8y agoI don't think it's really worth considering as a realistic reason for societies choosing suboptimal technologies, but maybe some sort of Skynet scenario is possible, or something more like Frank Herbert's Butlerian Jihad[1]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butlerian_Jihad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butlerian_Jihad
- darkmighty 8y ago> Even on the crazy fringe frontiers of real science, I am not aware of any candidates for communication any better than EM. There is one, and it is essentially > people carrying things around on Segways Electromagnetic radiation must obey the inverse square law. It spreads spherically through space, so required power for a given SNR raises with distance squared. Moreover, there are severe interference issues. Once you have several systems communicating on the same bands you get more noise in the relevant frequency bands. Unlike waves which don't self-interact (i.e. obey the superposition principle, are linear), matter is coherent. If you shoot a hard drive at a distance galaxy (with greater than escape velocity), it may take significant time to get there, but you can travel arbitrarily far for essentially the same energy, as a first approximation. Of course, as a second approximation there is necessity of guidance/control (because of finite motor precision, target uncertainty, etc), but also the possibility of harvesting energy or photon momentum from stars en route. Aside from the expansion of the universe there's no theoretical limit as to why a sufficiently advanced probe couldn't propagate information arbitrarily far (if it "refuels" periodically, then its total energy usage is proportional to distance, i.e. linear, but launch cost stays bounded). In the worst case (perhaps for cosmically large distances) it'd need to colonize a planet en route to rebuild a pristine copy of itself. "Never underestimate the bandwidth of a station wagon full of tapes hurtling down the highway." –Andrew Tanenbaum, 1981 https://what-if.xkcd.com/31/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/31/ "The only way to actually reach the FedEx point is if transfer rates grow much faster than storage rates. In an intuitive sense, this seems unlikely, since storage and transfer are fundamentally linked—all that data is coming from somewhere and going somewhere (...)" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakernet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakernet
- ajuc 8y agoEM doesn't have to spread spherically. There is such a thing as directional antennas, spotlights, or even lasers. Yes they spread too, but throwing a hard drive at distances on the scale of light years isn't going to be precise either. Go far enough and you won't hit the galaxy you wanted to.
- int_19h 8y ago
- bduerst 8y ago>which is a characteristic of the universe that it does not seem to allow any faster-than-light communication Great answer, but do you have more information on this? I thought quantum entanglement allowed for teleportation of information at faster-than-light speeds. Yes, there is the original information being parcelled and shipped at slower-than-light speeds, but the individual act of disentangling particles can act as a faster-than-light signal.
- stcredzero 8y agoGreat answer, but do you have more information on this? PBS SpaceTime. The Speed of Light is not about Light: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msVuCEs8Ydo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msVuCEs8Ydo
- lovemenot 8y agoInformation is defined in such a way as it may never travel FTL. When entangled particles reveal their states, they do not at that point in time transmit any new information. The information was actually encoded into the entangled pair which travelled at less than light speed to that destination. I imagine this answer is probably unsatisfying and counterintuitive to you, as it is to me.
- mrfusion 8y agoI think neutrinos would be viable with real world physics. They can go through anything which would be pretty useful and you can direct it easily. We don’t have an easy way to detect them but a more advanced civilization might.
- saagarjha 8y agoThat's the paradox, isn't it? You want something that doesn't interact with matter until to reaches the detector, where you want it to interact as much as possible.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> You want something that doesn't interact with matter until to reaches the detector, Axions [1]! [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axion
- scotty79 8y agoThat's not a paradox, it's just the property that good communication medium should have. EM waves have this property thanks to effect of resonance in the reciever. Neutrinos will have this property (but better) once we learn how to emit and detect them efficiently.
- ben_w 8y agoWanting two opposite properties simultaneously is paradoxical requirements. And no, resonance isn’t the reason for EM. Faraday cages are not resonant, and they block (certain frequencies of) EM. Neither are lenses, and they make directional detection of EM much easier. And, honestly, I’m not sure what the right word is for individual photons being absored by atoms or molecules. EM is a fundamental force. Everything interacts by fundamental forces, even neutrinos, but even though I think neutrino communication is cool and potentially useful in limited circumstances, it’s not reasonable to just assert that aliens will be chatting interstellar with them. EM is about the best you can get for interstellar because there’s nothing in the way to block it. Neutrinos are what you would use if there is a lot of stuff in the way — like, say, a planet or a star — and you benefit from the slightly lower lag time of going through it instead of bouncing around it, or you can’t go around it because thing you’re talking to is in the middle of it. Even if you posit that super advanced alien technology can make wormholes, the only way you’re going to get anything other than light going through them is if they turn out to be really small and it’s better to have a high energy electron (=small DeBroglie wavelength) beam going through them.
- cm2187 8y agoBut we didn't suspect EM radiations existed until we started understanding electricity, magnetic fields, etc. What else do we not suspect exists today but will be obvious in 50 years?
- flukus 8y agoWe knew light existed long before we understood electricity and magnetic fields, even those had observable effects to us long before we discovered them.
- sixstringbudha 8y agoThat is because we could "see" it. Imagine if we were not able to see. Could we have known the existence of EM? Or think if we were not able to hear. Could we have imagined the sensation of sound, or the concept of music? Human beings are so pathetically stupid that they think that their intelligence and sensory capability are at the limits of what is possible.
- flukus 8y ago>That is because we could "see" it. Imagine if we were not able to see. Could we have known the existence of EM? Probably, it has a number of physical effects, like heating up the areas that it hits, there is probably quite a lot we could have deduced about light with no eyesight, as long as we lived somewhere EM existed had a noticeable effect, which is just about everywhere. > Or think if we were not able to hear. Could we have imagined the sensation of sound, or the concept of music? Of course not, but that wouldn't prevent us from understanding the concept of pressure waves. > Human beings are so pathetically stupid that they think that their intelligence and sensory capability are at the limits of what is possible. What? We know our sensory understanding has sever limits, no one that graduated the third grade thinks our sensory capability are at the limit's of what's possible. Everyone that has ever seen an x-ray knows this. To quote Brother Cavil: I don't want to be human! I want to see gamma rays! I want to hear X-rays! And I want to - I want to smell dark matter! Do you see the absurdity of what I am? I can't even express these things properly because I have to - I have to conceptualize complex ideas in this stupid limiting spoken language! But I know I want to reach out with something other than these prehensile paws! And feel the wind of a supernova flowing over me!
- inks 8y agoThey could just high focus beams of extremely energetic photons or even gamma ray transmitters with encoding that’s basically “noise” because we grew and evolved around it. There was one theory for Tabby’s star that it was basically a transmission beacon and we happened to see the transmissions because we are in the line of sight.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- trumped 8y agoso the sun could not be a complex communication device? programmed by "someone" billions of years ago...
- graycat 8y agoHere's a faster than light issue I have: Take a really weak light source. Aim it at a beam splitter, say, at 45 degrees to the line of the light. Assume that the light source is so weak that typically we get a photon only one a second or so (not strictly necessary for the idea). Then each photon (there are standard claims that could also use an electron, proton, neutron, etc. but all photons travel at the speed of light, and using just light we don't have to worry about the electric charge of an electron or proton) has a quantum mechanical wave function. From the lessons we get from Young's double slit, the Michelson-Morley experiment, the Mach-Zehnder interferometer, the Fabre-Perot interferometer (right, my ugrad physics prof liked optics!), we believe at the beam splitter the wave function becomes two parts, one part continuing straight through the beam splitter and the other part going off at 90 degrees. Now sit and have a brewski or two; finish a physics Ph.D.; get married; have a lot of kids; get them all through college; and, I omitted, for the beam that went through the beam splitter, have it bouncing around in a box full of perfect mirrors or resting in some Bose-Einstein condensate, and then get out a very sensitive photo detector and try to detect the photon. Okay, for a perfect beam splitter, have a 50% chance of detecting the photon. Suppose we do, or, suppose we just in the beginning did this stuff for 1000 individual photons and pick one of the photons where we do get a detection from the part of the wave function close to us (the other half of the wave function is way past the nearest star by now). So, we get our detection. We know the energy we get, just proportional to the frequency of the light. So, our detector gets it all -- the wavelength, the frequency, the momentum, the energy, maybe the polarization. Fine. Now, folks, what the heck happens to the other half of the wave function, the half that went 90 degrees and by now is part way out of the galaxy? No sense in saying that half just disappeared. For one, ET way out there 50% of the time could detect the photon. For another, we could have a mirror out there and have that half of the wave function return to us and do a Young's double slit or Michelson-Morley experiment where both parts of the wave function definitely get involved. So, no saying that the half of the wave function nearly out of the galaxy doesn't matter. I know; I know; that half of the wave function gets old and tired, goes de-coherent, etc., but such stuff raises other little issues such as conservation of energy. So let's assume that, even after all these years, both parts of the wave function are still nice and healthy just like they would have been in Young's double slit, the Michelson-Morley experiment, etc. Besides we believe we can detect photons 13.8 or so billion years old, and, really, some of those may have their wave functions, from being deflected here and there for all those years, in multiple parts. But we know also that we and ET can't both detect the photon. So, that part of the wave function out there with ET can't just do its own thing -- with us and ET, there will be exactly one detection. Okay, when we get the detection, supposedly the other half of the wave function, some light years out there where ET is, disappears, folds up, evaporates, leaves town, becomes null and void, instantly, just as soon as we make our detection. So, sorry guys, that looks like an instantaneous effect (I didn't say communications) over a distance of light years. So, the naughty boy in his room running the simulation for our universe, as soon as we detect the photon, has to run around all over the whole darned universe and clean up any stray pieces of the wave function of the original photon, and there may be thousands of those. During this clean up, the whole simulation (think of a data base problem!) has to stop. So, the simulation has to run all over the universe or a lot of it in zero time -- that's an effect infinitely fast! I know; I know; this is not faster than light travel for us, but it looks like faster than light travel for the naughty boy's universe simulation program. Now from this, what can we say about how the quantum fields we believe in actually have to work? Is there something? E.g., suppose both we and ET have really sensitive gravitational wave detectors and, thus, can detect each of the two pieces of the wave function as they pass by. Uh, the photon has to feel gravity and also create gravity, and, thus, BOTH parts of the wave function have to create gravity. So that part of the wave function that ET gets MUST create a gravitational wave as it passes by and MUST create a gravitational wave as it disappears instantly as we detect the photon. We're getting close to faster than speed of light something or other ...! Okay, suppose ET is 10 light years away and we want to spend the next 10 years setting up an instantly fast communications channel. We agree to send one bit a second. We use the beam splitter, ..., etc. as above. If we are using our elecgtro-magnetic detector, the for each photon we have not detected, ET gets both a gravitational wave detection and a photon (electro-magnetic) detection. For each photon we do detect, ET gets neither the gravitational nor the electro-magnetic detection. If we put our detector in the path of our half of the wave function, then we get a detection half the time which means that half the time ET gets neither a gravitational nor an electro-magnetic detection. If we do not have our detector in front of our half of the photon, then ET always gets the gravitational signal and half the time gets the electro-magnetic signal. So, suppose each second (since when we started spending 10 years setting up the communications channel) we sent 1000 photons a second. Now for one of those seconds, if we are using our electro-magnetic photon detector, ET gets about 500 gravitational wave detections and 500 electro-magnetic detections. If we are not using our photon detector, then ET gets 1000 gravitational wave detections and 500 electro-magnetic detections. So, once we have spent 10 years setting up the communications channel, we can communicate at data rate of 1 bit a second with ET instantly. I don't really believe it, but first cut it looks that way! Now each second, we either put our detector in the path of our half of the wave function or we don't.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> flights of fancy It seems presumptuous to dismiss the entirety of non-Standard Model physics thusly. Axions [1] are one of my personal favourites. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axion
- adrianratnapala 8y agoI agree with your praise of EM. But hypothetical aliens might want to explore some trade-offs. The game we are playing is to find some advantage in the known physics of a medium even if we know of no practical way to create and detect those signals. Neutrinos spring to mind: we can't work with them because they don't interact with matter. But if you had some technology that could interact with them, you would have the advantage that nothing in the natural world screens them much. Even if that technology was much more cumbersome than radio, aliens might have special cases uses for it (e.g. for signalling to and from their secret base at the centre of the Earth).
- sterlind 8y agoNeŭtrino detectors are coming along nicely! For example, see this paper on the compact COHERENT detector, which is theoretically portable! https://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.01294 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1708.01294 It can only detect neutrinos <50 MeV but still, wow. Production, modulation and beam forming (and then demodulation and background removal) is a significant challenge, but neutrinos have many advantages for signaling for a galactic civilization, such as not needing to worry about occlusion.
- some_account 8y agoStaying grounded in current physics is not a good idea. Humans are primitive and other civilizations capable of traveling the solar system is not. Its like if you would ask a human 500 years ago how he think aliens would travel. He would say something likely in that age according to his understanding. We are exactly the same.
- scotty79 8y ago> Maybe, but it's still easier to build EM detectors, and EM emitters, by a lot. It's easier to build paperclip factories than iphone factories but we are awash in both and some people own more iphones than paperclips. Why on earth would you build EM emmiter if by bit more effort you could have device for unobstructible communication?
- dmead 8y agoThis is a very panglossian statement. You just recited a version of the "Best of all worlds" fallacy.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y ago>If you want to go off on flights of fancy, then anything is possible, but there's no way to say anything useful about it. I would guess, though I could be completely wrong, that a civilization that both had access to far more advanced 'sci-fi' level technology and wanted to broadcast it's existence would also have an understanding of the technology other civilizations would have access to and would choose to broadcast using numerous 'ancient' technologies that more privatize civilizations could pick up on. When we sent probes out into space to broadcast ourselves, we realized we couldn't just write a message in English and as such tried to send numerous different ways of conveying information, some linguistic and some not.
- nikofeyn 8y agoi feel this is too hyperbolic in the wrong direction. there is clearly more beyond our current knowledge of physics, so why is it beyond the realms of reality to assume that something in that subset of all knowledge is useful? we didn't even know of the possibility of gravitational waves a century ago and just confirmed their existence. so why is it reasonable to say they couldn't possibly be useful for communications? in dealing with the eventuality of alien civilizations, we must open our mind. it is certainly probable they communicate in ways we can't understand, even if they are simply evolutions of our current communication methods.