5 ms·
LA gets vilified for being sprawling and car-centric, as if its love of cars is why it sprawls. This is not true. It sprawled from the beginning before cars wer
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
LA gets vilified for being sprawling and car-centric, as if its love of cars is why it sprawls. This is not true. It sprawled from the beginning before cars were the norm. It is rooted in the high cost of building infrastructure in a desert and how that necessitates building large tracts in one fell swoop to make the financing make sense.
- piyh 8y agoHow is building in a desert more difficult than building on a plain? Water is a municipal problem, not the builder's.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoMuch of the water for LA comes from the Colorado River. You have to build substantial infrastructure to pipe it in. Building a large swathe of stuff helps defray the cost of this essential infrastructure, without which you can't survive. Once you put in the pipes to get it there, you better build out enough homes and businesses to at least break even on that part of it or you are doomed.
- tomnipotent 8y agoSure, when you're building in 2018 with all the luxuries the modern world has to offer. Not so a hundred years ago.
- the_gastropod 8y agoThis is technically true, but kind of a stretch. The population of LA in 1900 was only ~100k people. By 1920, there were over 500k. And it continued to explode in growth through the '70s. The "sprawl" was less sprawly than it was a collection of multiple cities that have been annexed over the decades. In the 1890's, LA was 28 square miles (and that 28 "original" LA is still very evident today). Today, it's 469 square miles. LA's current sprawl is absolutely because of the car. There's a very clear reason old east coast cities and european cities look so much different than newer cities like LA.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI have read a history of the origin of LA. It didn't agree with you. LA sprawled from the start. This likely made it well suited to developing their cult of the car, not the other way around.
- wwweston 8y agoWhich history? I'd love to know more. I've got stories of relatives living anywhere from Hermosa Beach to Huntington Park pre-depression, so I'm inclined to believe LA certainly spread out early on, but I'd guess most of the density was along the coast and rail.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't recall. I believe it was part of a book with short excerpts from many famous urban planning books. I was (or had been) bedridden. I had been to San Francisco for the first time and fallen madly in love with the city and I spent $300 at the bookstore on the way home on urban planning books and other books that I felt made sense for my mad, mad scheme to get well and someday be an urban planner. (And also to keep me occupied while I recuperated.) I'm terrible with titles anyway and this was a particularly bad time in my life. Sorry.
- trgn 8y agoNot sure why this get downvotes. American cities were overbuilt from the start. In most american cities, from the late 1700s onward, wide roads on a grid were a desirable feature, a hundred years before cars were a thing. These wide roads were originally a buffer space for all the smoke and filth of the industrial city. As a weird unintended consequence, the car could become commonplace so early because american cities already had the roads to accommodate them. And now with cars, these roads became dangerous and noisy as well. When industry left the city proper, early 20th century, the cars remained and continued to make the city an unpleasant place to live in. No wonder people decided to move out, first using streetcars or trains, and then yes, with their cars, which paradoxically contributed to why the city was awful in the first place. LA, even though younger than most american cities, follows a similar template.
- cimmanom 8y agoBuilding vertically instead of horizontally would make the infrastucture even more cost-efficient.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoTrue, but 100+ years ago, there were practical engineering limitations on building vertically. I don't remember the details of the history I read. It was a long time ago. I just remember that it made the point that LA sprawled from the beginning and this had to do with what made financial sense at the time. What we can do today is different from what was feasible back then.
- cimmanom 8y ago100 years ago, NYC already had 20-story buildings. Cities built longer ago tend to sprawl LESS because most people got around most of the time on foot. Most of LA (by square mileage) was built up since the 1950s (later than the Empire State Building). There’s no reason except political will that it couldn’t have been built in clusters of 2-4 story multi-family units within walking distance of transit.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou say that like political will is merely a matter of wanting it bad enough. I don't think that's true. As a college student, I wrote an alternate commuter rail plan for Solano County around 15 years ago. It was based on GIS and research and lacked the politicking that strongly influenced the existing rail plan. I was told gas would need to be $4/gallon before the stations would be built. I was sick and going through a divorce and had been a homemaker for 2 decades. I have no political connections and no political know how. Some months ago, I tried briefly to figure out how to promote that plan. It basically went nowhere. The first rail station had its grand opening in April. I believe this increases the odds that Travis AFB will finally leave California like the federal government has threatened for years. The worst of the three stations has yet to be built. I updated the website yesterday and stuck a link in my HN profile. That's probably as far as it will go. I'm no longer in California. I'm still struggling to solve my own problems. The rail plan research I did is dead in the water. I wish I had the know how. I wish I had the right connections. I wish people took me more seriously than they do. I wish I had to be time and energy to pour into figuring this out. I don't. I have to get on with my life and none of that fits into my schedule. I've tried. It went nowhere. Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by entropy.