4 ms·
I don’t agree with Bezos on a few things, but this is big. It’s about time companies care for their down and out compatriots. Progressives make all kinds of n
by mc32 8y ago
I don’t agree with Bezos on a few things, but this is big. It’s about time companies care for their down and out compatriots.
Progressives make all kinds of noise and virtue signal for people outside our care, but where the rubber meets the road, they fall short on helping fellow Americans—this is a nice start. Let’s see where it goes.
Wonder if he’ll get Bernie to contribute (tongue in cheek)
- noobermin 8y agoThe best way for companies to care for their down and out compatriots is to pay their workers their due instead of profiting handsomely from underpaying them.
- lolsal 8y agoAre we in disagreement that this is better than nothing, though?
- gamegoblin 8y agoThis is something I have legitimately wondered for a while now, and maybe someone on here with an economics background has some links to share: Which is more economically efficient: 1. Pay workers above-market wages 2. Pay workers market wages, but use taxes and some sort of welfare to bring the workers effective income up to where it would be had you paid them above-market wages. Presumably the taxes used to fund Option 2 would be something like a wealth tax (including corporate wealth). My non-economist intuition is that Option 1 could have weird effects on the economy due to paying non-market-based wages.
- cryoshon 8y agothe problem is that the "market wages" generate both humanitarian disasters of poverty and also demand gaps wherein people can't afford to buy goods, which puts a drag on the economy. #2 is an issue because government transfers nearly always have terms attached. people get food stamps for food, housing assistance for housing, etc. so demand gaps can still occur because people still don't have the "right" kind of money. plus, it's less efficient because the government has to be involved. i'm in favor of a wealth tax, however. implementation issues aside, it's the most realistic chance we have of making businesses pay up.
- geofft 8y ago> Progressives make all kinds of noise and virtue signal for people outside our care, but where the rubber meets the road, they fall short on helping fellow Americans Can you expand on this?
- mc32 8y agoWe have homeless, we have veterans, we have addicts, we have people with mental health issues and we have illegal immigrants. The latter gets much more vocal support from progressives over fellow americans. We can have an influence on how we treat compatriots. So while some progressives want to subsidize services out of our tax dollars for people who have not contributed to our society, they don’t fight for fellow Americans in need with the same vigor, nor do they even denounce the policies or governments in those countries which contribute to those counties’ economic malaise —quite the opposite, some admire Chavista and Catroist policies.
- barneygumble742 8y agoI have never seen or heard of progressives voting down on programs meant to help the homeless, veterans, addicts, people with mental health issues, or illegal immigrants. I do see progressives being more vocal about illegal immigrants because that is the only group that is vilified by the current administration. Illegal immigrants do contribute to society by being nanny's, cleaning houses, working at farms, and paying sales tax.
- wycy 8y agoDisagree. Progressives very actively campaign on helping all of those groups of people. It's the centrist democrats who are focusing solely on illegal immigrants--to the neglect of the others--because it's a corporate-friendly issue.
- tptacek 8y agoThe right way to respond to inflammatory political comments is to flag them, not to feed them oxygen.
- pessimizer 8y ago
- jethro_tell 8y ago> It’s about time companies care for their down and out compatriots. A nit, but this is still a little like dominoes fixing pot holes in the city so their drivers can actually deliver. Sure it's great, but it would be better to pay a more fair share of taxes and provide a safety net for our people and the money needed to maintain common infrastructure. I don't doubt this will be a more efficient endeavor than a government one, but it's also not really accountable to anyone. And bezos can actually just hire two PR people and shut the rest of it down. He has no obligation to homeless people, and no obligation to see this to the end. I'm sure he will, but it's pretty fucked to think that companies will be less self interested in their charity than in their business, or a government. The idea that we should just make a few mega rich then depend on their kindness to address societies woes is really toxic.
- philipps 8y agoAgree with almost everything you wrote. But given the track record of big philanthropy I doubt very much that this will be more efficient than government efforts.
- jethro_tell 8y agoWould you take government efforts with political sandbagging as a substitute?
- dvdhnt 8y ago> Progressives make all kinds of noise and virtue signal for people outside our care, but where the rubber meets the road, they fall short on helping fellow Americans—this is a nice start. That's pretty presumptuous of you, isn't it? For one, it ignores that the system and actions that give Bezos the ability to do this, i.e. accumulation of wealth, are a contributor to problem itself. Second, he'll use this as both a distraction and tax write-off. Third, rubber meeting the road isn't just about money. I spend many, many hours each month doing service within my community - from youth groups, to after-school programs, to community cleanup, etc. As do many of my friends, both conservative and progressive. Trust me, he isn't special. $2 billion is LESS THAN 2% of his net worth!! So, yeah, he's still a scourge, but I'll happily encourage him to distribute the wealth he builds off of the exploitation of average people.
- skybrian 8y agoThis is not company money. It's from his personal fortune.