3 ms·
> The thin-walled tube of circular cross section is a most efficient structural member; it can resist tension or compression, bending, torsion, or the combinati
by forapurpose 8y ago
> The thin-walled tube of circular cross section is a most efficient structural member; it can resist tension or compression, bending, torsion, or the combination of stresses that are exerted on the frame of a vehicle. Although for bending in a particular plane an I-section joist may be more efficient, if bending load can be applied in any plane, then the thin tube is to be preferred. It is for this reason that tubes are used as a strut or compression member in which failure could occur by elastic instability, or bowing. For torsion there is no better section, hence the tube is the typical main transmission shaft of an automobile. The stem of the bamboo plant is an excellent example of the properties of a hollow tube ...
I notice that many current bikes have flattened, non-tubular frame components. Why? Style? New materials? I would assume, knowing little about it, that the tube shape would generally retain its advantages regardless of the material. But perhaps the new material doesn't form tubes well?
- analog31 8y agoI think the answer is aluminum. Note that I'm not an engineer, just a physicist. As I understand it, aluminum has different mechanical properties such as strength to weight ratio, and how it behaves when flexed. So it may require a different design approach to produce a strong but light frame. At the same time, it's easy to hydroform aluminum (blow it out into a mold using high pressure fluid), so you can in fact design a wider variety of shapes at a tolerable cost. And if you're going to engineer the shapes of the tubes, then why not make it look cool too. I own one aluminum bike, relatively low end and not super lightweight... but it does look cool. ;-)
- Someone 8y agoAerodynamics an/or looking aerodynamic and/or distinguishing a brand by showing of what you can build.