3 ms·
I have type 1 diabetes. Insulin wasn't medically available until 1922. Middle-class and alive, or rich and dead? Easy choice to make.
by cperciva 16y ago
I have type 1 diabetes. Insulin wasn't medically available until 1922.
Middle-class and alive, or rich and dead? Easy choice to make.
- tomjen3 16y agoIf we go that way I would have to answer the same thing. So a more interesting question would be, if you didn't have insulin, would your answer change?
- dctoedt 16y agoMy wife and I were talking about something similar while walking the dog this morning. I'd said 60 was the new 40; she said there are still a lot of ways aging can and does kill you, like Alzheimers (her mother died of it). I responded "but they're working on that." Then it dawned on me: These days, an integral part of our mental framework is the dollop of optimism that comes with "they're working on that." I wonder whether people 100 years ago had the same feeling.
- korch 16y agoI have thought about this too. It would be bizarre if all of us thinking "they're working on that" had some kind of society-wide placebo effect to actually cause people to live longer and healthier. Now that's a self-reinforced feedback-cycle I can get behind! I think this way of thinking is rather new, especially considering how many more people believe this than 100 years ago. Back then modernity was in full rising force, so there certainly was a social notion of progress happening to everything on a wide scale, and expectations of Western civilization's eventual achievement of some kind of utopia. But back then they were so limited by what they didn't even know about, so their vision of what modernity would become pales in comparison to what post-modernity actually has been.
- jaspero 16y agoThere is a high probability that you wouldn't have had diabetes in the first place. You would be living a very healthy life and more physical activities and oh yes, healthier non-GM foods. Definitely rich and healthy.
- fhars 16y agoThe probability that a person with type I diabetes would have had type I diabetes (and so died a painful death before 35) if born a hundred years ago is close to one, as type I is inherited. And most food was considerably less healthy and safe then, too, only more scarce and expensive. The problem with GM and processed food is not that it is less healthy than what came before it, but considerably less healthy than what can be produced today, which is the relevant reference point.
- cperciva 16y agoAs fhars points out, type 1 diabetes is not based on diet or lifestyle. There is no reason to think that I wouldn't be diabetic if I were born a century earlier.