4 ms·
> It's as nonsensical to refuse to say where the line is drawn. The rest of my comment is arguing for where I think the qualitative line is... > Are we actual
by mindslight 8y ago
> It's as nonsensical to refuse to say where the line is drawn.
The rest of my comment is arguing for where I think the qualitative line is...
> Are we actually comparing private property and free speech to an unlimited totalitarian state?
Yes. Kim Jong-un himself has some of the best-maintained private property and free speech rights. The field of CS is very comfortable with logical reductions - don't play coy.
> I have no obligation to change their mind. I have no obligation to listen to them. An unwelcome visitor is, in law and right, a trespasser.
Ostensibly you've invited this person into your home for some reason. But if they express a disagreeable view, and they're not already beating their feet, then they're a trespasser? Do you really not see how ridiculously binary and supremely divisive this is?
If you argue and they're invited back, maybe they'll attempt to square their views with civility/commonsense/reality before speaking them again. If you banish them from your life, then you're all but guaranteeing their only friends will be their echo chamber.
> Calling it an "environment of censorship" is hyperbole.
It's accurate - scroll down the responses on the OP and most everybody is cheering it on. We used to make fun of stupid ideas (including general censorship itself). Now we celebrate the pruning of a community because doing so undermines the opposing political ignorance team.