7 ms·
Manhattan DA's office drops more than 3,000 open marijuana cases
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWill the DA’s office work to overturn previous convictions people are currently serving time for? Not meant to undermine this incredibly progressive action.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RIMR 8y agoThe DA cannot do that AFAIK, unless the law changes. The Governor could though.
- Jgrubb 8y ago> this incredibly progressive action ..that never would've happened if Cuomo didn't feel real heat from Cynthia Nixon.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- joshgel 8y agomaybe this is true, maybe not. But polls show he is up 40 points on her[0]. Maybe internal polling shows a different race, but not clear to me from publicly available information that he is feeling "real heat". 0:https://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2018/governor/ny/new_york_governor_democratic_primary-6526.html https://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2018/governor/ny/ne...
- chimeracoder 8y ago> maybe this is true, maybe not. But polls show he is up 40 points on her[0]. Maybe internal polling shows a different race, but not clear to me from publicly available information that he is feeling "real heat". He's trying to run up the score to make it look like he has a mandate. If Nixon gets anything close to what Teachout got four years ago, it'll look bad for his 2020 presidential run.
- bdhess 8y agoHuh? This doesn't have anything to do with Cuomo. This is the New York County (Manhattan) DA, who is himself an elected official.
- aisengard 8y agoPeople are so incredibly desperate to attribute things to people who haven't really done anything. I hate Cuomo too, but I'm not going to descend into nonsense peddling in order to fight him. It only serves to undermine any actual effort of resistance to the man.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> People are so incredibly desperate to attribute things to people who haven't really done anything. I hate Cuomo too, but I'm not going to descend into nonsense peddling in order to fight him. It only serves to undermine any actual effort of resistance to the man. The New York State political machine is incredibly corrupt and interconnected. And Cuomo himself is more powerful and influential at all levels of state government (which includes country-level positions) than any governor since, well, his father. It's really not unreasonable to suspect he had a hand in this. What Cuomo wants, Cuomo gets.
- mancerayder 8y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
- _jal 8y agoAre you asserting Cuomo had some influence on the Manhattan DA's decision? Can you point to a reference?
- Jgrubb 8y agoNo I can't. You're probably right and it's a complete coincidence this is happening the day before the primary.
- mancerayder 8y agoA complete miss. The Mayor and Council have been moving in the direction of ceasing to prosecute lesser crimes for several years. But more importantly the DA is an elected position. Nixon and Cuomo's drama is at the state level and pretty far removed. NYS hasn't legalized cannabis. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_County_District_Attorney https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_County_District_Att...
- ams6110 8y agoThe article states that the DA's action "does not apply to any cases where a defendant was convicted"
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI’m aware of that. I’m curious if further action can be taken. It’s insufficient that these proceedings are dropped when others will continue to serve out sentences for equivalent crimes.
- ams6110 8y agoI do agree. But every day, decisions are made that result in no prosecution of charges against "guilty" people, while others may be in prison serving sentences for the same offense. We don't vacate convictions just because there's an example of another person who was charged but not prosecuted for the same thing. In this case, where the DA has made a blanket pronouncement that the office is not going to prosecute minor drug possession charges, I think there is a stronger argument to apply that retroactively. It seems to me like the right thing to do. But that would need to be done by a judge or perhaps the governor, not the DA. And you'd have to look at each case. There are really very few people serving significant time for simple possession. There's usually large quantities, intent to distribute, weapons or violence, prior offenses, or some other aggravating factors.
- caymanjim 8y agoThat would be a far greater thing. It's good that they're dropping open cases, and good that the city is deprioritizing marijuana offenses in general, and administratively declaring that further charges for minor possession shouldn't be filed. It's barely scratching the surface of justice reform, however. The laws still remain on the books; they're just selectively choosing not to enforce them at the moment. More importantly, they're doing nothing to reverse the thousands (possibly millions) of prior convictions. This is rewarding the people who skipped out on facing prosecution. It's a pragmatic move, and a tiny step in the right direction, but the people most hurt by these insane laws are the ones who did the right thing, faced their charges, and are now sitting in jail or had their lives damaged in ways small and large. They deserve relief far more than the people who managed to avoid getting convicted in the first place.
- kibwen 8y agoI applaud the move. Curious that these cases stretch as far back as 1978, isn't there a statute of limitations for this sort of charge? If so, I would have expected the oldest to have been closed automatically decades ago.
- ucha 8y agoThe statute of limitation applies to the time between the moment the crime was committed and the moment charges are filed. If charges were filled and warrants were issued in 1978 but the "fugitive" was not caught, the statute of limitation won't apply, and the suspect could still be arrested now.
- kibwen 8y agoAha, I didn't realize that statue of limitations only limited charging. Clearly I should have paid more attention in social studies. :P
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I applaud the move. Curious that these cases stretch as far back as 1978, isn't there a statute of limitations for this sort of charge? The statute of limitations runs from the date of the alleged offense to when charges are filed; cases may not be resolved timely after charges are filed, e.g., if a defendant flees and prevents the case from proceeding to trial.
- chrischen 8y agoI believe OP was confusing real life for Grand Theft Auto, where after an amount of time on the run, the cops stop looking for you.
- thaumasiotes 8y agoYou know, I'm pretty sure they have stopped looking for D. B. Cooper.
- jefflovejapan 8y agoFuck you, Cuomo! Swagger jacker.
- swerveonem 8y agoOut of how many open cases total?
- viraptor 8y agoAccording to https://edition-m.cnn.com/2018/05/15/us/manhattan-marijuana-cases/index.html https://edition-m.cnn.com/2018/05/15/us/manhattan-marijuana-... There's been 5,500 cases in 2017, which is apparently 85% decline compared to pre-2014. So 3k is just over half year's worth. But that's combined with stopping the possession prosecution this year.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- danschumann 8y agoI'm from Wisconsin.... I reallly wish someone would get on the ball legalizing it here.
- MichaelApproved 8y agoVote for those who advocate for it. Take your friends and family to the polls with you. If you have extra money, donate to those politicians. Even a $10 donation is helpful.
- ams6110 8y agoOr move to where it's legal, if it's that important to you.
- jhabdas 8y agoThat won't happen because of Chicago. Just drive to CO, fill your trunk with Boulder Bars, and avoid states with harsher penalties on the blissful ride home.
- ComputerGuru 8y agoIllinois just legalized medical marijuana as an alternative to opioid prescriptions.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoIt’s coming. There is no future for prohibition of cannabis.
- dorsdag 8y agoMedical marijuana is a part of Tony Evers official agenda[0], so we definitely have the Democratic party leader advocating for it. I think it would be difficult without some Democratic control of the statehouses, but I think there's a strong fiscal argument to be made as well, so I wouldn't rule it out. [0]https://tonyevers.com/plan/ https://tonyevers.com/plan/ (ctrl-f marijuana)
- kevmo 8y agoThis is likely stemming at least in part from Cynthia Nixon's strong run for the Democratic nomination for governor of New York. She is running to the left of the current governor, Andrew Cuomo (Mario Cuomo's son), and has been making these sorts of outdated drug charges an issue.
- everdev 8y agoI think the majority like the idea but surprised there isn't a financial effort from the prison and associated industries to fight the idea. If it works though, it's a huge win for getting minor offenders out of concrete cages.
- true_religion 8y agoGoverment officials can just ignore financial efforts of private companies, when their reelection campaign is not dependent on that money. If by fighting a private company, you make voters happy then those votes directly gotten can be worth more than any votes that added campaign funds would possibly give.
- forapurpose 8y ago> Goverment officials can just ignore financial efforts of private companies, when their reelection campaign is not dependent on that money. I'm not sure what you mean. Isn't the whole problem that winning elections is heavily dependent on money?
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIn a one party state like NY all you have to do is win the primary.
- forapurpose 8y agoAgreed about one party election districts (statewide or otherwise), but winning the primary still depends on money. It's an interesting question about whether it depends on money more or less than in districts decided by the general election. Many fewer people vote in the primary, but perhaps those people are harder to reach, or perhaps who shows up depends heavily on money (or perhaps something else). Also, I observe that politicians want money for more than their elections. They provide funds from their treasure chest to other politicians and groups. I wonder how much that use of money affects their fundraising and money's influence on them. (I think it seems like a source of corruption, and that money donated for the election should be spent on it or returned.)
- dj43nq 8y agoI wonder what the economic / race demographics of these cases are?
- gnulinux 8y agoI wonder this too. I would want to explore a dataset regarding this. Maybe there should be a startup collecting/exploring data regarding social justice issues. Would be so much easier to make rational policies and convince the public that there exists a problem or vice versa
- IncRnd 8y ago> Vance announced earlier this year that his office would no longer prosecute marijuana smoking and possession cases. People who believe smoking marijuana shouldn't be illegal may agree with this, but the better path seems to be to change the law. Otherwise, we are letting prosecutors decide which laws will get prosecuted. I'm not referring to selective prosecution based upon the merits of a case but a prosecutor who can decide to completely stop prosecuting theft, embezzlement, or murder. The end doesn't justify the means.
- martin1975 8y agogreat move. more money for real crime.
- 24gttghh 8y agoPerhaps you mean: more money to prosecute real crimes?
- martin1975 8y agoyes.
- stephenSinniah 8y agoMeanwhile in Malaysia a 29 year old father to be has been sentenced to hang. https://www.change.org/p/jabatan-peguam-negara-free-muhammad-lukman https://www.change.org/p/jabatan-peguam-negara-free-muhammad...
- jhabdas 8y agoHaven't translated the Malay but since you speak Engris want to give us some details surrounding the case?
- stephenSinniah 8y agoThere is an English translation at the middle of the change.org page.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoWhen I was in Msia I talked with our younger guide about it. He was well aware the risk was not worth it. I was a little surprised at how strictly treated drugs. There is no reason to lay your life on the line for pot. It’s ridiculous to hang someone for that. Too bad people can’t claim it’s even mildly addictive after years and years of saying it isn’t. Punishment and crime obviously don’t fit. But... He chose to have illegal drugs in his country, he wasn’t framed. He knew how illegal it was.
- lolc 8y ago> He knew how illegal it was. Oh yes the police had to arrest him. The judges just apply the law anyway. And the executioners hanging him will be following orders. Looks like the only guy left to be be blamed here is the guy, because he had the choice, didn't he? Let's turn this around! Everyone of those involved knows what that law does. All of them could have walked away and said: "Fuck that law, I'm not enforcing it." But they chose to enforce it. Unjustifiable violence must never be blamed on the victim. Especially if perpetrated by a government.
- 8y ago
- jhabdas 8y ago> It does not apply to any cases where a defendant was convicted, or to more serious charges like selling marijuana. Because selling weed would interfere with tax laws. DA just punting to save money so they can get themselves some new hemp money satchels for future convictions.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoWith all the case dropping one wonders if the court calendars are suddenly freeing up a lot of time to hear other cases. Is anyone tracking that?
- lacker 8y agoI support dropping these cases, but it's a tough incentive that people who simply didn't show up for court are getting their case dropped, whereas people who got convicted will keep their convictions. I guess there is no totally clean way to make this transition and the sooner it happens the better.
- refoundglory 8y agoYou could also void old convictions on these charges. Won't undo the damage but will help.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoYou’re absolutely right to say that in an ideal world that would be a better option. But I can also see that freeing convicts from the prisons may be perceived way more negatively than this. Even though semantically there’s 0 difference.
- JakeKalstad 8y agoNow if we can get Larry Sharpe elected this year we may actually be able to have some pride in how our state is being administered.